Steinhart Marine Officer Watch
Steinhart Marine Officer Watch
Author
Discussion

richtea78

Original Poster:

5,574 posts

189 months

Sunday 13th January 2013
quotequote all
A while back I was looking to get an Omega with an inheritance I received but circumstances changed and I had to put it on hold.

I also have had to look at a significantly lower budget now so the Omega is out of the question really

Ive been looking for a suitable watch and stumbled upon this

http://www.steinhartwatches.de/en/MARINE-Officer-B...

I really like the appearance of it and would like to know some thoughts on it from people with more experience of watches.

Is it a good movement? Is it likely to be a long lasting watch? I dont want something thats going to break easily and not be fixable. Id like this watch to last a good few years/ decades even

Is that realistic?
If I buy it how reliable is the service etc?

Thanks for your comments

TomM

662 posts

226 months

Sunday 13th January 2013
quotequote all
The ETA movement in that is found in a lot of other watches, and a lot of Steinharts. I have a Steinhart Ocean One and the quality is very good - but that was £300, so a lot cheaper.

That particular model isn't my thing, but as a brand using that movement I can recommend both.

Pesty

42,655 posts

287 months

Sunday 13th January 2013
quotequote all
OOhh I like that a lot.

I am a fan of steinhart watches and for the money they are well made.

Some things you need to consider with bronze. It will not look like in the pictures for ever.

After a few months verdigris will start to build up and the watch will darken. This can be cleaned off with tooth paste or coke or brasso though to get it back all nice and shiny. Most people leave their bronze watches to age.

depending on the actual alloy content it may be softer and easier to ding and mark than stainless steel.

Oh and bronze in contact with the skin can cause allergic reactions which is why it has a ss back. However the lugs may still touch teh skin.

I wouldn't worry about any of that though personally. Another watch added to the list.




tertius

6,914 posts

261 months

Monday 14th January 2013
quotequote all
One thing to bear in mind is that that is a modular chronograph - that is to say it has a "base" time-only movement (ETA 2824) with a chronograph module (DD 2030) piggy-backed on top. This will have a couple of implications:

1. it is quite a bit more complicated than an integrated chronograph movement, and servicing may be expensive
2. the pushers and the crown will not be in-line; the crown is aligned to the base movement and the pushers to the module on top
3. there will probably be slack in the drive train, which means that when you set the time and push in the crown it will take some seconds before the minute hand starts to move after the seconds hand has started; if you are a bit OCD this makes getting the hands set exactly damn tricky

None of these are that serious and may not bother you of course.

clockworks

7,818 posts

176 months

Monday 14th January 2013
quotequote all
I thought that the standard way of servicing the 2824 with D-D piggyback module was to service the base movement, and fit an exchange module if necessary?
I would've though that this would make servicing easier, as any watch tech could do the job.

I could be wrong, as I'm a clock man who only repairs watches for fun. I've done a few standard 2824s (plus a lot of vintage stuff), but I wouldn't attempt to service a "proper" chronograph.

richtea78

Original Poster:

5,574 posts

189 months

Monday 14th January 2013
quotequote all
I have to confess I dont understand what you mean about the movement and the chronograph part? Could someone explain what a piggyback means?

From what it sounds like there is the standard watch movement and the chronograph part fits on top of that but I dont understand what it means about the pushers not lining up.

The appearance of the brass was one of the main things that attracted me. I like brass stuff and the way it ages, I think it looks more attractive as it gets older. Im a bit concerned about the allergy thing as well though.

I also like the Triton watch they sell

Pesty

42,655 posts

287 months

Monday 14th January 2013
quotequote all
richtea78 said:
Im a bit concerned about the allergy thing as well though.
I have not had an issue and I have not read of any other bronze watch owners having an issue.


I only mention it as it is a possibility. The back of the watch is SS and glass so that wont be a problem chances are the lugs wont touch the skin anyway.

If you like it go for it. You wont ever see anybody else wearing one like it I wouldn't have thought.

as for the ageing if it ages evenly I agree.

CardShark

4,264 posts

210 months

Monday 14th January 2013
quotequote all
richtea78 said:
I have to confess I dont understand what you mean about the movement and the chronograph part? Could someone explain what a piggyback means?

From what it sounds like there is the standard watch movement and the chronograph part fits on top of that but I dont understand what it means about the pushers not lining up.

The appearance of the brass was one of the main things that attracted me. I like brass stuff and the way it ages, I think it looks more attractive as it gets older. Im a bit concerned about the allergy thing as well though.

I also like the Triton watch they sell
Piggyback basically means that an extra module has been added to the standard movement so it becomes a chronograph as opposed to the movement originally incorporating a chrono function from the start. Adding an extra module may mean that the pushers - the buttons either side of the crown -aren't equidistant from the crown ie one of the pushers may be closer to the crown than the other. Looking at the watch in question I'd say that the pushers are equidistant.

tertius

6,914 posts

261 months

Monday 14th January 2013
quotequote all
CardShark said:
richtea78 said:
I have to confess I dont understand what you mean about the movement and the chronograph part? Could someone explain what a piggyback means?

From what it sounds like there is the standard watch movement and the chronograph part fits on top of that but I dont understand what it means about the pushers not lining up.

The appearance of the brass was one of the main things that attracted me. I like brass stuff and the way it ages, I think it looks more attractive as it gets older. Im a bit concerned about the allergy thing as well though.

I also like the Triton watch they sell
Piggyback basically means that an extra module has been added to the standard movement so it becomes a chronograph as opposed to the movement originally incorporating a chrono function from the start. Adding an extra module may mean that the pushers - the buttons either side of the crown -aren't equidistant from the crown ie one of the pushers may be closer to the crown than the other. Looking at the watch in question I'd say that the pushers are equidistant.
My point was not about distance from the crown (I have never heard of that varying) but about alignment - if you look at the almost edge on picture of the case you will see that the crown is mounted towards the bottom of the case (ie nearer the caseback) whereas the pushers are in the middle; this is because the pushers operate on the chrono module, on top of the base movement which is what the crown operates on.

CardShark

4,264 posts

210 months

Monday 14th January 2013
quotequote all
Ah.... getmecoat

I have seen the odd watch with unequally spaced pushers and stupidly thought that was what you were referring to, however your explanation makes much more sense!

shambolic

2,146 posts

198 months

Tuesday 15th January 2013
quotequote all
The grey version looks lovely!