Help! Watch disaster...advice appreciated
Help! Watch disaster...advice appreciated
Author
Discussion

crashS2K

Original Poster:

107 posts

285 months

Wednesday 12th December 2012
quotequote all
So following on from a recent thread as to suitable present for wife to mark occassion of birth of second child / christmas I ordered a lovely Longines Dolce Vita through Goldsmiths. Got a decent discount on it too through work scheme too which was an added bonus.

My wife took it to a local jewellers to have the bracelet adjusted. I get a call at work yesterday from her which is where it all starts to go a bit pear-shaped.

Apparently, the watch stopped working and the jeweller took the back off to check the battery and now the second hand has come off and is now rattling around inside the face!

I checked the watch over when I got home last night and there are light scratches on the side of the case and a small gouge on the front near the top right lug where it attaches to the bracelet.

He has offered to get the watch hand reattached but didn't say anything about the damage to the watch itself.

This all feels rather fishy to me and it feels like the jeweller either dropped / damaged the watch to the extent that the hand came off and then has tried to cover his tracks only to find he couldn't re-attach the hand when he took the back off.

I'm inclined to pursue him to replace the watch for a brand new one. I doubt Goldsmiths will offer to replace given there is clear damage to the watch and it's not a manufacturing defect.

Clearly wife is distraught given the sentimental value of the present and that she chose the jeweller...

Advice - options appreciated. Particularly any pointers as to how to frame discussion with him at the weekend. Can I threaten to take him to small claims?

clockworks

7,818 posts

176 months

Wednesday 12th December 2012
quotequote all
Sounds like the watch slipped and fell off the bench while the "jeweller" was trying to remove the bracelet/links.

If the watch was basically unworn, I'd be chasing them for a new watch. They should have liability insurance to cover this kind of thing.

mikeveal

5,141 posts

281 months

Wednesday 12th December 2012
quotequote all
Yep, letter to the jeweller stating that you hold him liable for the damage to the watch and that as he has damaged the case of the (brand new) watch that you require a replacement. Enclose an invoice for the replacement value and make it clear how long the jeweller has to pay. I'd add a one liner that you are prepared to accept a new replacement watch directly from the jeweller. At this point he old watch of course becomes the property of the jeweller.

Personally, I'd hand deliver the letter, making it clear that you understand that as a reputable co. the jeweller will obviously be keen to make good on their error. You merely wish to make it clear in writing to the jeweller what you hold them liable for and what you expect them to do about it.

Mods... Move to Speed Plod Law? I think the OP will get better advice there.

Justayellowbadge

37,057 posts

273 months

Wednesday 12th December 2012
quotequote all
Does this 'Jeweller' also cut keys and mend shoes?

Fitz666

692 posts

173 months

Thursday 13th December 2012
quotequote all
We had something similar with exactly the same watch but 10 years ago.

It was Goldsmiths and they replaced the watch without question, cracking sevice.

Adrian W

15,623 posts

259 months

Thursday 13th December 2012
quotequote all
Justayellowbadge said:
Does this 'Jeweller' also cut keys and mend shoes?
My thoughts exactly

crashS2K

Original Poster:

107 posts

285 months

Thursday 13th December 2012
quotequote all
Not a timpsons but a 'reputable' local jewellers that doesn't cut keys or mend shoes!

hilly10

7,543 posts

259 months

Thursday 13th December 2012
quotequote all
crashS2K said:
Not a timpsons but a 'reputable' local jewellers that doesn't cut keys or mend shoes!
As said put it in writing should not be a problem if they are reputable. If they do not respond, name and shame

mikeveal

5,141 posts

281 months

Tuesday 18th December 2012
quotequote all
Fitz666 said:
We had something similar with exactly the same watch but 10 years ago.

It was Goldsmiths and they replaced the watch without question, cracking sevice.
We had something similar with my wife's Tissot 10 years ago.

It was Goldsmiths and they refused to accept liability, awful sevice.