Replicas - What's your opinion on them?
Replicas - What's your opinion on them?
TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED
Author
Discussion

fwaggie

Original Poster:

1,644 posts

231 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
Leaving out the legality of them for a second, what's your view on them?

Not quality wise, but do you think

  • They are a way of getting a very nicely finished mechanical watch that is (if you choose the right one) well made and mechanically fascinating?
  • They are all made to rip people off thinking they're buying the "real thing"?
  • They are depriving the genuine manufacturers of $$$$ profit?

Personally I'm the first. I love the looks of a nice watch, am fascinated with the mechanical movements, don't really care about the badge on the front and think the good reps look better than anything genuine you can get for the same price.

marcosgt

11,506 posts

207 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
You mean FAKES?

M.

Dominic H

3,289 posts

263 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all

RDMcG

20,920 posts

238 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
They don't bother me though the quality is hugely variable. Personally I prefer for myself the feeling of knowing its the real thing and would not want one for that reason. If you like one,buy one.

andy_s

19,857 posts

290 months

ofcorsa

3,546 posts

274 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
Are you talking about straight up fakes or budget models that look similar to premium brands?

Odie

4,187 posts

213 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
Homages - Yes
Replicas ie Fakes - No

Whats the difference?

Homages are made by reputable companies and put their own name on them (Sekonda, Steinhart etc).
Replicas are just trying to be something they arent.

carter711

1,849 posts

229 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
Fake watches are an interesting little hobby for me and are useful for mucking about with.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
OP do you own an MR2 Ferrari?

andy tims

5,606 posts

277 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all

Not this st AGAIN please



Edited by andy tims on Monday 7th January 14:43

Spice_Weasel

2,369 posts

284 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
Stuart, where's your STOP sign?

fwaggie

Original Poster:

1,644 posts

231 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
ofcorsa: "Are you talking about straight up fakes or budget models that look similar to premium brands?"

I've looked around (Ebay and some jewellers) and the watches upto a couple of hundred quid don't interest me beyond those I already have. There's plenty of bling tat, but to me it looks like that price range of similar budget models is more aimed at younger fashion conscious people. There's very little (read: nothing I can find) that looks really desirable (IMO), classical and has a manual movement.

PSBuckshot: "OP do you own an MR2 Ferrari?"

No. And I have no problem at all if anyone wants an MR2 Ferrari, or Cortina-Royce. Why should I? If I personally don't like something, no one is forcing me to buy / own it.

Andy tims & Spice Weasel: I checked through 10 pages of topic titles, nothing mentioned about reps at all, so this certainly isn't a hotly debated subject.

grumbledoak

32,571 posts

264 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
Fake but label says "Rolex Submariner"? No.

Near identical "bks Submarine"? Yes, if you like it.

andy_s

19,857 posts

290 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
fwaggie said:
Andy tims & Spice Weasel: I checked through 10 pages of topic titles, nothing mentioned about reps at all, so this certainly isn't a hotly debated subject.
It's not an oft mentioned subject, but usually ends up hotly debated.

For a few hundred quid you can go either fake, homage or mainstream. At that price point (did you see the thread I linked to?) I would go for someone like Steinhart or Timefactors in the homage corner and Seiko in the mainstream corner.

fwaggie

Original Poster:

1,644 posts

231 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
andy_s said:
It's not an oft mentioned subject, but usually ends up hotly debated.

For a few hundred quid you can go either fake, homage or mainstream. At that price point (did you see the thread I linked to?) I would go for someone like Steinhart or Timefactors in the homage corner and Seiko in the mainstream corner.
Thanks Andy.

I've had a read of that dissection of that fake, enjoyable.

In the two rep forums I've found, the most enjoyable parts are reading posts from the watch repairers. These are very skilled guys, and reading about their dissection and comparison of all the different movements, and also learning how all these things work. (e.g., the mechanism to convert the two way movement of the auto-winder to unidirectional rotation - great!)

The fact that the supply of swiss ETA movements are drying up now Swatch has stopped supplying them, and more often than not a "Swiss 7750" may either be an old one in dire need of a full service ASAP or a good new one, so the asian 7750s are now a better bet overall.

I've got a nice Seiko on now, american model, plus three Citizen chronos at home, one again imported.

Honestly I wouldn't care if they didn't have the copied name on them, but as I said, I must have spend 6~10 hours looking through EBay for anything that I find equally attractive and there's nothing other than the same as what I have.

I'll have a look at those TZs, never let it be said I'm not open to suggestions smile

Du1point8

22,984 posts

223 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
Say what you want (this thread will be locked soon)...

Replica is a rip off of the genuine article, it often provides money to dubious people and why would you do it anyway?

If you want an Omega/Rolex, then say up and buy one... dont buy a copy and pretend its an Omega/Rolex, even worse is telling people you have a fake Omega, as it brings up the topic of why buy it?

Its not an Omega/Rolex, its a copy no matter how good, you are trying to fool people into thinking you have one.

Best excuse I hear is that it save on wear and tear of a real one... Well no it doesn't, Im a clumsy mofo and my Omega has lasted through it all, dropping it, falling over, whacking it into things and spilling crap on it... it soaks it up and then some without a scratch, so that argument/excuse is a moot point.

If you want something that looks like an Omega/Rolex then buy a steinhart, its got fantastic mechanicals and is not pretending to be an Omega/Rolex much.

carter711

1,849 posts

229 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
Even worse than telling people you have a fake Omega is telling people you've got a real Omega when it's fake.

I've got a fake watch because it is worry free. If it gets wrecked, lost or stolen it's no biggie, I love the design of it and it's 98% of the original for, let me work this out..... 2% of the the cost of the original. Yes it's fake and I didn't wear it for ages because of it but then I thought what the hell, I like it and it's not that I don't care what anyone thinks of me else because it is literally impossible to do so but lets just say I'm not worried.

I have a premium genuine watch too that's been sent back to its maker as it was losing a lot of time, thankfully just under warranty. I won't get it back for 2 months! I was thinking of selling it as a result but I quite miss it now and am looking forward to wearing it again.

andy tims

5,606 posts

277 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
fwaggie said:
Andy tims & Spice Weasel: I checked through 10 pages of topic titles, nothing mentioned about reps at all, so this certainly isn't a hotly debated subject.
10 pages is only just over a months worth. Here is the last thread - ran to 8 pages.

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

Since you persist. My opinion is that whilst Homages are fine, replicas are fakes generally bought by really sad people who want to try to big themselves up.

Like the look of a Panerai or Submariner but can't afford the real thing? Buy a Marina Militare or a Steinhart etc. don't buy a fake.



Edited by andy tims on Monday 7th January 17:29

Du1point8

22,984 posts

223 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
carter711 said:
Even worse than telling people you have a fake Omega is telling people you've got a real Omega when it's fake.

I've got a fake watch because it is worry free. If it gets wrecked, lost or stolen it's no biggie, I love the design of it and it's 98% of the original for, let me work this out..... 2% of the the cost of the original. Yes it's fake and I didn't wear it for ages because of it but then I thought what the hell, I like it and it's not that I don't care what anyone thinks of me else because it is literally impossible to do so but lets just say I'm not worried.

I have a premium genuine watch too that's been sent back to its maker as it was losing a lot of time, thankfully just under warranty. I won't get it back for 2 months! I was thinking of selling it as a result but I quite miss it now and am looking forward to wearing it again.
You heard of the word insurance?

I have that and dont worry about my watches if it does get lost/stolen/damaged, its all covered.

Again people like you try and justify it... you can't... It matters not if you tell people its fake (I doubt you do this), but 99% of people you leave thinking its a real one, so pretending you have an expensive watch.

Why not go for a homage watch?

carter711

1,849 posts

229 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
Du1point8 said:
You heard of the word insurance?

I have that and dont worry about my watches if it does get lost/stolen/damaged, its all covered.

Again people like you try and justify it... you can't... It matters not if you tell people its fake (I doubt you do this), but 99% of people you leave thinking its a real one, so pretending you have an expensive watch.

Why not go for a homage watch?
You are the best, and I am a scumbag. smile
TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED