Should I ??
Author
Discussion

Windowlicker

Original Poster:

12 posts

175 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
Hi there,

I am sort of thinking out loud, and I guess hoping for some opinions from any knowledgeable and informed members on the forum .

I have a 16600 SD which I treated myself to for my 40 th, now don't get me wrong , it is a lovely thing, I chose it specifically because it didn't have the cyclops which I dislike with a passion, and because it was a bit less (dare I say ) common than the sub.
At the time of buying I looked at various other watches, and the one I nearly bought, which I really liked, was the JLC Mc diver chrono titanium.

http://www.blowers-jewellers.co.uk/titanium_jaeger...

So my option is to trade the SD in plus a bit of cash to make the change.

My head said SD , which was the almost obvious choice "upgrade "over the SM full size auto I had worn daily for the last 8 years, but my heart wanted to buy the JLC.

Rightly or wrongly I was swayed by the salespersons suggestion the SD would retain it's value and maybe even appreciate in value, though this was irrelevant as it wasn't an investment for me, also swmbo was also liking the SD more so than the JLC , and made her opinion known!.

So , I ended up buying it, and as I say I do like it, but am constantly looking for a reason to change it!!

Either I am annoyed at myself for my obvious choice purchase, or there are little things niggling subconsciously , that is making me look elsewhere.

So has anyone any experience of the JLC in question, or just opinions, positive or negative to throw into the mix??

Many thanks, Nick


Edited by Windowlicker on Monday 7th January 19:44


Edited by Windowlicker on Monday 7th January 19:54

Vvroom

1,170 posts

221 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
Are you fond of 'regret'?

Windowlicker

Original Poster:

12 posts

175 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
Vvroom said:
Are you fond of 'regret'?
Is that a suggestion that I will end up in the same boat with the JLC ?

Cheers.

Vvroom

1,170 posts

221 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
Windowlicker said:
Vvroom said:
Are you fond of 'regret'?
Is that a suggestion that I will end up in the same boat with the JLC ?

Cheers.
I was being flippant, mostly. I love JLCs, but this one does nothing for me. I was referring to the SD being an iconic piece and one that I can imagine being easily missed if lost from a collection- I'd never part with my Sub, for eg.

Having re read your post, seems you were persuaded to get the SD. If you want a change- do it. I don't expect you'd lose the shirt on your back with that JLC, so you could always trade up/down the next time you fancy a change without it hurting too much.

Tazza

160 posts

268 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
It is always a personal choice. FWIW I would go for almost any JLC over any Rolex, but that is my taste and it's you that will be wearing it. That said, that isn't my favourite JLC. Some of the other master compressors are nicer. As an alternative, try to look at an IWC Aquatimer (if you can get an old titanium one - 3536 I think) they are lovely. I have a JLC master calendar (from Dom H) and it is a delight. I'd only think of changing it for a different JLC.

Declaration of interest, I have 2 old rolexes and I never wear them because they do absolutely nothing for me (1950's and 1960's Oysters from my Grandfather and my dad) I'd not have the heart to get rid of them for the sentimental value, but even despite that, they are in a drawer and wouldn't get a look in next to my Aquatimer, the JLC and my Sinn (EZM 2B).

If you can, go and look at the JLC and go with what you feel is right. Have no worries that the JLC is in any way inferior to the others you list though! I confess, I never understand buying an expensive watch with an eye to what you might sell it for. I'd only buy a watch I really wanted and would want to keep. Again, however, that is what I do and not supposed to be judgemental of anyone else.

Windowlicker

Original Poster:

12 posts

175 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
Vvroom said:
I was being flippant, mostly. I love JLCs, but this one does nothing for me. I was referring to the SD being an iconic piece and one that I can imagine being easily missed if lost from a collection- I'd never part with my Sub, for eg.

Having re read your post, seems you were persuaded to get the SD. If you want a change- do it. I don't expect you'd lose the shirt on your back with that JLC, so you could always trade up/down the next time you fancy a change without it hurting too much.
I know what you mean I think with regards the model of JLC , I guess I think I have yet to to allow myself to go away from the metal sports watch designs, I suppose I have always had this bizarre idea that leather strapped watches, and I guess the smarter watches are for someone other than me, either age related or someone who dresses smarter than me, as in , wears a suit daily for example.
Me and suits connect not even once a year, dependent on weddings/funerals.

Though something else JLC has made me look more than once, and I think initially it was the slightly aged look to the strap and the relatively clean looking face.
http://www.blowers-jewellers.co.uk/gents_steel_jae...
Not 100% on the world time bit at the bottom, but other than that I do really like it.

Windowlicker

Original Poster:

12 posts

175 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
Tazza said:
It is always a personal choice. FWIW I would go for almost any JLC over any Rolex, but that is my taste and it's you that will be wearing it. That said, that isn't my favourite JLC. Some of the other master compressors are nicer. As an alternative, try to look at an IWC Aquatimer (if you can get an old titanium one - 3536 I think) they are lovely. I have a JLC master calendar (from Dom H) and it is a delight. I'd only think of changing it for a different JLC.

Declaration of interest, I have 2 old rolexes and I never wear them because they do absolutely nothing for me (1950's and 1960's Oysters from my Grandfather and my dad) I'd not have the heart to get rid of them for the sentimental value, but even despite that, they are in a drawer and wouldn't get a look in next to my Aquatimer, the JLC and my Sinn (EZM 2B).

If you can, go and look at the JLC and go with what you feel is right. Have no worries that the JLC is in any way inferior to the others you list though! I confess, I never understand buying an expensive watch with an eye to what you might sell it for. I'd only buy a watch I really wanted and would want to keep. Again, however, that is what I do and not supposed to be judgemental of anyone else.
Thanks for the response,

I suppose due to my lack of knowledge with regards the hierarchy and history related to the mass of brands out there, when looking to replace my omega I went for the other biggie if that makes sense, and went with something I was au fait with.

Bit Like people still pay a premium for a Goretex waterproof garment when there are many other comparable fabrics available, but as they weren't aware of the others due to less marketing , product placement etc, they dare not spend their hard earned on an unknown quantity.

I have learnt more in the last 8 months from perusing this site and TZ , and at least accepted that Rolex are only mid level eek watches in the overall scheme of things.
I suppose I now lust after something that most will not be au fait with, unless it is something they have a passion for too.

Cheers, Nick

andy tims

5,606 posts

277 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
I have this





so I like the Master Compressor divers a lot, but I would NOT PX a 16600 SD for one.

Windowlicker

Original Poster:

12 posts

175 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
andy tims said:
I have this





so I like the Master Compressor divers a lot, but I would NOT PX a 16600 SD for one.
Hi andy,

That is a stunning watch, I had actually looked at a similar one, and much as I liked the look/feel of the bracelet, and black bezel etc, I was a bit concerned about the rubber coated bracelet marking easily , so was drawn more to the Ti one,on the basis that if marked I could simply scotch pad the bracelet , and freshen it up as and when needs be.

The other point you made , as in, not Px ing the SD for one, could you say why that would be please?

I know , having seen other posts from yourself, that you have many amazing pieces, and fine taste, so I am curious as to what you think?

Thanks, nick.

geezerbutler

561 posts

173 months

Monday 7th January 2013
quotequote all
I prefer the Navy Seals compressor and you can pick one up for less than 6K on Jura Watches

andy tims

5,606 posts

277 months

Tuesday 8th January 2013
quotequote all
Windowlicker said:
Hi andy,

That is a stunning watch, I had actually looked at a similar one, and much as I liked the look/feel of the bracelet, and black bezel etc, I was a bit concerned about the rubber coated bracelet marking easily , so was drawn more to the Ti one,on the basis that if marked I could simply scotch pad the bracelet , and freshen it up as and when needs be.
So far so good on the bracelet with regards to marking, but I don't wear the watch when I'm doing any manual tasks & it's worn in "rotation" with my other pieces rather than daily. The watch also works well on other straps, so the bracelet is only one option.

Windowlicker said:
The other point you made , as in, not Px ing the SD for one, could you say why that would be please?

I know , having seen other posts from yourself, that you have many amazing pieces, and fine taste, so I am curious as to what you think?

Thanks, nick.
I just think the 16600 is the last really nice Rolex made. I only sold mine to buy my 1665 and I just wouldn't want to be without a Sea Dweller in my collection. It's just such a perfect watch IMHO.