Daytona or Navitimer?
Discussion
As per the thread title really - I came across two watches today, both of which I'm very interested in;
1) Rolex Daytona - bi-metal, white diamond dial, 2004, B&P, just been serviced.
Watch is at a jewellers (non Rolex AD that seems to always have several pre-owned Rolex for sale)
The watch is up at £8950 (do you consider this good value?) and I was told that a new one would cost £12600
2) Breitling Navitimer Blue Sky.
I saw this watch in the news section of the current 'Watchworld' magazine.
It's a limited edition to celebrate 60 years of the Navitimer (only 500 to be made), with a blue dial and a sapphire crystal case-back.
Available on a bracelet for £7290 or a blue croc strap for £6770
I enquired about this watch at my local AD and they have one on order - expected in February.
I haven't seen the Navitimer Blue Sky for real yet but the AD showed me a Navitimer World which has a blue dial, but to my eyes it didn't look very blue
(it's a very subtle shade).
So now I'm mulling them both over and wondering where my money would be best placed.
Over say the next 5 years, which one does the PH fraternity consider to be the best investment?
I know that Rolex bi-metal doesn't hold it's value as well as the steel versions but with this watch now being 8 years old I'm hoping it will have done most of it's depreciating. Now that Rolex has become sponsors of F1, what effect, if any, might this have on residuals and new prices?
I'm also aware that Breitling loose shed loads as soon as you walk out of the shop but might it be a different case with a Navitimer LE which I'm hoping might one day become quite collectable?
I'm pretty sure I will gain a lot of pleasure from owning either watch, but the purchase will also be what I hope to be an investment, so I'm concerned about residual value moving forward.
So I throw it open to the sound advice from the watch experts on this forum.
TIA
1) Rolex Daytona - bi-metal, white diamond dial, 2004, B&P, just been serviced.
Watch is at a jewellers (non Rolex AD that seems to always have several pre-owned Rolex for sale)
The watch is up at £8950 (do you consider this good value?) and I was told that a new one would cost £12600
2) Breitling Navitimer Blue Sky.
I saw this watch in the news section of the current 'Watchworld' magazine.
It's a limited edition to celebrate 60 years of the Navitimer (only 500 to be made), with a blue dial and a sapphire crystal case-back.
Available on a bracelet for £7290 or a blue croc strap for £6770
I enquired about this watch at my local AD and they have one on order - expected in February.
I haven't seen the Navitimer Blue Sky for real yet but the AD showed me a Navitimer World which has a blue dial, but to my eyes it didn't look very blue
(it's a very subtle shade).
So now I'm mulling them both over and wondering where my money would be best placed.
Over say the next 5 years, which one does the PH fraternity consider to be the best investment?
I know that Rolex bi-metal doesn't hold it's value as well as the steel versions but with this watch now being 8 years old I'm hoping it will have done most of it's depreciating. Now that Rolex has become sponsors of F1, what effect, if any, might this have on residuals and new prices?
I'm also aware that Breitling loose shed loads as soon as you walk out of the shop but might it be a different case with a Navitimer LE which I'm hoping might one day become quite collectable?
I'm pretty sure I will gain a lot of pleasure from owning either watch, but the purchase will also be what I hope to be an investment, so I'm concerned about residual value moving forward.
So I throw it open to the sound advice from the watch experts on this forum.
TIA
Pictures? I like traditional Navitimers, but fear this may be at the less tasteful end of the range (ETA actually I found some pictures and it's ok, I think - http://professionalwatches.com/2012/10/breitling_n... ).
Rolexs (even Daytonas) don't really appeal on the whole, but I suspect you'd find it a safer bet financially, if you're worried about potential resale value.
On reflection, I'd take the Breitling, but I suspect I might be the only one
M.
Rolexs (even Daytonas) don't really appeal on the whole, but I suspect you'd find it a safer bet financially, if you're worried about potential resale value.
On reflection, I'd take the Breitling, but I suspect I might be the only one

M.
Edited by marcosgt on Monday 17th December 18:40
Adam B said:
Daytona will be a better bet IMHO but then I am not a fan of Breitlings - but for your budget why not get a new S/S and skip the bi-metal/diamond chintz? Will hold value better and you will have the pleasure of being the first owner which you might prefer.
Hi Adam - I already have a s/s one and have been looking for a while for something bi-metal with diamonds.I came very close to getting a Chronomat 44.
The 116523 I viewed today fit's the bill.
I've just seen an identical watch on Chrono24 for £6000 - the prices seem all over the place.
Ballistic said:
Hi Adam - I already have a s/s one and have been looking for a while for something bi-metal with diamonds.
I came very close to getting a Chronomat 44.
The 116523 I viewed today fit's the bill.
I've just seen an identical watch on Chrono24 for £6000 - the prices seem all over the place.
Fair enough, sounds like the Daytona is exactly what you are after (but the Navi doesn't!) - do you really want 2 or will you sell the S/S? Nice problem to have either way.I came very close to getting a Chronomat 44.
The 116523 I viewed today fit's the bill.
I've just seen an identical watch on Chrono24 for £6000 - the prices seem all over the place.
Adam B said:
Fair enough, sounds like the Daytona is exactly what you are after (but the Navi doesn't!) - do you really want 2 or will you sell the S/S? Nice problem to have either way.
I'm very happy with the s/s and am planning on keeping it for the long haul - I can't see myself losing any money on it.My thoughts are that the bi-metal will compliment it nicely, but from doing some research on the prices I'm not convinced that some of them have finished depreciating yet.
Ballistic said:
Adam B said:
Fair enough, sounds like the Daytona is exactly what you are after (but the Navi doesn't!) - do you really want 2 or will you sell the S/S? Nice problem to have either way.
I'm very happy with the s/s and am planning on keeping it for the long haul - I can't see myself losing any money on it.My thoughts are that the bi-metal will compliment it nicely, but from doing some research on the prices I'm not convinced that some of them have finished depreciating yet.
£8950 for a 2004 steel and gold Daytona is hugely overpriced.
You have mail...
D
raptor600 said:
Daytona over a Breitling every single day of the week.
I went and had a look at the Daytona in question and I can't understand that thinking at all! 
Personally, whilst this Navitimer's a classic icon of watch design, the bi-metal Daytona with the diamond dial looks like an object lesson in tasteless bling to me...
Your mileage may vary and I KNOW everyone will say the Daytona will hold its value better, but really? You'd rather wear that than the Navitimer (which looks really rather classic to me)?
M.
Edited by marcosgt on Tuesday 18th December 10:42
marcosgt said:
raptor600 said:
Daytona over a Breitling every single day of the week.
I went and had a look at the Daytona in question and I can't understand that thinking at all! 
Personally, whilst this Navitimer's a classic icon of watch design, the bi-metal Daytona with the diamond dial looks like an object lesson in tasteless bling to me...
Your mileage may vary and I KNOW everyone will say the Daytona will hold its value better, but really? You'd rather wear that than the Navitimer (which looks really rather classic to me)?
M.
Edited by marcosgt on Tuesday 18th December 10:42

I would not get a 2 tone - but a SS with white or black face and diamond markers I would still prefer to the Navitimer if I had to choose one

Riff Raff said:
el stovey said:
Not tasteless enough. How about a mother of pearl dial (with diamonds)?Gassing Station | Watches | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff






