Watch winders - why so bad? :(
Watch winders - why so bad? :(
Author
Discussion

tvrforever

Original Poster:

3,196 posts

296 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
So I've current got 2 automatic watch winders :-

1. The Rapport dual winder in Ebony, and polished aluminium (W622) http://www.rapportlondon.com/windersDouble_W262.ht...

It looks beautiful and fits & winds my Omega & Monaco & Seiko watches nicely (obviously only 2 at a time), HOWEVER in the 3years I've had it it's had 3 motors replaced due to failures (2 at the factory and the 3rd they sent me to do).

Sadly however the bigger issue appears to be noise, simply the 'cups' wear on their rollers and make grinding & squeaking loud noises, yes silicon lube fixes for a few weeks but this involves dismantling the unit.

Their service has been good, but for something that cost £600+ this just isn't on and good enough frown Very disappointed by one of the supposed market leaders.

2. The Beco Boxy Modular http://www.amazon.co.uk/Boxy-Winder-Carbon-Stackin...

Much cheaper, thus expectations were lower. It's been ok, reasonably quiet, and reliable.

However, and it's a big however, it fails to be compatible with winding my Seiko reliably, and my Monaco doesn't fit in it.



Like most people I suspect, we keep our nicer watches in our bedroom so quiet is a requirement - as frankly is reliability.

So - does anybody have any recommendations? I'm looking for either a dual or quad winder that is quiet, has to look nice, not cost the earth and work?

My other annoyance is that very very very few shops seem to even know about winders, let alone stock a selection so that you can look at them / try them - any recommendations?

andy tims

5,606 posts

277 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
tvrforever said:
So - does anybody have any recommendations?
Don't bother.

Keep your watches out of site from burglars & just wind & set the date when you want to wear one.

geezerbutler

561 posts

173 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
I have a Wolf Designs 3 watch winder. Seems good, but have only had for a few weeks so no idea how reliable it will prove to be. Runs silent at the moment though.

TeaNoSugar

1,483 posts

196 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
Just out of interest I was wondering if anyone knows whether its better for an automatic watch movement to be kept going on a winder, or just left to stop after 36/48hrs etc., and then get manually re-set again whenever its worn (as per Andy Tims' recommendations)?

Is there any long term benefit or damage from either approach?

andy tims

5,606 posts

277 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
TeaNoSugar said:
Just out of interest I was wondering if anyone knows whether its better for an automatic watch movement to be kept going on a winder, or just left to stop after 36/48hrs etc., and then get manually re-set again whenever its worn (as per Andy Tims' recommendations)?

Is there any long term benefit or damage from either approach?
An often asked question, to which there is no definitive answer to my knowledge.

My gut feel is that I do less damage hand winding each watch every so often, compared with the wear & tear of keeping watches running 24/7

Tom_C76

1,923 posts

219 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
TeaNoSugar said:
Just out of interest I was wondering if anyone knows whether its better for an automatic watch movement to be kept going on a winder, or just left to stop after 36/48hrs etc., and then get manually re-set again whenever its worn (as per Andy Tims' recommendations)?

Is there any long term benefit or damage from either approach?
When I bought my TAG automatic I was told there was no harm in letting it stop as modern watches are lubricated with stuff that won't gunge them up. Older lubricants needed to be kept moving hence the need for winders.

As it is, I only have one decent watch so it's not yet had a chance to stop...

Chris99

354 posts

191 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
I bought a 2 watch winder about 4 months ago:

http://watch-winder.co.uk/Black-Wood-Double-Watch-...

My Seamaster and Bremont MBII both fit with no problem and so far it's been quiet and reliable.


Gixer

4,463 posts

279 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
TeaNoSugar said:
Just out of interest I was wondering if anyone knows whether its better for an automatic watch movement to be kept going on a winder, or just left to stop after 36/48hrs etc., and then get manually re-set again whenever its worn (as per Andy Tims' recommendations)?

Is there any long term benefit or damage from either approach?
Interesting question and one I've asked before.

I have a winder but don't leave watches on it all the time. I knew I would be wearing a watch a lot through December due to lots of social events etc on the run up to Christmas so when I wasn't wearing it I put it on the winder so it was ready to put on. Now Christmas and new years is behind us, I've let the watch run down and will set it the next time I wear it.

tvrforever

Original Poster:

3,196 posts

296 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
Anybody tried one of these for Seiko Kinetics :-
http://www.kinetic-repairs.co.uk/Kinetic-Charger.h...
http://youtu.be/YKmWhmMEhAE

Looks like there are some well know issues with winders not working with Seiko as the winders are typically 'too gentle', this modified winder looks to resolve that smile