Sharp Practice by Cartier Jeweller?
Sharp Practice by Cartier Jeweller?
Author
Discussion

bad company

Original Poster:

21,920 posts

297 months

Tuesday 23rd July 2013
quotequote all
I took Mrs BC's Tank American in for a new battery. The watch was working perfectly but as we were are going on holiday shortly and we did not want the battery to fail while away it seemed like a good idea. The last battery was fitted 2 years previously. I was advised that the cost would be £70 and the watch would be ready in 2 weeks.

Three weeks later I had heard nothing so phoned the shop this morning. After 3 more 'chase up' calls they finally phoned back. They said that the watch needed a full service at a cost of £340 and would be ready in 5 weeks! . censored I asked them to fit a new battery as the watch was working when I took it in but they said that the new battery would not work and the watch needs a service. frownfrown

Does this seem right?

robsa

2,472 posts

215 months

Tuesday 23rd July 2013
quotequote all
It would really depend on how old the watch is and how often the battery has been changed. Quartz watches still need servicing, it just tends to be far less than, er, 'proper' automatic movements.

I assume the watch cost you many thousands, so it doesn't sound too bad to me. If you really want to be horrified, take a look at the new RRPs of Rolex watches.... talk about price hike!

ecain63

10,653 posts

206 months

Tuesday 23rd July 2013
quotequote all
Hmm. Sounds iffy. Cartier movements are notorious for being easily damaged during maintenance work (copper wire coil is exposed rather than clear coated for protection). Its too easy on these watches to clip the copper wire with a screwdriver or tip of your tweasers when opening them up or when lifting out the movement and then its game over for the shop as far as an in-house fix goes. Not saying thats what happened but for it to have to go away for a 'battery / service' for 5 weeks i can only think theyve messed up somewhere. Of course it could just be a miscommunication and they thought you meant service instead of battery.

pincher

10,641 posts

248 months

Tuesday 23rd July 2013
quotequote all
Did you sign anything to say what work was being undertaken I.e. an authorisation form or something similar?

If so, and it simply says battery fitting, I'd say you have a reasonable case for paying for that and that alone as it was them who decided it needed a service, not you.

I reckon you could kick up quite a fuss if they refused to give you your watch back.

But check the small print on any receipt you may have - there could be some sort of get out clause in there somewhere.

ecain63

10,653 posts

206 months

Tuesday 23rd July 2013
quotequote all
Normally there is a get out clause for battery fitting. The customer should normally be told that it might not be the battery that is at fault and the customer takes responsibility for any remedial work needed to fix the issue. I think in this case, as it was working when you took it in you have cause to complain.

apotek

727 posts

216 months

Wednesday 24th July 2013
quotequote all
I had a similar experience with my wifes Cartier. A local quality jeweller put a new cell in and the watch ran very slow. After a hefty quote from the jewellers I had it serviced in London for about £120.
The problem for us was that it had been left with a dead cell for quite a while. Good luck

Nick M

3,632 posts

254 months

Wednesday 24th July 2013
quotequote all
bad company said:
After 3 more 'chase up' calls they finally phoned back. They said that the watch needed a full service at a cost of £340 and would be ready in 5 weeks! . censored I asked them to fit a new battery as the watch was working when I took it in but they said that the new battery would not work and the watch needs a service. frownfrown

Does this seem right?
Personally, and perhaps because age and experience has provided me with a somewhat jaded or cynical view of things, my bullstometer would be twitching away at a comment like that from a jeweller...

richwig83

15,842 posts

169 months

Wednesday 24th July 2013
quotequote all
Isnt this a bit like buying a Bugatti Veyron and the complaining at the price of servicing. Man up and pay.

Mr_C

2,508 posts

260 months

Wednesday 24th July 2013
quotequote all
Only 2yrs for a battery?

The battery in a tag I've got lasted 7yrs!

bad company

Original Poster:

21,920 posts

297 months

Wednesday 24th July 2013
quotequote all
[quote=richwig83]Isnt this a bit like buying a Bugatti Veyron and the complaining at the price of servicing. Man up and pay. [/quote

I'm going to do just that. BUT it all leaves a bad taste particularly as I do not believe that the watch would not start with the new battery when it was working perfectly well with the old one.

richwig83

15,842 posts

169 months

Wednesday 24th July 2013
quotequote all
They probably got some wording wrong along the way.

I'm sure it would work if they just replaced the battery but as its in, you might as well get it serviced. There use of "won't work" is a bit shi**y agreed.

I'm sure my watch will go 10 years without a service despite the maker saying it needs it.

Adrian W

15,623 posts

259 months

Wednesday 24th July 2013
quotequote all
you have no contract of any type with them, ask for your watch back.

Perec

28,176 posts

253 months

Wednesday 24th July 2013
quotequote all
bad company said:
I took Mrs BC's Tank American in for a new battery. The watch was working perfectly but as we were are going on holiday shortly and we did not want the battery to fail while away it seemed like a good idea. The last battery was fitted 2 years previously. I was advised that the cost would be £70 and the watch would be ready in 2 weeks.

Three weeks later I had heard nothing so phoned the shop this morning. After 3 more 'chase up' calls they finally phoned back. They said that the watch needed a full service at a cost of £340 and would be ready in 5 weeks! . censored I asked them to fit a new battery as the watch was working when I took it in but they said that the new battery would not work and the watch needs a service. frownfrown

Does this seem right?
This whole situation seems odd, honestly. Having a watch battery changed ahead of a holiday "just in case" suggests impressive attention to detail. Assuming there were no other issues obviously.

If you were told two weeks, that would suggest the battery wasn't being replaced at the AD, the watch was going back to Cartier. If the AD had been doing it you'd have been looking at 2 hours or 2 days perhaps. If Cartier damaged a movement they would just replace it, I would have thought, the cost of doing so is too small to not do so. They don't need to fleece you to cover up their cock-ups.

I'm going to say there has been a "misunderstanding" here. I suspect that the AD said "we'll send it off and IF it only needs a battery it will be two weeks". You heard "It will be two weeks and £70".

But assuming the watch was working perfectly before you sent it off, this situation would seem to reinforce the maxim that if it aint broke, don't fix it.

BrabusMog

21,824 posts

217 months

Wednesday 24th July 2013
quotequote all
Perec said:
bad company said:
I took Mrs BC's Tank American in for a new battery. The watch was working perfectly but as we were are going on holiday shortly and we did not want the battery to fail while away it seemed like a good idea. The last battery was fitted 2 years previously. I was advised that the cost would be £70 and the watch would be ready in 2 weeks.

Three weeks later I had heard nothing so phoned the shop this morning. After 3 more 'chase up' calls they finally phoned back. They said that the watch needed a full service at a cost of £340 and would be ready in 5 weeks! . censored I asked them to fit a new battery as the watch was working when I took it in but they said that the new battery would not work and the watch needs a service. frownfrown

Does this seem right?
This whole situation seems odd, honestly. Having a watch battery changed ahead of a holiday "just in case" suggests impressive attention to detail. Assuming there were no other issues obviously.

If you were told two weeks, that would suggest the battery wasn't being replaced at the AD, the watch was going back to Cartier. If the AD had been doing it you'd have been looking at 2 hours or 2 days perhaps. If Cartier damaged a movement they would just replace it, I would have thought, the cost of doing so is too small to not do so. They don't need to fleece you to cover up their cock-ups.

I'm going to say there has been a "misunderstanding" here. I suspect that the AD said "we'll send it off and IF it only needs a battery it will be two weeks". You heard "It will be two weeks and £70".

But assuming the watch was working perfectly before you sent it off, this situation would seem to reinforce the maxim that if it aint broke, don't fix it.
2 weeks or 2 days for a battery to be changed? My old TAG needed a new battery, took it to a chap in Guildford and watched him change it in 3 minutes. Granted I didn't ask for it to be pressure tested etc.

Regardless of that point, I'd expect a phone call if more work was going to be required, not to have to chase up the jeweller and then be told it's going to take longer and cost more money!

Perec

28,176 posts

253 months

Wednesday 24th July 2013
quotequote all
BrabusMog said:
Perec said:
bad company said:
I took Mrs BC's Tank American in for a new battery. The watch was working perfectly but as we were are going on holiday shortly and we did not want the battery to fail while away it seemed like a good idea. The last battery was fitted 2 years previously. I was advised that the cost would be £70 and the watch would be ready in 2 weeks.

Three weeks later I had heard nothing so phoned the shop this morning. After 3 more 'chase up' calls they finally phoned back. They said that the watch needed a full service at a cost of £340 and would be ready in 5 weeks! . censored I asked them to fit a new battery as the watch was working when I took it in but they said that the new battery would not work and the watch needs a service. frownfrown

Does this seem right?
This whole situation seems odd, honestly. Having a watch battery changed ahead of a holiday "just in case" suggests impressive attention to detail. Assuming there were no other issues obviously.

If you were told two weeks, that would suggest the battery wasn't being replaced at the AD, the watch was going back to Cartier. If the AD had been doing it you'd have been looking at 2 hours or 2 days perhaps. If Cartier damaged a movement they would just replace it, I would have thought, the cost of doing so is too small to not do so. They don't need to fleece you to cover up their cock-ups.

I'm going to say there has been a "misunderstanding" here. I suspect that the AD said "we'll send it off and IF it only needs a battery it will be two weeks". You heard "It will be two weeks and £70".

But assuming the watch was working perfectly before you sent it off, this situation would seem to reinforce the maxim that if it aint broke, don't fix it.
2 weeks or 2 days for a battery to be changed? My old TAG needed a new battery, took it to a chap in Guildford and watched him change it in 3 minutes. Granted I didn't ask for it to be pressure tested etc.

Regardless of that point, I'd expect a phone call if more work was going to be required, not to have to chase up the jeweller and then be told it's going to take longer and cost more money!
ADs will take longer than Shakil down at Watchlab and I suspect that there are two sides to this story, only one of which are we likely to hear.

bad company

Original Poster:

21,920 posts

297 months

Wednesday 24th July 2013
quotequote all
I don't think I am allowed to say where I took the watch but it is in New Bond Street, London, W1

Perec

28,176 posts

253 months

Wednesday 24th July 2013
quotequote all
bad company said:
I don't think I am allowed to say where I took the watch but it is in New Bond Street, London, W1
Do you mean Cartier's own shop there?

Davel

8,982 posts

289 months

Wednesday 24th July 2013
quotequote all
Have had exactly the same issue with my Cartier.

Every time the watch needs a battery - it needs another service.

Once they serviced it, without my permission and asked for the full cost and saying that I'd authorised the work.

I denied this and they then settled on just the cost of the replacement battery.

It does seem a bit of sharp practice to me.

Perec

28,176 posts

253 months

Wednesday 24th July 2013
quotequote all
Davel said:
Have had exactly the same issue with my Cartier.

Every time the watch needs a battery - it needs another service.

Once they serviced it, without my permission and asked for the full cost and saying that I'd authorised the work.

I denied this and they then settled on just the cost of the replacement battery.

It does seem a bit of sharp practice to me.
To balance the discussion here: I sent a Tank Francaise back to Cartier which had experienced salt water ingress, the movement was rusty and the bracelet was looking scruffy. The movement in fact didn't erm... move.... A local repairer said it needed a new one. Cartier sorted the watch out and sent it back like new for the cost of a service - £315.00, which is less than the retail cost of a movement I believe.


bad company

Original Poster:

21,920 posts

297 months

Wednesday 24th July 2013
quotequote all
Perec said:
Do you mean Cartier's own shop there?
Not supposed to say - naming and shaming & all that. wink