Does this Datejust look real?
Discussion
There is a stolen register but the f
kers no longer make it possible for us to access it directly. Authorised dealers still can, so Id conclude any deal there, where the watch can be appraised and its provenance checked all in one go.
My local AD offered to do this, but they had to go away and have a think about what they would charge...
kers no longer make it possible for us to access it directly. Authorised dealers still can, so Id conclude any deal there, where the watch can be appraised and its provenance checked all in one go.My local AD offered to do this, but they had to go away and have a think about what they would charge...
More like too bad to be true 
The gold batons at 6 and 9 o'clock look wrong. The bracelet doesn't fit the lugs snugly as it should. The markings on the clasp look completely wrong and as has already been pointed out, a Rolex Jubilee bracelet simply wouldn't twist like that.
The real deal should look like this (in an almost equally poor image for direct comparison)...

IF in any doubt, a good start point is to obtain the serial number from a seller. That can be checked to determine that it starts with letters/numbers that signify a year of manufacture rather than just some random numbers. You can then check that those prefixes match the year in which the watch is supposed to have been made and of course against the "stolen" register.
The serial number is on the outside of the case between the lugs at 6 o'clock but of course the bracelet has to be detached there to read it.
Nick.

The gold batons at 6 and 9 o'clock look wrong. The bracelet doesn't fit the lugs snugly as it should. The markings on the clasp look completely wrong and as has already been pointed out, a Rolex Jubilee bracelet simply wouldn't twist like that.
The real deal should look like this (in an almost equally poor image for direct comparison)...
IF in any doubt, a good start point is to obtain the serial number from a seller. That can be checked to determine that it starts with letters/numbers that signify a year of manufacture rather than just some random numbers. You can then check that those prefixes match the year in which the watch is supposed to have been made and of course against the "stolen" register.
The serial number is on the outside of the case between the lugs at 6 o'clock but of course the bracelet has to be detached there to read it.
Nick.
der1 said:
Out of intrest how much would one of these sell for ?
A real one or a fake? The estimate given earlier on this thread (for a real one presumably!) I think was low low but like all things it all depends on authenticity/age/condition/paperwork and even original packaging to a smaller extent.OP. The watch looks fine to me. I'm a little rusty on older Datejusts, it's probably a US spec watch hence the oval section link rather than the usual semi-circle section link. Check the serial number as previously advised to confirm the year. If the serial number is c2500000 then it matches the bracelet, which was produced in the 1st 1/4 of 1970, as shown in the final image. With wear, a Jubilee bracelet can flex through and beyond 90 degrees.
The dial is fine, it's known as a 'Pie-pan' dial. As it slopes off from the baton edges to the rehaut. This one with the thick baton 6 and 9 is typical of the lates 60's and early 70's.
Watch looks original, it all comes down to price and condition.
Hope this help...
D
The dial is fine, it's known as a 'Pie-pan' dial. As it slopes off from the baton edges to the rehaut. This one with the thick baton 6 and 9 is typical of the lates 60's and early 70's.
Watch looks original, it all comes down to price and condition.
Hope this help...
D
My opinion doesnt add a great deal after Doms, but Id say that this watch would be at the lower end of the scale, as the bracelet is stretched about as far as it can go, by the looks of it.
The ends can become less than perfect with wear. Theyre probably still available but Im not sure that itd be worth the cost.
The ends can become less than perfect with wear. Theyre probably still available but Im not sure that itd be worth the cost.
nikman said:
A real one or a fake? The estimate given earlier on this thread (for a real one presumably!) I think was low low but like all things it all depends on authenticity/age/condition/paperwork and even original packaging to a smaller extent.
A real one for between £900-£1500 ? My old man would probably like one for his 60th birthday and if I could get one somewhere in that price range I would be happy
Steel yes, but Id be surprise if you could get a steel and yellow Datejust for that, even though theyre the ginger haired stepson of the range. I have an equally undesirable steel and yellow (oyster) Date, bought many years ago at a price too good to miss and long before Rolexs price rises had driven up other residuals.
der1 said:
nikman said:
A real one or a fake? The estimate given earlier on this thread (for a real one presumably!) I think was low low but like all things it all depends on authenticity/age/condition/paperwork and even original packaging to a smaller extent.
A real one for between £900-£1500 ? My old man would probably like one for his 60th birthday and if I could get one somewhere in that price range I would be happy
Of everyone posting here, I'd suggest Dom is best qualified on authenticity and price. My observations are based on having followed the market in these for some time as I owned (a newer one) for 25 years.
We don't know the asking price of this one, but from what has been said, I'd guess it's within that range if not below it! But if Dom reckons it looks OK to him and if it proves OK from the serial number making sense then after closer inspection this may be one for your dad's 60th if not bought by the OP

Gassing Station | Watches | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


