Omega PO or no date sub?
Omega PO or no date sub?
Author
Discussion

MYOB

Original Poster:

5,130 posts

169 months

Wednesday 19th June 2013
quotequote all
Hello

I'm conscious the following decision has to be my choice based on personal preferences, but still, would be interested in reading some views:

I recently purchased a pre-owned Sea Dweller and intend to leave this to my eldest son in my will. I have another son, who currently has nothing. Thus I have an excuse to buy another watch to leave him in the will!

I'm interesting in buying a Planet Ocean as I had one before and regretted getting rid of it. But my wife says I cannot leave one son with a Rolex whilst the other gets an Omega! The only other Rolex I would consider is a no -date Sub but I worry that this is too similar to my Sea Dweller. I would like to alternate the watches and feel that there will be no significant difference between the SD and Sub and thus I won't necessarily feel as if I own two different watches.

So, do I go ahead and get a PO and not worry that this isn't a Rolex? After all, I hope the true value will lie in the sentimental side rather than fiscal.

By the way, this isn't necessarily an Omega v Rolex debate! I like both brands. It's about owning a SD and a no date sub/PO.

Many thanks boys and girls.



Edited by MYOB on Wednesday 19th June 13:42

Miguel Alvarez

5,193 posts

201 months

Wednesday 19th June 2013
quotequote all
I'm assuming money is an option hence you asking here so with that in mind I'd get the PO. I know the Sub and the SD are different watches but for the most part they look similar to the untrained eye.


JRewing

17,551 posts

210 months

Wednesday 19th June 2013
quotequote all
I'm much more of a Rolex than Omega fan, but as you own an SD already and with that criteria in mind I think that the Planet Ocean should be the solution.

Xtriple129

1,173 posts

188 months

Wednesday 19th June 2013
quotequote all
I've got a couple of Omega's and my wife wears an SMP as her everyday watch (she loves it)and I recently bought a new Rolex Sub' ND (114060) and I ABSOLUTELY ADORE THE THING! It has not been off my wrist since the day I bought it (8 months now) and that is with thirty odd more watches in the box. Timekeeping is excellent (0.5 seconds per day) and the quality just shines through.

yeti

10,704 posts

306 months

Wednesday 19th June 2013
quotequote all
I don't know how old you are, but let's assume you've 20-30 years left before they get them.

Have a check on the price of 20-30 year old Rolex Sub's vs 20-30 year old Omega Seamasters.

Your wife is right, Omega boy would be getting screwed smile

How about a GMT Master or Yachtmaster?

JRewing

17,551 posts

210 months

Wednesday 19th June 2013
quotequote all
If it helps my father gave me a watch of his once (for the same reason as you want to leave your sons watches, but it was before he died).

I've only kept the bd thing because he gave it to me. It's a quartz Gucci with the most hideous steel and crap gold plate finish. It has a green face and bezel markers and it is fking horrible.

That was unhelpful, but I wanted to contribute to the thread.

kazste

6,129 posts

229 months

Wednesday 19th June 2013
quotequote all
Does the oldest son already know he's getting the seadweller?
If not get the omega and in the will put it that if they dont agree they flip a coin.

If he does then hopefully they will want you to have two watches that YOU will enjoy and for me the two rolex's would be too similar.

MYOB

Original Poster:

5,130 posts

169 months

Wednesday 19th June 2013
quotequote all
The consensus appears that although Rolex is the better brand and inheritance, the Omega PO will suit me personally as the Sub ND is too similar to the SD I currently have.

My boys are too young to realise the significant of the watches at this stage, and I probably won't even mention the inheritance when they are older. After losing my dad recently, I valued everything of his that had sentimental value...even his cheap watches that he took pride in as they were cheap as chips! So my boys will hopefully feel the same and will value any watch I wear for the same reason.

Thus I think I'm leaning towards a PO again (possibly with a rubber strap this time although that could be considered as "cheap"...!).

Thanks again.

philmots

4,666 posts

291 months

Wednesday 19th June 2013
quotequote all
My good friend has a Sub which I had on a few times as I thought I wanted one.

I've always preferred the Omega brand so I tried on the 8500 PO 45.5 and I just had to have it. I can't explain how much nicer the PO is. I'm over the moon with it.

Although, this is obviously a very personal choice.

mark831

119 posts

262 months

Wednesday 19th June 2013
quotequote all
How about the new explorer ii?? Beautiful.....especially the white face..has gmt function also and is very different from the sd????

MYOB

Original Poster:

5,130 posts

169 months

Thursday 20th June 2013
quotequote all
mark831 said:
How about the new explorer ii?? Beautiful.....especially the white face..has gmt function also and is very different from the sd????
Nah, not my cup of tea! I only like the SD or ND Sub of the Rolex brand. But thanks.

I had the 45.5 PO before but think I may get the 42mm this time round as I only have small wrists and found the 45.5mm version a bit too cumbersome, but wearing the watch loose probably didn't help. At my age, subtle is the name of the game, thus the smaller PO.

The GMan

2,508 posts

286 months

Thursday 20th June 2013
quotequote all
I've got a sub date and a PO 45.5mm.

The Omega feels a more solid watch than the Rolex. I rotate between the 2 watches but find I wear the Submarnier more.

Re what to buy, you have an SD already do you really want another Rolex so similar? However to add to that, if it is for inheritance value and not just sentimentally value go for the Rolex, because as has been said they do have a history of holding value.

I'm looking at new watches at the minute as I want a 2013 birthdate watch for my son who is 4 week old today, I want to give it to him for his 21st. I can't decide what to buy either as I want to wear it, be different to what I already own and be a classic. I'm looking at Navitimers Worlds and white faced Explorer 2's but seem to change my mind every other day.


MYOB

Original Poster:

5,130 posts

169 months

Thursday 20th June 2013
quotequote all
The GMan said:
if it is for inheritance value and not just sentimentally value go for the Rolex, because as has been said they do have a history of holding value.
Nope, just sentimental value - I would like to think they wouldn't sell the watches...

Seems I'm limited in options due to liking only black or grey dials on divers-type watches. IN a sense, I envy you being more flexible in design as it widens your options. Good luck in deciding which one to go for.

The GMan

2,508 posts

286 months

Thursday 20th June 2013
quotequote all
MYOB said:
Nope, just sentimental value - I would like to think they wouldn't sell the watches...

Seems I'm limited in options due to liking only black or grey dials on divers-type watches. IN a sense, I envy you being more flexible in design as it widens your options. Good luck in deciding which one to go for.
What about a used Fifty Fathoms?

Then your sons can argue who copied who.

mark831

119 posts

262 months

Friday 21st June 2013
quotequote all
Agree with the above....pre owned Blancpain Fifty Fathoms!

Or just to throw it out there....new green sub??? I'd take the ff over the rolex especially if you already have a seaweller.

It's a nice decision the have to make

mark831

119 posts

262 months

Friday 21st June 2013
quotequote all
Agree with the above....pre owned Blancpain Fifty Fathoms!

Or just to throw it out there....new green sub??? I'd take the ff over the rolex especially if you already have a seaweller.

It's a nice decision the have to make

MYOB

Original Poster:

5,130 posts

169 months

Friday 21st June 2013
quotequote all
The Fifty Fathoms is a nice (and expensive) watch but I do prefer the classic look and thus imo, not quite what I'm looking for.

I have considered the green ND Sub (especially with an Irish heritage behind me) but again, not sure if it's "understated" enough for me which is a shame as I really want to like it. It's the same reason why I wouldn't consider an orange PO. I like to stay below the radar and not have a watch screaming for a little attention.

But I appreciate the recommendations.

kazste

6,129 posts

229 months

Friday 21st June 2013
quotequote all
If you like the green sub to want something more understated have you thought about the older green bezel black faced sub. Looks like a very good investment and still quite understand whilst having a bit of colour.

jogon

2,971 posts

189 months

Thursday 4th July 2013
quotequote all
Oops wrong thread, bloody iPhone.

Nick_MSM

739 posts

217 months

Thursday 4th July 2013
quotequote all
What about an Explorer II? Very different to the SD particularly if you went for the white dial. I have one, and a Sub ND - They are probably my two fav watches in the collection. I would take a Sub ND over the PO but I don't have a SD.