Who's actually done this?
Discussion
The problem is that there are few watches that can pass muster in the 'any place, any time' stakes. Rolex Sub can, but there aren't many IMHO. So anyone used to having a sports, dress, tool, complicated, (as a bare minimum) would, like me, struggle to reduce the collection to just one piece.
the accused said:
......looked at their watch collection and thought "how pointless is it to keep so many watches,especially the ones I hardly ever wear? Think I'll swap the lot for one super special lifetime keeper"!
Ok we've all thought about it, but has anyone actually done it, and how did the decision work out ?
Not one, but I have sold off my cheaper watches in favour of three "quality" items. One Rolex sports watch, one Cartier dress watch and a Tag SEL Chronometer that I have had for years and which has sentimental importance for me.Ok we've all thought about it, but has anyone actually done it, and how did the decision work out ?
An aside: The Tag is 20 years old, still looks excellent after much wear and keeps perfect time despite never having had a service. Underrated watch methinks.
Vvroom said:
Too fragile as a daily wearer? Perhaps not.
Gold case makes it unsuitable as a daily I think, I'd prefer steel. However, I am now seriously considering revisiting this plan... Although some REALLY hard choices to make 
Would likely cost me:
Zenith Stratos 1/10th
Reverso Chrono Retrograde
AMVOX 2
Breitling Spatiographe
Vintage Breitling Cosmonaute
Limited edition TAG Monaco

I keep a float of no more than 5 to stop me buying stuff I'm not going to use.
I'm usually crap at keeping to such things, but this works well for me. It's not that there aren't more than that I'd like, just that it would get out of hand, and cost a bloody fortune.
So I've got my perfect smart watch, sport watch and a go anywhere, drive over it for fun g-shock. So, the smart ones among you will note that that leaves space for 2 more, which is great as I can then pounce on something on a whim without breaking the rules.
I'm usually crap at keeping to such things, but this works well for me. It's not that there aren't more than that I'd like, just that it would get out of hand, and cost a bloody fortune.
So I've got my perfect smart watch, sport watch and a go anywhere, drive over it for fun g-shock. So, the smart ones among you will note that that leaves space for 2 more, which is great as I can then pounce on something on a whim without breaking the rules.
Edited by Dr Nookie on Monday 12th August 12:47
Edited by Dr Nookie on Monday 12th August 14:26
the accused said:
......looked at their watch collection and thought "how pointless is it to keep so many watches,especially the ones I hardly ever wear? Think I'll swap the lot for one super special lifetime keeper"!
Ok we've all thought about it, but has anyone actually done it, and how did the decision work out ?
Haven't taken the plunge yet, but have considered it for many months. Don't quite have the £ tied up that yeti might have Ok we've all thought about it, but has anyone actually done it, and how did the decision work out ?
but there are one or two "nicer" watches that I've had my eye on for a while that I could cover if I sold the lot, I guess that I haven't done so for a couple of reasons.I really enjoy the versatility of my collection, there's never a moment when I think that I don't have a watch to wear for a particular occasion. Secondly, I don't think that I could be disciplined enough to stick to one or two watches after being used to more.
CardShark said:
I really enjoy the versatility of my collection, there's never a moment when I think that I don't have a watch to wear for a particular occasion.
Agreed - but of the ones I have, I probably wear half a dozen of them regularly. Some I have had a long time though and there's the chance I'll wear them again one day. If not, they're just gathering dust though 
I recently bought a Blancpain FF chronograph. Surprisingly for me, I wear it pretty much every day. It's nice to be a bit smarter every now and again; Daytona or PAM190 (or Breguet XXI I am buying). Or very smart: Breguet 5707. Fancy a change; SD 16600. A 'vintage' day: Carrera, Speedy, Bundeswehr. That's nine. Add a Duometre (to bridge the smart/smartest gap) and that's ten. It should be enough

Actually it's 11, the SuperOcean I bought with my first pay packet 17 years ago is staying.
Would miss the AMVOX, don't really wear the others.
Opinions? And as the OP asked; has anyone done this and were there regrets?
Vvroom said:
The problem is that there are few watches that can pass muster in the 'any place, any time' stakes. Rolex Sub can, but there aren't many IMHO. So anyone used to having a sports, dress, tool, complicated, (as a bare minimum) would, like me, struggle to reduce the collection to just one piece.
Agree apart from the Rolex Sub bit. They might look like a watch for all occasions but there are plenty of places and activities that I could do that would have me leaving my watch at home. For sports, suits, casual and travelling the world (proper travelling visiting third world countries rather than spending 2 weeks in Marbella), perhaps a Casio digital something is a better choice. But it won't satisfy the inner WIS.Reality check; a lot of worry goes into what to wear when.
Does it really matter?
I've worn an analogue G Shock with a very smart tux (proper now tie, expensive shoes, etc) to a very smart event. I can't remember anyone batting an eyelid
Much of the "right watch" thing is in your heads. It's not a problem and caused no harm but believe me, only you actually give a thought to it; no one else worried unless there happens to be a fellow watch geek present!
Does it really matter?
I've worn an analogue G Shock with a very smart tux (proper now tie, expensive shoes, etc) to a very smart event. I can't remember anyone batting an eyelid
Much of the "right watch" thing is in your heads. It's not a problem and caused no harm but believe me, only you actually give a thought to it; no one else worried unless there happens to be a fellow watch geek present!
Vladimir said:
Reality check; a lot of worry goes into what to wear when.
Does it really matter?
I've worn an analogue G Shock with a very smart tux (proper now tie, expensive shoes, etc) to a very smart event. I can't remember anyone batting an eyelid
Much of the "right watch" thing is in your heads. It's not a problem and caused no harm but believe me, only you actually give a thought to it; no one else worried unless there happens to be a fellow watch geek present!
To a degree I agree with this. I've had people on watch websites recoil in horror that I considered wearing a chronograph with a dinner jacket, but I don't think I'd go as far as wearing a G-Shock. They're just to angular, bulky and plasticky in my experience. Maybe there are some handsome ones out there - I'm not sure.Does it really matter?
I've worn an analogue G Shock with a very smart tux (proper now tie, expensive shoes, etc) to a very smart event. I can't remember anyone batting an eyelid
Much of the "right watch" thing is in your heads. It's not a problem and caused no harm but believe me, only you actually give a thought to it; no one else worried unless there happens to be a fellow watch geek present!
Vladimir said:
Does it really matter?
To you? No To me? Yes.
How long until you get this..? It's not about what other people look at or think

You don't understand (or want to) and probably never will. Watches are an all-consuming thing for me, I think about them all day every day. Can't help it, it's just what I do.
So just relax and let the watch idiots be

Mine is about as subtle as you can get for a G shock:
http://www.casio.com/products/archive/Watches/G-Sh...
http://www.casio.com/products/archive/Watches/G-Sh...
yeti said:
To you? No
To me? Yes.
How long until you get this..? It's not about what other people look at or think
You don't understand (or want to) and probably never will. Watches are an all-consuming thing for me, I think about them all day every day. Can't help it, it's just what I do.
So just relax and let the watch idiots be
Seconded, I absolutely buy and wear my watches for me and no one else. Its kind of a joke with my mates that I can spend minutes looking at the watch on my wrst and not have a clue what time it is, I also fi d myself endlessly trawling websites for the latest watch. My mantra for watches is if I like it and I can afford it, I buy it. This so far has netted me a wide selection ranging from a red £13.99 casio digital to a patek nautilus. The crazy thing is I like them both equally!!To me? Yes.
How long until you get this..? It's not about what other people look at or think

You don't understand (or want to) and probably never will. Watches are an all-consuming thing for me, I think about them all day every day. Can't help it, it's just what I do.
So just relax and let the watch idiots be

Gassing Station | Watches | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


