Belly Pan
Author
Discussion

brdee

Original Poster:

3,206 posts

250 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
Hi Guys,

Have been talking with Alan 2 ref fitting a belly pan to the engine compartment which would help keep things clean etc - and yes I know the factory say don't do it, but provided ventilation is taken care of, and A2 says it worked for him, then maybe its worth trying anyway.

How about using something like PolyCarb sheet? - or even Carbon Fibre board? Anyone done this?

My only problem with ally (although I think it looks very nice) is that over time the road-salt etc would make it corrode especially near any contact with metal (electrolysis). I have seen a thread from some guy who has had an ultima for a while and he says he had to repair his fuel tanks for the very same reason!

Which brings me to the second point:
Given that we are connecting ally panels and tanks to steel via rivets made up of both components, we have a very real electrolytic problem here especially whan the vehicle could be exposed to damp or wet conditions. There are ways to minimise the undertray problems, in that I have recently found some stainless steel rivets on offer designed to help combat this common corrosion problem, trouble is it is too late for me.

...So does anyone know of what spray/paint treatment could be used for the underpanels, and even the tanks to stop or reduce corrosion?

luckyp

6,243 posts

254 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
I'm at the stage where I want to protect all the hard work done to date. I've been looking long and hard and this stuff looks the best bet to me so far:

www.fertan.co.uk/item-over_4_bodywork_and_stone_chip_p.htm

Cheers
Pete

brdee

Original Poster:

3,206 posts

250 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
When I read about the corroding Fuel tanks - that put the willies up me - especially as it apparently takes a lot of stripping/ tearing down to get them out for refurb. I think they are quite well exposed under that pod, and you can't see too well what is going on there till you start smelling petrol!

Any-road looks good stuff - have sent them an email to verify aluminium compatability as it seems all reference is to steel/rust coverage!

steve_d

13,802 posts

287 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
I seem to remember the build instruction to paint the underside of the tanks.
Anyway that's what I did with mine starting with etch primer.

Steve

brdee

Original Poster:

3,206 posts

250 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
Thanks Steve,

Not got that far yet so didn't know!
The Guy that suffered the problem (think it was on a Sport) may not have had this done on his!

Anyroad, better to prep for this now rather than later!

brdee

Original Poster:

3,206 posts

250 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
Luckp

Got a reply from those nice guys at Fertan when asked about aluminium protection!

This is what they say!

'For a normal road going vehicle it would be absolutely fine to
use UBS120 directly onto the panels. I'd expect that to have a
service life of twelve to fifteen years.'

'OVER4 is intended for areas of high wear such as the inside of
wheel arches and front and rear valances which also get a hard
life. But I have a commercial customer who prepares new
Landrovers for export and he steam cleans the underside and then
uses OVER4 as the underseal.'

But to answer your direct question - OVER4 will bond well to
aluminium. In practice I've used an etch primer underneath it
but someone gave me 40 litres of that a few years ago and I'm
keen to get it used up.'


Soo...there you have it! Looks like UBS120 for most of the car underpants then!

danielgray

668 posts

251 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
Polycarbonite becomes very brittle if you get petrol on it so using it as a belly pan may not be the best idea.

bigmack

553 posts

289 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
I too had to repair my fuel tanks...3 or 4 times now I'm afraid. However, I must point out that I live in town with a great deal of salt and humidity in the air. Currently looking to have a tank mounted in the cockpit. I've not run a belly pan under the engine and so I can't comment on that, but I would go for either aluminum or c/f which would also strengthen up the chassis some.
Cheers!
-Mack

builder

1,225 posts

271 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
Do you guys know about zinc chromate?

Or this "wheel paint"...at a USA manufacturer?

crafty

2,291 posts

266 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
Corrosion at the fixings is bimetallic corrosion and can be solved by isolating the two disssimilar metals electrically. There is also a grade of stainless steel called austenitic stainless... its used in roofing and cladding screws where you have stainless screws going thru aluminium into steel... www.sfsintec.biz/internet/SFSintEN.nsf/PageID/Corrosion_RC

The other thing that will make the tanks corrode is condensation... just like when you pull a cold drink out of the fridge, the condensation is on the outside of the can (warm side)... so if your car is in a garage and its cold, and you take it outside where its warm, you'll get condensation on the outside.


Alan 2

162 posts

293 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
crafty said:
Corrosion at the fixings is bimetallic corrosion and can be solved by isolating the two disssimilar metals electrically. There is also a grade of stainless steel called austenitic stainless... its used in roofing and cladding screws where you have stainless screws going thru aluminium into steel...


Grant. I think you'll find that virtually all commercial grades of s/s used in engineering applications are austenitic. If you're in doubt, put a magnet on it. If the magnet falls off, it's austenitic. Alan.

edfoxuk

203 posts

259 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
dont think all tank failures are down to corrosion. Mine was very clean and leaking!

bigmack

553 posts

289 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
mine had several pin hole leaks on the welds.

ultimacz

260 posts

284 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
Ultima Factory said:
Fuel Tanks

If builders follow the assembly instructions in the build manual then the fuel tanks will not be prone to corrosion and to our knowledge only two have suffered this problem in 14 years.
Damage from other causes has also been rare and when it has occurred it has been due to over enthusiastic use of spanners on fuel fitting welded to the tank or tank modifications.



Have to support the Factory here. We have in total 4 cars in our country which were all turn-key build by the factory. On no car there is any sign of problems with the fuel tanks after 3 years of operation. I know this sample might not be representative, but there could be really a problem rather in the assembly process than in the component quality.
(really hope I´m right on this one - seems to be nightmare to replace the tanks...)