Liver seems off.....
Author
Discussion

cramorra

Original Poster:

1,689 posts

263 months

Wednesday 14th November 2012
quotequote all
http://www.caterersearch.com/Articles/14/11/2012/3...

It looks as though the days of perfect pink liver might be numbered, as no less than Brasserie Blanc, Raymond Blanc’s high street French restaurant chain, looks set to abandon serving lamb's liver after customers in Covent Garden got food poisoning. It seems likely that if this chain decides it isn't worth the risk, pretty much everywhere else will have to do the same. And probably that will mean no liver on the menu, as who wants to eat leathery liver? Shame! (found on mattandcat)

what a shame - love it and think that there is a certain risk in ceratin things - aka life
IO am happy to take it - why does the goverment get in the way - nobody has to eat it...

HarryW

16,001 posts

297 months

Wednesday 14th November 2012
quotequote all
I have an old school mindset, offal should be cooked. It might upset chefs, but if I'm paying........

Pothole

34,367 posts

310 months

Wednesday 14th November 2012
quotequote all
cramorra said:
http://www.caterersearch.com/Articles/14/11/2012/3...

It looks as though the days of perfect pink liver might be numbered, as no less than Brasserie Blanc, Raymond Blanc’s high street French restaurant chain, looks set to abandon serving lamb's liver after customers in Covent Garden got food poisoning. It seems likely that if this chain decides it isn't worth the risk, pretty much everywhere else will have to do the same. And probably that will mean no liver on the menu, as who wants to eat leathery liver? Shame! (found on mattandcat)

what a shame - love it and think that there is a certain risk in ceratin things - aka life
IO am happy to take it - why does the goverment get in the way - nobody has to eat it...
If the restaurant was prepared to print full information of the possible consequences I might (MIGHT) go along with you. Cooking food sufficiently to kill well-known nasties is a basic, though, surely? I'm sure Chef Blanc wouldn't serve pink chicken, would he?

21TonyK

13,245 posts

237 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
Read this the other day on the BBC website. First thing I did is run down to the butchers and got some lambs liver for lunch yum

This morning (for breakfast) sliced up a bit and vacced it carefully as one thin layer. Water bath @ 70 as required by FSA for ten minutes then straight into iced water. Let it chill then flashed in hot butter for 30 seconds each side and a splash of hot gravy, reduce for another 20-30 seconds. Still pink, no running blood but didn't dry out. Another 30 seconds in the pan would have been too much but it was interesting as an experiment.

Melman Giraffe

6,794 posts

246 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
21TonyK said:
Read this the other day on the BBC website. First thing I did is run down to the butchers and got some lambs liver for lunch yum

This morning (for breakfast) sliced up a bit and vacced it carefully as one thin layer. Water bath @ 70 as required by FSA for ten minutes then straight into iced water. Let it chill then flashed in hot butter for 30 seconds each side and a splash of hot gravy, reduce for another 20-30 seconds. Still pink, no running blood but didn't dry out. Another 30 seconds in the pan would have been too much but it was interesting as an experiment.
What was the texture like?

miniman

29,958 posts

290 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
I've had the lamb's liver at Blanc in Bristol and for me it was just too rare. Bordering on raw to be honest. Didn't like it at all.

But it is rather worrying that this is the thin end of the wedge. The FSA will always err well on the side of caution so are we going to end up with "safe" food everywhere? Akin to a Brewer's Fayre on every corner.

21TonyK

13,245 posts

237 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
Melman Giraffe said:
What was the texture like?
It was okay. Me and three other chefs all tried it and agreed that we would personally eat it rarer but for 90% of people it would be perfect. Certainly would still describe it as pink and wouldn't send it back as under or over cooked.

Changedmyname

12,549 posts

209 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
HarryW said:
I have an old school mindset, offal should be cooked. It might upset chefs, but if I'm paying........
Indeed

21TonyK

13,245 posts

237 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
Just packed a bit more for lunch, will post a pic later

Melman Giraffe

6,794 posts

246 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
21TonyK said:
Just packed a bit more for lunch, will post a pic later
How was lunch?

Output Flange

17,047 posts

239 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
Talking of liver, I was watching Monday's Pro Masterchef last night, and the classics test was monkfish liver. I've never had it, and hadn't realised it was something that people make a dish out of.

What's it like?

Melman Giraffe

6,794 posts

246 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
Output Flange said:
Talking of liver, I was watching Monday's Pro Masterchef last night, and the classics test was monkfish liver. I've never had it, and hadn't realised it was something that people make a dish out of.

What's it like?
Very strong flavour not to everyone's liking

Pete Franklin

849 posts

209 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
21TonyK said:
Read this the other day on the BBC website. First thing I did is run down to the butchers and got some lambs liver for lunch yum

This morning (for breakfast) sliced up a bit and vacced it carefully as one thin layer. Water bath @ 70 as required by FSA for ten minutes then straight into iced water. Let it chill then flashed in hot butter for 30 seconds each side and a splash of hot gravy, reduce for another 20-30 seconds. Still pink, no running blood but didn't dry out. Another 30 seconds in the pan would have been too much but it was interesting as an experiment.
Interesting thoughts on the sous vide- never considered offal. any thoughts on what the texture would be like after pasturisation at 55dc, that would give a medium rare doneness? Theoretically that would take just over 2hrs (assuming roughly 2.5cm thick using meat charts) but i'm not sure what the texture would end up like. I know offal often has significantly more enzymic activity which might be amplified at these temps.

21TonyK

13,245 posts

237 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
Pete Franklin said:
21TonyK said:
Read this the other day on the BBC website. First thing I did is run down to the butchers and got some lambs liver for lunch yum

This morning (for breakfast) sliced up a bit and vacced it carefully as one thin layer. Water bath @ 70 as required by FSA for ten minutes then straight into iced water. Let it chill then flashed in hot butter for 30 seconds each side and a splash of hot gravy, reduce for another 20-30 seconds. Still pink, no running blood but didn't dry out. Another 30 seconds in the pan would have been too much but it was interesting as an experiment.
Interesting thoughts on the sous vide- never considered offal. any thoughts on what the texture would be like after pasturisation at 55dc, that would give a medium rare doneness? Theoretically that would take just over 2hrs (assuming roughly 2.5cm thick using meat charts) but i'm not sure what the texture would end up like. I know offal often has significantly more enzymic activity which might be amplified at these temps.
Well, this was lunch...



Cooked at 70 for ten minutes then flash fried.



You can;t see the colour properly in this photo but it was an even pink and didn't dry out or overcook. Unfortunately it sat on the pass for a few minutes under lights so it did cook a bit more than I would have ideally liked but still perfectly okay.

Will be on the menu next week lick

I think a lower temp would work quite well but it needs to be for a short period of time or I suspect it would come out like a grey pate!

Re: monkfish liver, very, very strong flavour. Thin slivers pan fried like foie gras on toasts is okay but even then it's quite an overpowering flavour.

miniman

29,958 posts

290 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
That looks delicious. The one I had at Blanc was completely different, closer to raw.

cramorra

Original Poster:

1,689 posts

263 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
21TonyK said:
Well, this was lunch...



Cooked at 70 for ten minutes then flash fried.



You can;t see the colour properly in this photo but it was an even pink and didn't dry out or overcook. Unfortunately it sat on the pass for a few minutes under lights so it did cook a bit more than I would have ideally liked but still perfectly okay.

Will be on the menu next week lick

I think a lower temp would work quite well but it needs to be for a short period of time or I suspect it would come out like a grey pate!

Re: monkfish liver, very, very strong flavour. Thin slivers pan fried like foie gras on toasts is okay but even then it's quite an overpowering flavour.
Damm seem to need a sous vide- possibly time for a new thread...
Looks great and seems worth trying

cramorra

Original Poster:

1,689 posts

263 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
miniman said:
I've had the lamb's liver at Blanc in Bristol and for me it was just too rare. Bordering on raw to be honest. Didn't like it at all.

But it is rather worrying that this is the thin end of the wedge. The FSA will always err well on the side of caution so are we going to end up with "safe" food everywhere? Akin to a Brewer's Fayre on every corner.
This is what I mean - if you don't like it raw don't have it (I am sure they would have done it longer) - but life is z\bout taking risk
The best things involve certain risks - in this country we will have grown ups who have never used a match for risk avoidance everywhere (sorry going off thread here..)

21TonyK

13,245 posts

237 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
cramorra said:
This is what I mean - if you don't like it raw don't have it (I am sure they would have done it longer) - but life is z\bout taking risk
The best things involve certain risks - in this country we will have grown ups who have never used a match for risk avoidance everywhere (sorry going off thread here..)
Just waiting for the day they outlaw rare beef or steak rolleyes

Couple of years back on holiday in Spain they insisted on frying eggs both sides so the yolk was cooked hard. They claimed it was because of EU H&S regs, a month later I was served raw egg on pizza in South of France so I suspect that was crap. Certainly not a requirement in the UK.

I do however know of several places that will not serve a blue steak. Says more about their steak than their chef frown

miniman

29,958 posts

290 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
Fortunately there remain a few bastions of civility; my local's menu proclaims "no well done steaks" and the chef means it.

dazco

4,281 posts

217 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
cramorra said:
miniman said:
I've had the lamb's liver at Blanc in Bristol and for me it was just too rare. Bordering on raw to be honest. Didn't like it at all.

But it is rather worrying that this is the thin end of the wedge. The FSA will always err well on the side of caution so are we going to end up with "safe" food everywhere? Akin to a Brewer's Fayre on every corner.
This is what I mean - if you don't like it raw don't have it (I am sure they would have done it longer) - but life is z\bout taking risk
The best things involve certain risks - in this country we will have grown ups who have never used a match for risk avoidance everywhere (sorry going off thread here..)
he didn't say he was scared, he said he didn't like it.