Beauty or the beast? Chrono help
Beauty or the beast? Chrono help
Author
Discussion

yeti

Original Poster:

10,704 posts

306 months

Wednesday 9th January 2013
quotequote all
Have shortlisted 2 possible chonographs; the Breguet Type XXI or the Zenith Stratos Striking 10th. Have a good few chronos (Daytona, Speedy, JLC AMVOX and Reverso, classic and modern Heuer)

The Breguet is a thing of beauty, has a rare use Lemania movement and an interesting chronograph where the seconds and minutes are on the same centre pinion. I also like the Flyback function and the day/night indicator. Lovely brand with storied history, but does the Lemania movement preclude it from being a true Breguet? They are owned by the same parent company.

The Zenith is a bit big and hardly exudes class although s very cool (Felix B wore one on the space jump), and I had made the decision to live with it before finding a Breguet at the right money. But the striking 10th complication (chrono second hand circulates the dial once every 10secs rather than every 60secs) coupled with the Flyback makes this watch extremely special; I can't think of another mechanical chronograph at this price point with this degree of complexity and reliability. The Zenith is also completely in house and has an exhibition back, which is great as the EP is a beautiful movement.

The Zenith is new at 4k, almost half price, the Bregust is preowned at the same money so outlay is not a concern.

Thoughts? confused

I genuinely am struggling to make up my mind and had all but committed to the Stratos before finding a Breguet at that money.

andy_s

19,857 posts

290 months

Wednesday 9th January 2013
quotequote all
Wow, good dilemma...and a few of the top modern chronographs as you detail. Well chosen.

Lemania (or Nouvelle Lemania) were subsumed into Breguet as you know, but at this time Breguet was only a vestigial reminant of its pre-quartz self. It needed its own 'in-house' production - the way Hayek did this was to bring Lemania across the SWATCH group and into Breguet to produce movements for them, (in a nutshell), so as to put them back as a main player on the horological map. In reality, Lemania was predominantly a movement manufacturer that had formerly been associated with Heuer during its transition, Omega and Tissot in SSIH group for fifty years before that and had provided, and still does, ebauches for Patek, albeit heavily worked. No lightweight manufacturer. So, really the question of whether it is in-house in the truest sense is perhaps debatable, but I think only if you want to be pedantic; it's as good as, technically, and is far from being the case where manufacturers modify ETA (or have ETA modify) movements and redesignates as their own.
Let's not forget that Breguet was powered by Valjoux, (as were Rolex etc), back in the days of the old type XX anyway, which itself was also made by Dodane, Airain, Auricoste and others - even the case was Mathey-Tissot....so as you see, nothing is so straightforward!!

The movement itslf is based on the Lemania 134x series, (but you have to go back a few iterations really), which was made in 1971, anything after that had a focus on ease of production and cheapness, hence the anachronistic 5100. In its original form the 134x (or omega cal. 1040), was integrated, terrace construction, horizontal clutch and sliding cam operated, similarly to the Omega cal. 861 manual which is in turn based on the venerable cal. 321 (or Lemania 2220/1873). So, no column wheel or vertical clutch, but a great movement anyway, especially as the fly-back adds another honest dimension on top I think.

As for the 'complication' of the central pinion chronograph minute hand, well, I think it's the best way to read a chronograph, for three reasons; 1) You have maximum resolution as you have no subdial but the whole dial to read from 2) You have an intuitive scale - i.e. the same as the watch, so can judge quickly the time by just seeing the hand position 3) you do not need to reference the hour counter for lengthy timings to see whether you are counting 0-30mins or 30-60mins. All chronographs should be like this imo... smile


The Zenith is an interesting one, unfortunately I'm not that au fait with Zenith, indeed it's a big hole for me at the moment. I would just make a few observations though. Take a look at past Zeniths and you'll see how the subdial overlap doesn't affect accurate indication of minutes, whereas the new Zeniths have swapped subdial overlap so now you can't read the minute indication accurately at certain times. To me this is a big gaffe, and although isn't in the spirit of higher-ended watches to ultimately be practical, it would niggle me personally. In the case of the Stratos 1/10th the dial overlap has a similar problem, only with what I presume are the chrono seconds at 3 o'clock. I think they are optimistic having a 60min scale also, in reality I could see this being intuitive but difficult to be accurate.

The movement needs no introduction, I'm sure you've seen the ins and outs, but there's a place for an El Primero in every chronograph collection, without a doubt a fascinating, robust and clssically made movement, updated for fly-back and tenth second timing in this case, which is a fascinating feature which more than makes up for my petty snipes earlier perhaps. A very interesting watch, movement and feature, very nicely executed (the non-Stratos for me though) and surely a bargain when compared to other in-house complicated high end chronographs.

Nice choice - good luck!!



yeti

Original Poster:

10,704 posts

306 months

Wednesday 9th January 2013
quotequote all
Thanks - very nice information on the Breguet and its relationship with Lemania - not a brand I know much about, my Zenith knowledge is better! If the biggest problem with the Zenith is dial overlap, I can live with that I think. Looking closely at the dial, the minute and second counter have the advantage of both being on the same scale(i.e. 0-60; therefore they share the indexes of the 60 minute scale.

It is just whether that case size of the Zenith is too big. I have a Radiomir 8 Days which is collossal at 45mm... and the Zenith is 45.5mm! Today I'm wearing a TAG Monza Cal 36 which is tiny by comparison and probaly looks about right.

My feeling is probably to pounce on the Zenith as it's such a great deal and the foudroyante is something I have nothing like; I already have other flybacks.

I would then grab the Breguet in a while, the XX never appealed to me but the XXI was a HUGE step forward I thought. They are not particularly rare however and I am sure another would come up in that price range again.


Miguel Alvarez

5,194 posts

201 months

Wednesday 9th January 2013
quotequote all
I thought the S-10th was 42mm? On looks alone I'm more of a fan of Zenith watches over Breget watches so that's where my money would go. I also like the idea of a 10 second count down chrono.


andy_s

19,857 posts

290 months

Wednesday 9th January 2013
quotequote all
I'm tempted to agree - the Breguet would win my head, but I think the foudroyante must be a stunning thing to have and see. The Stratos is large, which is why I'd be tempted by the standard 1/10th above the Stratos, but having handled neither it's difficult to say. I like the pushers on the Zenith too - and my gripe on the subdials is very petty when seen against the backdrop of what they've done with this one.

- 45.5 for the Stratos, 42 for the 'standard'.

Edited by andy_s on Wednesday 9th January 15:53

Miguel Alvarez

5,194 posts

201 months

Wednesday 9th January 2013
quotequote all
Oh ok. I skipped over the stratos part.


andy_s

19,857 posts

290 months

Wednesday 9th January 2013
quotequote all
...and just another thought - you could of course get a very nice Lemania 5100 / Omega 1045 centre minute chronograph for half the price of the Breguet....just sayin'...!

yeti

Original Poster:

10,704 posts

306 months

Wednesday 9th January 2013
quotequote all
andy_s said:
...and just another thought - you could of course get a very nice Lemania 5100 / Omega 1045 centre minute chronograph for half the price of the Breguet....just sayin'...!
Thanks - unfamiliar with it so will have a Google later. The classic Speedy Pro probably meets my Omega needs though...

yeti

Original Poster:

10,704 posts

306 months

Wednesday 9th January 2013
quotequote all
andy_s said:
The Stratos is large, which is why I'd be tempted by the standard 1/10th above the Stratos,
The standard 1/10 is missing the Flyback though... Just think that stopping that madly rotating hand and resetting that Chrono 'in flight' will never get old!

I think I'll go with the Zenith first partly due to the great deal. If we don't get along, I won't lose much.

If I can do both... That would be a result smile


andy_s

19,857 posts

290 months

Wednesday 9th January 2013
quotequote all
yeti said:
Thanks - unfamiliar with it so will have a Google later. The classic Speedy Pro probably meets my Omega needs though...
The movement was found in many watches other than Omega - it's rudimentary but interesting, certainly if you want that particular arrangement of display.

yeti said:
The standard 1/10 is missing the Flyback though... Just think that stopping that madly rotating hand and resetting that Chrono 'in flight' will never get old!

I think I'll go with the Zenith first partly due to the great deal. If we don't get along, I won't lose much.

If I can do both... That would be a result smile
Ahh, OK then. True it would be a great thing to play with, it's an interesting complication to have certainly. Right choice I think.

MarkS3

53 posts

167 months

Wednesday 9th January 2013
quotequote all
The Zenith gets my vote both for looks and because of the recent history with Felix B.

yeti

Original Poster:

10,704 posts

306 months

Wednesday 9th January 2013
quotequote all
MarkS3 said:
The Zenith gets my vote both for looks and because of the recent history with Felix B.
Yeah... I'm a marketing man's dream, always have been!

Cheers all for comments, I will make the purchase tomorrow. And post pics smile

Vvroom

1,170 posts

221 months

Friday 11th January 2013
quotequote all
Well, what did you go for?

(I hope the Zenith...)

sneijder

5,231 posts

265 months

Saturday 12th January 2013
quotequote all
Vvroom said:
Well, what did you go for?

(I hope the Zenith...)
.... And the photographic equipment !

yeti

Original Poster:

10,704 posts

306 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
Vvroom said:
Well, what did you go for?

(I hope the Zenith...)
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&f=187&t=1240248&mid=9431&nmt=A+Good+Week+%28Zenith+and+JLC+content%29

Loving it smile


MarkS3

53 posts

167 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
Two beautiful watches you have there!

yeti

Original Poster:

10,704 posts

306 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
MarkS3 said:
Two beautiful watches you have there!
Thanks - the AMVOX had been on my radar for a long time, was a question of finding one tray the right money; I waited and got what I wanted, but I waited years.

The Zenith came out of nowhere and I had to have it. It's amazing.