How big a premium does Box and Papers justify?
Discussion
I am not really what you could call a watch collector, but have been thinking about buying an older Rolex Submariner (5513). However, I am curious as to the fairly wide spread of prices these are offered at by dealers, with the same dealer having ostensibly similar watches ranging from £3,500 to nearly £5,000. The more expensive options do have Box and Papers, but would this alone justify the additional cost?
If you want to buy a Sub and you are going to keep it and I mean keep it, make certain you buy a good one verify at AD to make you feel 100% you have a pukka watch,then buy without papers. I dont know what an actual figure would be to value just box and papers depends also on the watch itself I guess.
If you're buying for investment - get the papers/box.
My wife very kindly got me a '72 1680 'red' sub for my birhday last year.
Luckily we have a friend in the watch business who put my wife in touch with a rolex expert/enthusiast.
In the end we went without papers (but are very happy that the watch is validated as the genuine article)based on his opinion that the one without was a better example. And I don't know exactly what my wife paid - but of the two examples found (one with papers, one without) I am sure the one with was a good few £k more. Maybe 25%.
My wife very kindly got me a '72 1680 'red' sub for my birhday last year.
Luckily we have a friend in the watch business who put my wife in touch with a rolex expert/enthusiast.
In the end we went without papers (but are very happy that the watch is validated as the genuine article)based on his opinion that the one without was a better example. And I don't know exactly what my wife paid - but of the two examples found (one with papers, one without) I am sure the one with was a good few £k more. Maybe 25%.
It's a strange thing, for most vintage it's not going to come with box and papers and people wouldn't expect them too, if you get something with then yes, a small surcharge for the novelty but nothing otherworldly like 25% - except Rolex.... How did we get to this position - I think it just became the done thing to assure genuiness (which it doesn't necessarily) and provenance (which may or may not be important), but to be honest, I would prefer a 25% discount and know myself something is genuine than pay a premium that doesn't necessarily mean anything. Boxes can be bought on eBay or faked as much as watches can...
Anyway, I just think it's odd that it has a level of importance attached that to me is just a 'nice to have if it's there' rather than a 'must have B&P'. In some ways the whole 'must have B&P' becomes a bit of a self fulfilling prophecy. Probably just me.
Anyway, I just think it's odd that it has a level of importance attached that to me is just a 'nice to have if it's there' rather than a 'must have B&P'. In some ways the whole 'must have B&P' becomes a bit of a self fulfilling prophecy. Probably just me.

An aside - Being aware that box and papers are important are important, I have stored those for mine somewhere safe. "Safe" being in our loft which is about the size of Luxembourg, so if I ever sell one of my watches it will be without "B&P". I would venture that many watches sold without box and papers have belonged not to people who discarded them, but those with big lofts.
944Nick said:
I am not really what you could call a watch collector, but have been thinking about buying an older Rolex Submariner (5513). However, I am curious as to the fairly wide spread of prices these are offered at by dealers, with the same dealer having ostensibly similar watches ranging from £3,500 to nearly £5,000. The more expensive options do have Box and Papers, but would this alone justify the additional cost?
My 1974 5513 is being sold by Dane at dream watches .......it's being serviced at the moment but will go onto his site next week......papers and box are worth 300-500 michael gould said:
My 1974 5513 is being sold by Dane at dream watches .......it's being serviced at the moment but will go onto his site next week......papers and box are worth 300-500
Crikey - it didn't even make it into stock and went from "arriving soon" to not being on the site at all. Presumably they had a keen buyer? Gassing Station | Watches | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


