Anyone on here buy milk in bags?
Anyone on here buy milk in bags?
Author
Discussion

thatone1967

Original Poster:

4,246 posts

219 months

Saturday 14th May 2011
quotequote all
Seen these in the local Sainsburys for a while now, but always shyed away for fear of bursting one. Just wondered if anyone on here uses them and how sturdy they are?

Bullett

11,168 posts

212 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
No.

We have a milkman though so glass bottles that get reused and delivered in an electric van. Don't get much more eco than that.

Mr Dave

3,233 posts

223 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
I worked for sainsburys for a bit and got a few of them free and to be honest I go through too much milk it was impractical, one of the bags burst on me on the way home but I did drop a good few putting them out for sale, supposedly less mess but you have to wash the jug after every bag really.

No real advantage for the end user, but a lot less bulk and waste for the supermarket chains. Which isnt a bad thing really.

So- if you use not a lot of milk its handy and will rarely burst, if you use a lot of milk its too much hassle.

tenex

1,010 posts

196 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
I haven't seen these (the nearest Sainsburys is 200 miles away).
Same idea was trialled up here in the seventies. Total crap. Once the bag was open it lost it's structural strength and pouring was virtually impossible.

T84

6,941 posts

222 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
Yes, you get it everywhere here (Montreal) smile

T84

6,941 posts

222 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
tenex said:
I haven't seen these (the nearest Sainsburys is 200 miles away).
Same idea was trialled up here in the seventies. Total crap. Once the bag was open it lost it's structural strength and pouring was virtually impossible.
You cut the corner off and put the bag in a jug, then tip the jug to pour the contents of the bag.

Shaw Tarse

31,875 posts

231 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
As tenex said "milk bags" are an old idea, I suppose they could work if you are happy to decant the milk into a jug?

T84

6,941 posts

222 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
You don't need to decant them, you just place the bag (Which is jug shaped roughly) into a plastic jug, cut the top corner off, and then use that to pour the milk, thus meaning that the inside of the jug doesn't get dirty, and that by having the 'rigid' structure at home means that supermarkets/etc can cut down on expensive, hard to store and transport rigid cartons.

Bloody hell.

Shaw Tarse

31,875 posts

231 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
T84 said:
You don't need to decant them, you just place the bag (Which is jug shaped roughly) into a plastic jug, cut the top corner off, and then use that to pour the milk, thus meaning that the inside of the jug doesn't get dirty, and that by having the 'rigid' structure at home means that supermarkets/etc can cut down on expensive, hard to store and transport rigid cartons.

Bloody hell.
So why didn't the idea catch on 30ish years ago?

T84

6,941 posts

222 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
I don't know :-D

I imagine we probably have a resident "Plastic milk bag and jug combo market success analyst" on here so if you can hold on you'll probably have a reply in the morning!

Mr. Potato Head

1,179 posts

247 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
They do beer in bags in China

Hoover.

5,993 posts

270 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
you dont tear the corner off..... just put bag in jug, make small hole part of the jug lid goes through to act as pouring spout.

... takes up more room in ridge, and doesn't come in pint sizes....... bit useless for the single man, as we only buy a pint open it for tea/coffee and throw most of it away when it goes off.

Pints

18,451 posts

222 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
Hoover. said:
you dont tear the corner off..... just put bag in jug, make small hole part of the jug lid goes through to act as pouring spout.

... takes up more room in ridge, and doesn't come in pint sizes....... bit useless for the single man, as we only buy a pint open it for tea/coffee and throw most of it away when it goes off.
Why not just have a glass of milk to drink, rather than throw it away? Few drinks are more refreshing IMO.

Bagged milk is the way it's done in SA.

shirt

25,327 posts

229 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
first time i saw bagged milk was on holiday to israel. the temptation to throw a litre of semi skimmed in my mate's face almost got the better of me. i'd never think of doing it with a bottle so trust me, milk bombing will be the new happy slapping if these take off wink

Puggit

49,742 posts

276 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
Found it very impractical - went straight back to (recyclable) plastic bottles.

I remember at school that the milk used to come in huge big bags with an udder on them (long hose wink). You had to cut the hose to get the milk out, and a clamp allowed you to open up the hose and pour.

When they burst, they made an almight mess. Must have been 20 litres or so...

R TOY

1,747 posts

256 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
Noticed in costa(lot) coffee they had milk in bags, just as been said, bag in jug, cut corner and away you go.
Must work well with the quantity of milk they get thro,
Personally i get mine in one of these.
Milk kept fresh at a constant temp and comes complete with 4 decanting valves smile


marksx

5,174 posts

218 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
They are easy to use. You don't cut the corner off, the spout of the jug punctures the bag when you lock it in place.

They are handy for freezing, but they burst very easily. A few times I have put a bag on the drainer to defrost and returned to an empty bag!

shirt

25,327 posts

229 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
why would you need to freeze milk? like freezing bread, i find the whole idea just bizarre.

marksx

5,174 posts

218 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
shirt said:
why would you need to freeze milk? like freezing bread, i find the whole idea just bizarre.
Apocalypse preparation? biggrin
The fewer times in the shop the better.

NDA

25,425 posts

253 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
Wicker baskets.