Breitlings; do they hold their value?
Breitlings; do they hold their value?
Author
Discussion

Vladimir

Original Poster:

6,917 posts

189 months

Monday 4th March 2013
quotequote all
As above - thinking of a possible buy of a limtef editon model but it would be handy if it didn't drop like a stone in value. Worth a punt?


don logan

4,023 posts

253 months

Monday 4th March 2013
quotequote all
Vladimir said:
As above - thinking of a possible buy of a limtef editon model but it would be handy if it didn't drop like a stone in value. Worth a punt?
Hi, I wouldn't EXPECT a Breitling to hold its value, even a Ltd Ed of say 3,000 say won't help matters!!

As you know, I have a Super Avenger Black Steel (which is one of 3000) that certainly isn't worth what I paid for it 3yrs ago!

I also have a Chrono Avenger 69 which was one of 600 which I think has done a LOT better but I'd say that's more to do with how much more Breitlings cost now as opposed to what that watch cost in 2003!

The flip side to that is if you get a good enough deal in the 1st place it goes a LONG way, I bought one if the last Avenger Skylands (regular polished type finish the same as the regular current Avenger except woth WHITE numerals) and got a good enough deal that 3yrs ago I paid the same price new as dealers are asking for them used now!

A friend bought a Skyland Code Yellow for £3,400 a couple of years ago and that hasn't held brilliantly either but I'm sure it's "plateau'd" now

Ultimately if you buy a desireable model at the RIGHT price (22-25% off) then that should save you a lot of pain but buy one because you have to have one rather than investment or because they are depreciation proof!

Google Andrew Michaels jewellers, really really helpfull!!!!

Vladimir

Original Poster:

6,917 posts

189 months

Monday 4th March 2013
quotequote all
NeMiSiS said:
If you don't wear it and keep it in your family for 6 generations then a member of your family should be OK.

Keep the box and papers though.
Okay useful comments. Say the budget is ermm "flexible" - what IS a good investment (yes I know this is a stupid question but worth asking). IWC, Rolex or similar? This isn't a "buy it now, try and make a few quid" thing, it's more about wearing something nice for a while and then possibly changing it in a while.



don logan

4,023 posts

253 months

Monday 4th March 2013
quotequote all
Vladimir said:
Okay useful comments. Say the budget is ermm "flexible" - what IS a good investment (yes I know this is a stupid question but worth asking). IWC, Rolex or similar? This isn't a "buy it now, try and make a few quid" thing, it's more about wearing something nice for a while and then possibly changing it in a while.
I just commented on another thread and I know it's the same sort of thing as everyone always says BUT it's hard tomgo wrong with a Sub or a GMT 2C because they are so popular and because Rolex have a nasty habit of increasing prices by a fair whack every year!

My own experience is that I bought an early GMT2C in September 2007 for £3,400 (no discount) so just look at the new price being £5,600 and used generally being over £4k for a 2007 (though some may say that's optomistic)

Lorneg

228 posts

210 months

Tuesday 5th March 2013
quotequote all
Does a Breitling hold its value? err, Nope.

I'll let you into a secret by way of explanation. My hobby is building chronographs, and as part of my research I buy lots of other chronographs from many of the well known makes so I can dismantle them and examine how they've been engineered. So that my hobby doesn't become too expensive I tend to buy them from Pawn shops (top tip - when telling the wife you've found a pawn shop with some good material in it, be very precise about what you're talking about).

Now, what's the most common brand you find in pawn shops? You guessed it, Breitling, by a long long way. Second most popular are men's Ebel watches (bit yuck and generally with quartz movements so tend to ignore them) and third is of course the Rolex - often gold and sometimes with added diamonds just to remind me never to make a gold and diamond watch.

The Breitlings can be had for a real bargain, as can Ebels and Rolex's that have been blinged up. Un-modified Rolex's however are by far the closest to retail price.

So if you want a watch that holds its value there really is only one choice - Rolex and in particular the Submariner. As for Breitling; well what sort of person buys a fancy watch and the following year has it in a pawn shop?

marcosgt

11,506 posts

207 months

Tuesday 5th March 2013
quotequote all
Interesting. I've never seen a Breitling (or a Rolex) in a pawn shop, but I probably don't look in the right ones. Want to point me in the right direction? smile

If you get a vintage Breitling, there are some good candidates for watches that will hold their value.

I'm always baffled that Rolexes hold their prices, given how many they churn out every year. It's like Mercedes cars holding their values. Well made, yes, but rare? Most certainly not.

Unlike Mercedes, though, Rolex have an amazing marketing department that contrives to make people believe that it's normal for a product to have a massive price hike (with no changes) every year, meaning that people who pay say 5 grand this year, might well get it back as exactly the same model might cost 7.5 grand in 5 years time.

If you ONLY want to get your money back (and maybe even a little bit if you wait long enough) buy a Rolex (or stick your money in a solid investment somewhere, there's another sub-forum for that somewhere).

If you prefer a particular Breitling buy it, wear it and enjoy it! If you can't afford it new without expecting to get your money back, buy used.

M.

bigtime

541 posts

170 months

Tuesday 5th March 2013
quotequote all
I used to think about depreciation when buying watches. Now I just buy what I like and forget about what it's worth. I bought a limited edition 24h Breitling a few years back with the intention of selling it and then changing to a Navitimer World or similiar. When push came to shove I didn't want to sell the Breitling and just saved up to buy the Navitimer. My next purchase will probably be a an Omega, Cartier or Rolex but I won't be selling any other watches to fund this.

Adrian W

15,623 posts

259 months

Tuesday 5th March 2013
quotequote all
Lorneg said:
Does a Breitling hold its value? err, Nope.

I'll let you into a secret by way of explanation. My hobby is building chronographs, and as part of my research I buy lots of other chronographs from many of the well known makes so I can dismantle them and examine how they've been engineered. So that my hobby doesn't become too expensive I tend to buy them from Pawn shops (top tip - when telling the wife you've found a pawn shop with some good material in it, be very precise about what you're talking about).

Now, what's the most common brand you find in pawn shops? You guessed it, Breitling, by a long long way. Second most popular are men's Ebel watches (bit yuck and generally with quartz movements so tend to ignore them) and third is of course the Rolex - often gold and sometimes with added diamonds just to remind me never to make a gold and diamond watch.

The Breitlings can be had for a real bargain, as can Ebels and Rolex's that have been blinged up. Un-modified Rolex's however are by far the closest to retail price.

So if you want a watch that holds its value there really is only one choice - Rolex and in particular the Submariner. As for Breitling; well what sort of person buys a fancy watch and the following year has it in a pawn shop?
I just read through your website, very interesting, your watches look good too, also very interesting what you say about helium escape valves, I notice you havent got around to writing about the Deepsea yet.

Miguel Alvarez

5,194 posts

201 months

Tuesday 5th March 2013
quotequote all
marcosgt said:
Interesting. I've never seen a Breitling (or a Rolex) in a pawn shop, but I probably don't look in the right ones. Want to point me in the right direction? smile
I can think of two places in Reading that have Rolex in the pawn shops. One place had a battered old DJ in the window. Move walk 4/5 shops along the same street and Goldsmiths had a nicer condition one for less money. Madness. I know where I'd put my money.

Vladimir

Original Poster:

6,917 posts

189 months

Tuesday 5th March 2013
quotequote all
Very interesting reading! It's not just to sell it on; trouble is I just don't like Rolexes!

How about IWC, Hublot and similar? I would say AP but they are simply in a price bracket I deem slightly mad!

Riff Raff

5,462 posts

226 months

Tuesday 5th March 2013
quotequote all
Vladimir said:
Very interesting reading! It's not just to sell it on; trouble is I just don't like Rolexes!

How about IWC, Hublot and similar? I would say AP but they are simply in a price bracket I deem slightly mad!
Don't discount AP. I picked up an unworn Royal Oak for slightly more than half the RRP. It's a lovely watch.

Adrian W

15,623 posts

259 months

Tuesday 5th March 2013
quotequote all
Vladimir said:
Okay useful comments. Say the budget is ermm "flexible" - what IS a good investment (yes I know this is a stupid question but worth asking). IWC, Rolex or similar? This isn't a "buy it now, try and make a few quid" thing, it's more about wearing something nice for a while and then possibly changing it in a while.
No watch is a good investment, except very rare high end pieces from PP or maybe JLC and others, I assume you're not a watch dealer so will be paying normal prices, the safest regarding depreciation seems to be Rolex, but you keep saying you dont like them, so take the hit with another brand.

michael gould

5,698 posts

272 months

Tuesday 5th March 2013
quotequote all
Adrian W said:
Vladimir said:
Okay useful comments. Say the budget is ermm "flexible" - what IS a good investment (yes I know this is a stupid question but worth asking). IWC, Rolex or similar? This isn't a "buy it now, try and make a few quid" thing, it's more about wearing something nice for a while and then possibly changing it in a while.
No watch is a good investment, except very rare high end pieces from PP or maybe JLC and others, I assume you're not a watch dealer so will be paying normal prices, the safest regarding depreciation seems to be Rolex, but you keep saying you dont like them, so take the hit with another brand.
good advice.......5YO Rolex will have lost 30%-40% of its value and will stabalise over the next 5 years.....a new Breitling will loose 40% of its value in year 1


Vladimir

Original Poster:

6,917 posts

189 months

Tuesday 5th March 2013
quotequote all
My thinly disguised excuse for wanting a £3k Brietling isn't really working...

ellroy

7,858 posts

256 months

Tuesday 5th March 2013
quotequote all
Buy what you want to wear, not what you may want to sell in a few years.

You'll find life is a lot happier for you by living it.

Vladimir

Original Poster:

6,917 posts

189 months

Tuesday 5th March 2013
quotequote all
ellroy said:
Buy what you want to wear, not what you may want to sell in a few years.

You'll find life is a lot happier for you by living it.
It's what I always do. I just think it would be handy to buy a "Porsche" rather than a "Vauxhall...!!"

don logan

4,023 posts

253 months

Tuesday 5th March 2013
quotequote all
Vladimir said:
ellroy said:
Buy what you want to wear, not what you may want to sell in a few years.

You'll find life is a lot happier for you by living it.
It's what I always do. I just think it would be handy to buy a "Porsche" rather than a "Vauxhall...!!"
Ellroy is spot on, if there is something that you REALLY want then nothing else is going to make you happy, if you start with a 22-25% discount then it should help put your mind at rest too!

That guy I told you about (who also has an excellent reputation and is a sponsor on Breitlingsource) WAS selling the last Avenger Skylands at 35% discount, hard to go wrong with that!

http://www.breitlingsource.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.ph...

I think they have all gone but it's an example of what can be had!!!!

Lorneg

228 posts

210 months

Tuesday 5th March 2013
quotequote all
Adrian W said:
I just read through your website, very interesting, your watches look good too, also very interesting what you say about helium escape valves, I notice you havent got around to writing about the Deepsea yet.
The deepsea is a nice watch, although it does fit into the 'why on earth make a watch that goes to 3900m when the human brain turns to clotted cheese beyond 350m' category. And to do it Rolex had to use a domed chemical glass, which for me reduces the legibility of the time reading.

Glad you like the website though!

marcosgt

11,506 posts

207 months

Tuesday 5th March 2013
quotequote all
Vladimir said:
It's what I always do. I just think it would be handy to buy a "Porsche" rather than a "Vauxhall...!!"
Well, get a Rolex then you'll have an excuse to buy the Porsche for the obligatory my Rolex in my Porsche wrist shot smile

M.

Vladimir

Original Poster:

6,917 posts

189 months

Wednesday 6th March 2013
quotequote all
marcosgt said:
Well, get a Rolex then you'll have an excuse to buy the Porsche for the obligatory my Rolex in my Porsche wrist shot smile

M.
Tee hee!

Porsche yes, Rolex no..!