Would you swap a Rolex Milgauss for a Sub?
Discussion
I am contemplating selling my Milgauss and have been offered a swap for a Submariner. My Milgauss is a white dial 2009 watch. It had never been used before I bought it in March 2012. The sub is a 2001 watch with black dial/bezel.
I love my Milgauss and it was a grail for me, but since owning it it hasn't been a 'real' grail. I have a Steinhart Ocean 1 ceramic which I love and it gets the majority of wrist time at the moment. Is the Sub a bit too casual? At the moment I use the Milgauss as my special occasion watch. Could a Sub still be used in the same way and look equally as good with a shirt as the Milgauss does.
I really do not know what to do at the moment.
I love my Milgauss and it was a grail for me, but since owning it it hasn't been a 'real' grail. I have a Steinhart Ocean 1 ceramic which I love and it gets the majority of wrist time at the moment. Is the Sub a bit too casual? At the moment I use the Milgauss as my special occasion watch. Could a Sub still be used in the same way and look equally as good with a shirt as the Milgauss does.
I really do not know what to do at the moment.
If it makes any difference then here are the main watches in my collection as it stands;
Rolex Milgauss:

Tag Heuer Aquaracer:

Steinhart Ocean 1 Ceramic:

Raymond Weil Freelancer:

Incoming - Steinhart Artic Ocean (to give me my Tudor fix for the time being):

Would replacing the MG with a Sub ruin the slight variety of my collection?
Rolex Milgauss:

Tag Heuer Aquaracer:

Steinhart Ocean 1 Ceramic:

Raymond Weil Freelancer:

Incoming - Steinhart Artic Ocean (to give me my Tudor fix for the time being):

Would replacing the MG with a Sub ruin the slight variety of my collection?
- Do get rid of all that junk and get yourself a vintage Sub
- Your wrists are a bit on the narrow side, even the MG looks a bit too big for you. Maybe you should also consider an Explorer 1, a very timeless and strinking watch
- I dont understand your question about smart/casual. All your current watches are chunky ones, made from stainless steel. If you are looking for a dress watch, you should consider a flat, solid gold Patek/IWC/Vacheron/Audemars/Jaeger with a croc strap, not a divers/sports watch
- Do not waste any more money on homages-to-a-homage-watch (Stainer to Tudor to vintage Sub)
- Your wrists are a bit on the narrow side, even the MG looks a bit too big for you. Maybe you should also consider an Explorer 1, a very timeless and strinking watch
- I dont understand your question about smart/casual. All your current watches are chunky ones, made from stainless steel. If you are looking for a dress watch, you should consider a flat, solid gold Patek/IWC/Vacheron/Audemars/Jaeger with a croc strap, not a divers/sports watch
- Do not waste any more money on homages-to-a-homage-watch (Stainer to Tudor to vintage Sub)
Edited by Rushmore on Sunday 20th January 21:23
Rushmore said:
- Do not waste any more money on homages-to-a-homage-watch (Stainer to Tudor to vintage Sub)
A little harsh I think, Steinhart in particular offer great VFM and can be an enjoyable alternative to the "real thing" Edited by Rushmore on Sunday 20th January 21:23

OP - do you still get a kick out of wearing your MG, even if you don't wear it that often? Why do you wear your Steinhart more than the MG? Because of the style? Because you're not so scared to bash it? Because you simply prefer it?
I'm not the biggest fan of the MG myself, I kind of sit on the fence with it, but given your options and looking at what else you have/have incoming I'd keep it.
FWIW I think that Subs are one of the most versatile watches out there though, looking just as good with a T and jeans as it does a suit.
Edited by CardShark on Sunday 20th January 22:25
CardShark said:
A little harsh I think, Steinhart in particular offer great VFM and can be an enjoyable alternative to the "real thing" 
OP - do you still get a kick out of wearing your MG, even if you don't wear it that often? Why do you wear your Steinhart more than the MG? Because of the style? Because you're not so scared to bash it? Because you simply prefer it?
I'm not the biggest fan of the MG myself, I kind of sit on the fence with it, but given your options and looking at what else you have/have incoming I'd keep it.
FWIW I think that Subs are one of the most versatile watches out there though, looking just as good with a T and jeans as it does a suit.
Yes I love wearing my Milgauss. It still feels an occasion when I wear it. I don't wear it too much because I don't want to lose that sense of occasion. I'm not too fussed about bashing it, I just wear the Steinhart more as it goes with just about anything and its not too valuable so makes an ideal everyday watch IMO. 
OP - do you still get a kick out of wearing your MG, even if you don't wear it that often? Why do you wear your Steinhart more than the MG? Because of the style? Because you're not so scared to bash it? Because you simply prefer it?
I'm not the biggest fan of the MG myself, I kind of sit on the fence with it, but given your options and looking at what else you have/have incoming I'd keep it.
FWIW I think that Subs are one of the most versatile watches out there though, looking just as good with a T and jeans as it does a suit.
Edited by CardShark on Sunday 20th January 22:25
At the moment I am verging on the keep it option as I think a Sub is too similar to what I already have, albeit at least it would be the 'real deal'.
Easty-5 said:
Yes I love wearing my Milgauss. It still feels an occasion when I wear it. I don't wear it too much because I don't want to lose that sense of occasion.
You've just answered your own original post 
Seriously though, what you have already covers a large range of watch wearing scenarios and chopping the MG for a Sub would narrow that range - the MG/Ocean 1/Snowflake combo is more versatile than a Sub/Ocean 1/Snowflake combo IMO.
You could, of course, chop everything else in and have the Sub and an MG. Add a G-Shock and you'd have a pretty neat set-up

Gassing Station | Watches | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


