Restricted supplies of automatic movements
Restricted supplies of automatic movements
Author
Discussion

SVS

Original Poster:

3,824 posts

302 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
Switzerland's competition authorities have paused the Swatch Group's intention to restrict supplies of parts for automatic watch movements. I wonder how long this pause will last.

It does seem that Swatch is seeking to behave anti-competitively. What happens to your beloved non-Swatch watch when you can no longer get parts to maintain its ETA movement?

http://www.watchtime.com/wristwatch-industry-news/...readit

Thoughts?

Variomatic

2,392 posts

192 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
As an independent repairer, my thoughts on Swatch group recently are pretty well unprintable.

This, at least, prevents them from completely shutting the door on supplies in the near future and gives the competition a chance to move to other suppliers - I hear that uality from the Far East is coming on in leaps and bounds wink

While I can understand the argument that "they make them, they can restrict them", the fact is that there are an awful lot of non-Swatch group Swiss watches out there which have been made, sold and bought in good faith on the basis that Swiss watches are maintainable.

If they want to restrict new product from the start then, by all means, let them, but cutting the opposition off at the knees for products they've already sold is almost the definition of anti-competetive abuse of a (near) monopoly.

SVS

Original Poster:

3,824 posts

302 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
I totally agree. Though Swatch may have shot itself in the foot, because Citizen looks like it will fill the vacuum. Citizen even looks well positioned to make 'Swiss made' movements!

http://forums.watchuseek.com/f2/new-citizen-signat...readit

Variomatic

2,392 posts

192 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
I've always suspected that the only thing really holding Citizen / Miyota back is the snobbery in certain circles that will never accept that a "quality" watch can come from anywhere but Switzerland. Within that idset, even owning pet Swiss companies to get round the marketing rules doesn't work - "we all know xxx is japanese really". Why chase a market that doesn't want to accept you when you can dominate most other sectors like they do?

But people generally don't like being told what to buy, and Swatch are effectively trying to say "if you want Swiss, buy from us". That seems to me to be a very dangerous game, especially with the amount of information which is so readily available in the Internet age.

If they'd done this 20 years ago, people would still have "bought Swiss" blissfully unaware of the possible problems maintaining their investment in the future. Nowadays, every move is reported, discussed and analysed so widely that no-one will be taken by surprise. The available alternatives are also more easily seen than ever before, meaning that anyone considering investing in anything out of the ordinary has no real excuse for not being fully informed.

And an informed consumer is far less likely to display blind brand (or national) loyalty than their father or grandfather was!

costsmonkey

195 posts

187 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Is it now not a good idea to buy a non Swatch group watch with an ETA movement?

If you do buy one, do you run a significant risk of running into difficulties with servicing and obtaining spare parts in due course.

If so, there are likely to be a lot of brands looking for a new supply chain for non ETA movements.

michael gould

5,698 posts

272 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Variomatic said:
I've always suspected that the only thing really holding Citizen / Miyota back is the snobbery in certain circles that will never accept that a "quality" watch can come from anywhere but Switzerland. Within that idset, even owning pet Swiss companies to get round the marketing rules doesn't work - "we all know xxx is japanese really". Why chase a market that doesn't want to accept you when you can dominate most other sectors like they do?

But people generally don't like being told what to buy, and Swatch are effectively trying to say "if you want Swiss, buy from us". That seems to me to be a very dangerous game, especially with the amount of information which is so readily available in the Internet age.

If they'd done this 20 years ago, people would still have "bought Swiss" blissfully unaware of the possible problems maintaining their investment in the future. Nowadays, every move is reported, discussed and analysed so widely that no-one will be taken by surprise. The available alternatives are also more easily seen than ever before, meaning that anyone considering investing in anything out of the ordinary has no real excuse for not being fully informed.

And an informed consumer is far less likely to display blind brand (or national) loyalty than their father or grandfather was!
I have some sympathy with this view......the best sports car in the world at the moment is not European but Japanese the LFA

I think it's about time ETA stopped supplying movements which will, and indeed has resulted in so called high end watch makers get off their fat arses and make their own movements.......in the long term this has to be a good thing. The Public have been conned long enough by the likes of Breitling Channel IWC to name but a few ........I hope we do see high end watches come out of Japan or the USA or wherever



PJ S

10,842 posts

258 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
You'll be fine as most used ETA movements are replicated by Sellita, so direct drop-in replacement parts or whole movement will be available to whomever repairs/services the watch.

SVS

Original Poster:

3,824 posts

302 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
michael gould said:
I have some sympathy with this view......the best sports car in the world at the moment is not European but Japanese the LFA

I think it's about time ETA stopped supplying movements which will, and indeed has resulted in so called high end watch makers get off their fat arses and make their own movements.......in the long term this has to be a good thing. The Public have been conned long enough by the likes of Breitling Channel IWC to name but a few ........I hope we do see high end watches come out of Japan or the USA or wherever
What about Grand Seiko? Arguably a lot better than many of the big Swiss brands' watches. Solid watchmaking history. Highly innovative, e.g. spring drive, Dia-Shield.

I read that Seiko was banned from competing in the COSC accuracy completions, because Seiko kept beating the all the Swiss watch brands:
http://forums.watchuseek.com/f21/what-world-grand-...readit



Edited by SVS on Monday 19th August 18:05

SVS

Original Poster:

3,824 posts

302 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Bremont is moving from a Swiss movement to its own in-house movement. This will be the first all-British watch produced since the First World War!

www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/markets/article-239240...

woots787

142 posts

180 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
SVS said:
Bremont is moving from a Swiss movement to its own in-house movement. This will be the first all-British watch produced since the First World War!

www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/markets/article-239240...
Not exactly production but Robert Loomes? Plus didn't Smiths produce watches after the first world war or was that when they went to swiss movements? Anyway good on bremont, they've done very well in a short space of time and its good to see more manufactures making movements in house.

woots787

142 posts

180 months

Craikeybaby

12,177 posts

256 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Interesting, I was thinking of buying either an Oris or a Longines and had been swinging towards the Oris, but if Swatch are going to make things difficult for spares etc, that isn't ideal.

CardShark

4,264 posts

210 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Craikeybaby said:
Interesting, I was thinking of buying either an Oris or a Longines and had been swinging towards the Oris, but if Swatch are going to make things difficult for spares etc, that isn't ideal.
I'm pretty sure that one or two Oris watches (and maybe more) use Sellita movements - basically copies of ETAs. Either way I wouldn't be so concerned, as has been said already servicing shouldn't be an issue in the future.

ETA Oris is independently owned (ie not by ETAs owners Swatch or the other 2 large groups), maybe they saw the movement restriction thing coming some time back and their use of Sellita was in preparation. Fair move by them, regardless of the recent judgement.




Edited by CardShark on Tuesday 20th August 13:02

michael gould

5,698 posts

272 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
swatch or ETA are not restricting parts they are restricting ebauches or movement blanks from which manufacturers such as IWC finish and stamp their own name to

Tanguero

4,535 posts

232 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
SVS said:
...This will be the first all-British watch produced since the First World War!...
Apart from George Daniels, Roger Smith and a number of other independent horologists.

mikeveal

5,141 posts

281 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
CardShark said:
I'm pretty sure that one or two Oris watches (and maybe more) use Sellita movements - basically copies of ETAs. Either way I wouldn't be so concerned, as has been said already servicing shouldn't be an issue in the future.

ETA Oris is independently owned (ie not by ETAs owners Swatch or the other 2 large groups), maybe they saw the movement restriction thing coming some time back and their use of Sellita was in preparation. Fair move by them, regardless of the recent judgement.
Edited by CardShark on Tuesday 20th August 13:02
Oris have an interesting history. They were just outside of the Swiss national boundary and therefore not allowed to use the lever escapement - the one thing that made Swiss watches batter than the rest of the world. Instead they concentrated on the pin pallet, an escapment that was considered inferior and effectively throw away. During the period that they were not allowed to manufacture lever escapements, they became very, very good at pin pallets and the accuracy of their watches rivalled those of the Swiss lever escapements.

If they're not using ETA, I am unsurprised.

CardShark

4,264 posts

210 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
^^ Very interesting thumbup

michael gould

5,698 posts

272 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Tanguero said:
SVS said:
...This will be the first all-British watch produced since the First World War!...
Apart from George Daniels, Roger Smith and a number of other independent horologists.
ahhhhh the great and the good......but I think Roger Smith only makes 8 watches per year and I think they start at about 60k.....and his old "tutor" George in very unwell

CardShark

4,264 posts

210 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
michael gould said:
.....and his old "tutor" George is very unwell
hehe

sparkyhx

4,200 posts

235 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Variomatic said:
I've always suspected that the only thing really holding Citizen / Miyota back is the snobbery in certain circles that will never accept that a "quality" watch can come from anywhere but Switzerland. Within that idset, even owning pet Swiss companies to get round the marketing rules doesn't work - "we all know xxx is japanese really". Why chase a market that doesn't want to accept you when you can dominate most other sectors like they do?

If they'd done this 20 years ago, people would still have "bought Swiss" blissfully unaware of the possible problems maintaining their investment in the future. Nowadays, every move is reported, discussed and analysed so widely that no-one will be taken by surprise. The available alternatives are also more easily seen than ever before, meaning that anyone considering investing in anything out of the ordinary has no real excuse for not being fully informed.

And an informed consumer is far less likely to display blind brand (or national) loyalty than their father or grandfather was!
Sorry I don't agree. The man on the street looking for a 'quality' watch buys a brand, he may want a 'swiss watch', but generally its the brand. He's not even likely to know the subtle difference between 'Swiss Made' 'Swiss Movement' etc and the fact it may contain a large portion of chinese bits. You could get a completely Chinese movemnet watch and still call it 'swiss made'.

If Citizen started assembling watches in switzerland, launched a swiss sounding brand, labelled them swiss made, and spent a shed load on marketing, most people wouldn't have a clue. But they'd be lucky to break into the Rolex/Breitling/Omega/Tag strangle hold on the high street. Most people haven't heard of JLC, IWC, Chopard, Panerai let alone Patek, Lange, Glashutte, Audemars etc

Its only people like us who are interested/anal enough to look up this stuff.

I'm curious this has happened now. ETA siad they were doing this years ago and the govt got involved and told them to extend the deadline (2010?).

Edited by sparkyhx on Tuesday 20th August 16:21