Stone Roses

[horton]

the selftitled album is the best album ever recorded.

discuss.

if you are too old/young to own this album, then get out of my thread

[Plotloss]

Its great, without doubt the best in its class.

The best album ever? No chance.

[horton]

There a numerous classic songs out there, but Im finding it hard to find an album as full of them as Stone Roses.

[ALawson]

Plotloss said:

Its great, without doubt the best in its class.

The best album ever? No chance.

+1

[DrTre]

horton said:

There a numerous classic songs out there, but Im finding it hard to find an album as full of them as Stone Roses.

I'd always take Screamadelica over Stone Roses.

[absolutely]

ALawson said:

Plotloss said:

Its great, without doubt the best in its class.

The best album ever? No chance.

+1

+2

[Sciroccology]

I'm afraid the whole Madchester/Baggy thing completely passed me by, so I can't agree.

"Fool's Gold" is, however, a very catchy tune.

[horton]

DrTre said:

horton said:

There a numerous classic songs out there, but Im finding it hard to find an album as full of them as Stone Roses.

I'd always take Screamadelica over Stone Roses.

I'd take Vanishing Point over Screamdelica

[DrTre]

horton said:

DrTre said:

horton said:

There a numerous classic songs out there, but Im finding it hard to find an album as full of them as Stone Roses.

I'd always take Screamadelica over Stone Roses.

I'd take Vanishing Point over Screamdelica

Whoah!? Really? VP annoyed the crap out of me after a while, far too many weak tracks...can't think of a single average track on Scream.
Diff'rent strokes

[williamp]

Whats the story, morning glory
OK Computer
The Bends

There's three better ones for a start

[Sciroccology]

williamp said:

Whats the story, morning glory
OK Computer
The Bends

There's three better ones for a start

One Step Beyond
Absolutely
Seven

There's another three.

[25 JET]

I wanna be adored! doesnt get alot better than that, classic Track!

[Fittster]

DrTre said:

horton said:

DrTre said:

horton said:

There a numerous classic songs out there, but Im finding it hard to find an album as full of them as Stone Roses.

I'd always take Screamadelica over Stone Roses.

I'd take Vanishing Point over Screamdelica

Whoah!? Really? VP annoyed the crap out of me after a while, far too many weak tracks...can't think of a single average track on Scream.
Diff'rent strokes

Screamdelica caught/defined the Zeitgeist, Vanishing Point could have been recorded at any point over the last 15 years.

[KANEIT]

25 JET said:

I wanna be adored! doesnt get alot better than that, classic Track!

Ooooooh yes!

[clarkmagpie]

ian brown = legend

[Furyous]

clarkmagpie said:

ian brown = legend

Surely not ?

I saw him as a support for The Manics a few years ago, he was off his face and utterly ste.Even F.E.A.R. was unrecognisable.

Legend ? I think not.

[Yanto]

absolutely said:

ALawson said:

Plotloss said:

Its great, without doubt the best in its class.

The best album ever? No chance.

+1

+2

+3 - if they had included Love Spreads (prob best track) & Fools Gold, would make a great album a mega one.

[Mark V8]

25 JET said:

I wanna be adored! doesnt get alot better than that, classic Track!

I Am The Resurrection gets my vote from that album.

Loud and through headphones, and I'm back in '89, wandering to a party in 32" flared jeans, t-shirt and beads....

Great tunes, great times....

[horton]

williamp said:

Whats the story, morning glory
OK Computer
The Bends

There's three better ones for a start

no offence but radiohead are crap.(not that I expect you to agree)

morning glory is good, I still listen to it, but even someone as musically untalented as myself recognises that it is all presentation, no substance.

[Baby Huey]

Stone Roses, Oasis, Radiohead... Ha!

Best album ever is Back to the World by Curtis Mayfield.

There are about 3 great tracks on the first Stone Roses album, the rest ranges from OK to irritating. I've never trusted the Roses as they started out as a goth band, and judging from their second album and the combined output of the of their former members I think it's fair to say that they got lucky with their debut.

Edited by Baby Huey on Sunday 10th August 07:17