Jaeger or Girard???
Jaeger or Girard???
Author
Discussion

Paracetamol

Original Poster:

4,267 posts

275 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
I am about to buy one or the other of the following...cant quite make up my mind - can anyone help!!




Ikemi

8,611 posts

236 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
My vote goes to the JLC smile

ShadownINja

80,180 posts

313 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
Weird. Two completely different styles of watch. Answer, therefore: Both.

So, shall I get a pair of Nike trainers or a 3 bedroom detached house?

Stu R

21,701 posts

246 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
ShadownINja said:
Weird. Two completely different styles of watch. Answer, therefore: Both.

So, shall I get a pair of Nike trainers or a 3 bedroom detached house?
Don't be a smartass, they share much in common. The straps for example - both black leather, and the faces - both have numbers and hands on. biggrin

I agree though, two totally different watches there OP. Personally, I prefer the former, though normally I'd take a JLC over most stuff. I can think of countless examples of similarly priced watches I'd rather have - neither are really my cup of char.

ShadownINja

80,180 posts

313 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
Well, I'll take the GP for casual days and the JLC for office days.

RDMcG

20,916 posts

238 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
I am biased, but I like the Jaeger for its classic design. I bought one years ago and still have it. (Its a Reverso Duetto and is incredibly low key and discreet which is nice.)


Paracetamol

Original Poster:

4,267 posts

275 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
Hi, to clarify...

I already have a

Rolex SS Oyster Perpetual with the 'sportier' braclet (forgot the name)
A Tag Heuer Monaco (from the late ninties- the first limited edition one that they did)- I do not wear it very often as I would like to pass it on to my kids one day
A Dunhill (similar in shape to the JLT but with a raised glass face)- cannot rememeber its name

I now need a watch that I can wear with smart casual or casual.

My dilema is that the JLC can fill all three roles- Suit, SC and Casual. But the Girard can only do the latter two- though I have the Rolex for Suit days...

However, my best friend, who I went shopping with explained that the JLC is an absloute design classic and and the brand is better known and residulally stronger than the Girard What is putting me off the JLC is that its a manual wind..seems a bit old hat in this day and age...

To top it off, they are both exactly the same price....

Paracetamol

Original Poster:

4,267 posts

275 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
Stu R said:
I can think of countless examples of similarly priced watches I'd rather have - neither are really my cup of char.
My ears and eyes are open...these are costing equivelent of 3.3k gbp here in the middle east

ShadownINja

80,180 posts

313 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
IWC something? Depends on your taste really.

Paracetamol

Original Poster:

4,267 posts

275 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
ShadownINja said:
IWC something? Depends on your taste really.
Saw the Portuguese..very nice as well...will go see it again this evening. Had some real fun in the Patek Phillipe shop...wow!

LukeBird

17,170 posts

240 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
Normally Jaeger for me, but out of the two you posted it would be the GP. smile

MarkoNoTVR

1,139 posts

265 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
Out of those two, the Girard all day long.....

tertius

6,914 posts

261 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
Pictures don't work for me - what are they?

PS RDMcG I think that is a Duo rather than a Duetto ... the Duetto is the rather jewellery version set with diamonds

Paracetamol

Original Poster:

4,267 posts

275 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
Seems to be some issue with the image upload...I will try to re-attach

RDMcG

20,916 posts

238 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
tertius said:
Pictures don't work for me - what are they?

PS RDMcG I think that is a Duo rather than a Duetto ... the Duetto is the rather jewellery version set with diamonds
You are of course right..(OH has the Duetto which is a tad blingy for mesmile

Dr S

5,162 posts

257 months

Wednesday 1st September 2010
quotequote all
JLC anyday. Their movements are all of manufacture standard and the desings are absolute classics. Probably the best value for money mechanical watch there is

blindswelledrat

25,257 posts

263 months

Wednesday 1st September 2010
quotequote all
Personally I'd have the Girard any day.
The Jaeger looks a bit formal and dare I say boring. It would look wrong in casual IMO
The Girard is excellent and would look fine no matter where you wore it (maybe not brilliant formal)

Edited by blindswelledrat on Wednesday 1st September 16:11

tertius

6,914 posts

261 months

Wednesday 1st September 2010
quotequote all
Aha, at last I can see the pics, well, I already have a G-P extremely similar to that one, so I'd definitely have the JLC ... does that help?

For what its worth I do think the JLC is far the classier watch, with a true manufacture movement in an absolutely iconic design. Assuming the G-P is the same movement as mine (pic below) then it is a modular chronograph, with a Dubois Depraz chrono module, piggy backed onto an in-house G-P time only movement (the 3300 iirc).

There are a couple of considerations with a modular chrono like that:

1. its fearfully complicated and accordingly servicing can be pricey

2. I think because of slack in the drive train (presumably due to the modular construction) it has a very annoying habit where after you set the time the minute hand can take some seconds (perhaps up to 30) to start to move. If like me, you like to set the time exactly with the minute hand on the minute marker, this can be very annoying. It can be greatly reduced if you only adjust the time forwards, i.e. don't overshoot by a couple of minutes and wind it back, rather wait for time catch up.

Finally the G-P will lose money hand over fist, so try not to pay anything like RRP for it.


Paracetamol

Original Poster:

4,267 posts

275 months

Wednesday 1st September 2010
quotequote all
tertius said:
Finally the G-P will lose money hand over fist, so try not to pay anything like RRP for it
Hi - thought these were good for residuals? is that not so?

tertius

6,914 posts

261 months

Wednesday 1st September 2010
quotequote all
Paracetamol said:
tertius said:
Finally the G-P will lose money hand over fist, so try not to pay anything like RRP for it
Hi - thought these were good for residuals? is that not so?
I would say not, especially considering what I paid for mine.

I don't know why but G-P do not seem to be very sought after in the used market. I really like them, super watches and very well made.

To be clear the JLC won't be brilliant either (certainly not in the sports Rolex class) but it will do better than G-P I would expect.

Check asking prices on timezone.com - that should give a reasonable idea. As examples, there is a Monte Carlo chrono (quite similar to the one you picture) with bracelet, assuming the ad is correct the rrp is $12.8k and the seller is asking $5k, a ww.tc chrono, RRP 15k asking 4.3k. Also a few others (not so complete/nice) around the $3k mark, etc..