Insurance question - watches & jewellery
Insurance question - watches & jewellery
Author
Discussion

kingston12

Original Poster:

5,864 posts

188 months

Tuesday 25th June 2013
quotequote all
Thanks to advice on here, I have picked up a watch and a diamond ring at a significant discount to the high street price.

I am just doing my insurance renewal and want to make sure they are covered. As I'd expect, most insurers want to cover the items for the invoice price I paid rather than the retail value of the item.

That is absolutely fine because I would not exepct to make a profit if the worst happened, but the problem is the insurers would also pay out in high street jewellers vouchers.

Whilst I could re-buy the items that I have got from the same suppliers for the same price, if I go into Ernest Jones or equivalant, I'd be anything up to 40% short.

Does anyone have any recommended insurers who don't use high street vouchers, or insure at full high street replacement value?

onesickpuppy

2,672 posts

188 months

Tuesday 25th June 2013
quotequote all
kingston12 said:
Thanks to advice on here, I have picked up a watch and a diamond ring at a significant discount to the high street price.

I am just doing my insurance renewal and want to make sure they are covered. As I'd expect, most insurers want to cover the items for the invoice price I paid rather than the retail value of the item.

That is absolutely fine because I would not exepct to make a profit if the worst happened, but the problem is the insurers would also pay out in high street jewellers vouchers.

Whilst I could re-buy the items that I have got from the same suppliers for the same price, if I go into Ernest Jones or equivalant, I'd be anything up to 40% short.

Does anyone have any recommended insurers who don't use high street vouchers, or insure at full high street replacement value?
I'm pretty sure that you can argue your case at the time if you cannot replace the items on a like for like basis using the vouchers. I also believe they insure the items for their 'value', not what you paid for them.

tleefox

1,119 posts

179 months

Wednesday 26th June 2013
quotequote all
Ask a decent jeweller to give you an insurance purposes valuation - that should give you the valuation based on their own retail price, not what you paid for it.

I did this on my missus' engagement ring which I had custom made with a stone I bought in SA through family and the valuation came back at double what it cost me. The valuation amount is what is the declared value on the insurance policy.

ecain63

10,653 posts

206 months

Thursday 27th June 2013
quotequote all
I can organise an independent insurance valuation if you need. Done a few PHers items now and currently doing a platinum / diamond ring I made for a PHer last month.

matts4

2,117 posts

222 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
In the same situation myself, just had my watch taken clean off my wrist whilst in Barcelona on Saturday.
I bought it used (it was mint) but replacement is £600 more than what I paid for it.

I could live with a cash settlement for what i paid but would be disappointed with vouchers as I wouldn't be able buy pre owned again.

ShortShift811

650 posts

173 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
Most household insurance policies will replace items on a 'new for old' basis and ask that you specify valuable items that are above a certain limit and / or used or worn away from home.

As above, get an independent valuation from a reputable source and speak to your insurers aboout covering the item on this agreed value. The difference in premium should be negligible in most cases. Some insurers may also agree to give you cash rather than vouchers, espcially if the items can't easily be found at a mainstream shop.

Insurers I know of that used to do this are Hiscox, AXA and Aviva. Maybe also try your local NFU agent.

No affiliation with any of the above; I'm a commercial insurance broker and these are simply insurers I have dealt with for my own policies in the past.

GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
kingston12 said:
I am just doing my insurance renewal and want to make sure they are covered. As I'd expect, most insurers want to cover the items for the invoice price I paid rather than the retail value of the item.
Thats indemnity cover. Most insurance policies cover on a new for old basis, so an old Omega gets you a new Omega.

I wouldnt entertain indemnity cover (and then only for specific items) unless the watch was worth significantly more than a new replacement: pre-Pro Speedy etc.

Edited by GC8 on Wednesday 3rd July 00:01

ecain63

10,653 posts

206 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
If you have the correct insurance valuation done and declare all to your insurance provider then sure, you'll pay larger amounts on your premium. However, a good valuation and policy will ensure you get like for like or new for old should the worst happen.

jhw333

95 posts

162 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
I understand the new for old thing.

One thing I have a watch thats obviously pretty sentimental to me, I haven't insured it yet as I thought if the worst happens the insurance provide you with new replacement. While watch in question is still produced all these years on (still under same model name) only slightly different, I wouldn't want a new one it would have to be a birth year one (which is rarer than rocking horse ...)

What would happen in this scenario? I have a pretty valuable watch not insured directly because of this.

ecain63

10,653 posts

206 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
I'm sure if you spoke to your provider you could negotiate a cash or voucher payout if lost or stolen. Best thing to do is call them and be positive, firm and honest.

matts4

2,117 posts

222 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
ShortShift811 said:
Most household insurance policies will replace items on a 'new for old' basis and ask that you specify valuable items that are above a certain limit and / or used or worn away from home.

As above, get an independent valuation from a reputable source and speak to your insurers aboout covering the item on this agreed value. The difference in premium should be negligible in most cases. Some insurers may also agree to give you cash rather than vouchers, espcially if the items can't easily be found at a mainstream shop.

Insurers I know of that used to do this are Hiscox, AXA and Aviva. Maybe also try your local NFU agent.

No affiliation with any of the above; I'm a commercial insurance broker and these are simply insurers I have dealt with for my own policies in the past.
I placed the claim late yesterday evening, (with Aviva) and told them all the details when they asked what it was worth and where I purchased it. I obviously told them I'd bought it used, and not paid retail money for it. I wanted to be as up front as possible and am not trying to pull the wool over anyone's eyes.
They said they'd be in touch with their supply people and they would call me over the next couple of days.

If they do replace old with new, then it looks like the new model is now £1,750. However, I have found a pre-owned one of the exact same model that I had, at a dealer, for £1,295.
I'd be happy with either to be honest, but possibly happier with the used one, as I just like the design better.



Tino

1,948 posts

314 months

Wednesday 3rd July 2013
quotequote all
matts4 said:
I placed the claim late yesterday evening, (with Aviva) and told them all the details when they asked what it was worth and where I purchased it. I obviously told them I'd bought it used, and not paid retail money for it. I wanted to be as up front as possible and am not trying to pull the wool over anyone's eyes.
They said they'd be in touch with their supply people and they would call me over the next couple of days.

If they do replace old with new, then it looks like the new model is now £1,750. However, I have found a pre-owned one of the exact same model that I had, at a dealer, for £1,295.
I'd be happy with either to be honest, but possibly happier with the used one, as I just like the design better.
Fairly sure if you took your new watch into the dealers store, he would probably be happy to swap.
AQlternatively sell the high street vouchers and get the watch you want.
I'd much rather have a Sub 14060m over the new ceramic ones

matts4

2,117 posts

222 months

Thursday 11th July 2013
quotequote all
Just to round this off.
Claim lodged last Monday evening (9 days ago) for my second hand watch which I had robbed off my wrist last Saturday evening, 10 days ago.
Payment (voucher) received for brand new replacement yesterday, so replacement is now on my wrist.

Aviva claims service has been exceptional.

vinnie83

3,367 posts

224 months

Sunday 14th July 2013
quotequote all
kingston12 said:
Thanks to advice on here, I have picked up a watch and a diamond ring at a significant discount to the high street price.

I am just doing my insurance renewal and want to make sure they are covered. As I'd expect, most insurers want to cover the items for the invoice price I paid rather than the retail value of the item.

That is absolutely fine because I would not exepct to make a profit if the worst happened, but the problem is the insurers would also pay out in high street jewellers vouchers.

Whilst I could re-buy the items that I have got from the same suppliers for the same price, if I go into Ernest Jones or equivalant, I'd be anything up to 40% short.

Does anyone have any recommended insurers who don't use high street vouchers, or insure at full high street replacement value?
You can make a profit on the item.

No different to you getting the item as a gift, which costs you £0, but you wish to insure it.

I paid £1300 for my Tag Carrera and it's more than double that retail now. I insure it for the cost of replacement. In cash, I make a profit (by your reasoning above) but in reality, I am reimbursed to the sum required to replace the item.

Hope that makes sense.