AS engines'power
AS engines'power
Author
Discussion

budala

Original Poster:

258 posts

216 months

Friday 7th November 2008
quotequote all
My GTR just out of the bench.
And I can now confirm that the AS SBC engine, furnished in 2003, 4500 miles and deemed to be 540 hp is only...431.5 hp DIN (406 hp to the wheels).
American horses are european ponies !

LuckyP

6,243 posts

254 months

Friday 7th November 2008
quotequote all
'Ere we go! Hold on tight.... smile

UltimaCH

3,181 posts

218 months

Friday 7th November 2008
quotequote all
Perhaps that's why they use the expression "Pony cars" in the USA.

738 driver

1,202 posts

222 months

Friday 7th November 2008
quotequote all
Ah...but did you correctly correct the uncorrected by the appropriate correction???

Pb3

1,064 posts

275 months

Friday 7th November 2008
quotequote all
That's a high mileage engine then wink you need to correct for that too!

kylemrushall

1,922 posts

233 months

Friday 7th November 2008
quotequote all
budala said:
My GTR just out of the bench.
And I can now confirm that the AS SBC engine, furnished in 2003, 4500 miles and deemed to be 540 hp is only...431.5 hp DIN (406 hp to the wheels).
American horses are european ponies !
nothing new im afraid!!

my AS engine was supposed to be 535bhp.... my new engine is 530bhp but it feels like a different world when you redline it.

budala

Original Poster:

258 posts

216 months

Friday 7th November 2008
quotequote all
738 driver said:
Ah...but did you correctly correct the uncorrected by the appropriate correction???
Yes I did indeed...

budala

Original Poster:

258 posts

216 months

Friday 7th November 2008
quotequote all
kylemrushall said:
budala said:
My GTR just out of the bench.
And I can now confirm that the AS SBC engine, furnished in 2003, 4500 miles and deemed to be 540 hp is only...431.5 hp DIN (406 hp to the wheels).
American horses are european ponies !
nothing new im afraid!!

my AS engine was supposed to be 535bhp.... my new engine is 530bhp but it feels like a different world when you redline it.
Nothing new, that's why I confirm.
And hope my future 580 (real)hp engine will feel like a new and wonderfull world !

738 driver

1,202 posts

222 months

Friday 7th November 2008
quotequote all
Bud, so given what you found what was the correction originally applied?

As already said though, and before AS bashing gathers momentum again, you do have to consider that after 3-4-5 years and several thousand miles, parts of the valve train may be well past their best......just normal fatigue on the highly stressed bits resulting in lost performance.

It appears to regularly be the case that high initial output NA SBC's soon go off peak and sometimes even fail.

IMHO anyone rebuilding their high HP, N/A SBC motor would be wise to focus most of their funds and time on the whole valve train. Every component from the cam right throught to the face of the valves! Then look after them carefully if you expect them to last.

If you cant or dont have the time/inclination then stick a blower of some sorts on it... or just go LS7!

Good luck with your new motor.




Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

289 months

Friday 7th November 2008
quotequote all
The atlantic sucks out some of the bhp or so the swedes saysmile

budala

Original Poster:

258 posts

216 months

Friday 7th November 2008
quotequote all
738 driver said:
Bud, so given what you found what was the correction originally applied?

As already said though, and before AS bashing gathers momentum again, you do have to consider that after 3-4-5 years and several thousand miles, parts of the valve train may be well past their best......just normal fatigue on the highly stressed bits resulting in lost performance.

It appears to regularly be the case that high initial output NA SBC's soon go off peak and sometimes even fail.

IMHO anyone rebuilding their high HP, N/A SBC motor would be wise to focus most of their funds and time on the whole valve train. Every component from the cam right throught to the face of the valves! Then look after them carefully if you expect them to last.

If you cant or dont have the time/inclination then stick a blower of some sorts on it... or just go LS7!

Good luck with your new motor.

I agree.
In fact my "new" engine will be my actual motor with important improvements.

I'm not competent enough, either in engineering or english to explain it exactly.

But fortunately, I'm not only ten minutes far from the HTTT.
I'm also ten minutes far from ORECA (for performance parts), from Bullish Racing (competent for everything except engines and working for Alain Prost - Trophée Andros- or Ange Barde-Ferrari Challenge) and from Caldentey Engineering, one of the best US engines specialist in France.

For example, the bottom of my engine, sold new in 2003 by AS, is from 1979 !!! It will be changed for a "bow tie" (?) and upgraded to reach 580 hp at least.

By chance, I have competent guys around me and they give me some ideas and good advices.
Another example : they think an electric steering assistance could be mounted if wanted, using an Opel Corsa electric engine. That's what they do on their protos. Does someone allready tried that ?

Edited by budala on Friday 7th November 11:12


Edited by budala on Friday 7th November 11:13

Steve_D

13,802 posts

287 months

Friday 7th November 2008
quotequote all
budala said:
.......Another example : they think an electric steering assistance could be mounted if wanted, using an Opel Corsa electric engine. That's what they do on their protos. Does someone allready tried that ?
Never found steering to be a problem. Yes, it is heavy at parking speeds but once under way it is fine.

Steve

budala

Original Poster:

258 posts

216 months

Friday 7th November 2008
quotequote all
So I understand it could be better at parking speeds...and better too for certain tracks with hard cornering (Lédenon or Pole Mécanique d'Alès for examples).

It is easier and faster when you have one hand on the gear knob, one on the steering wheel, another one adjusting the mirror and one in the air vent to say hello to your girl(boy?)friend and the last one trying to close the ash tray you don't have in the car ...:-)

And all that for such a light expense !

Edited by budala on Friday 7th November 14:07

robm3

4,930 posts

256 months

Friday 7th November 2008
quotequote all
Boosted LS1 said:
The atlantic sucks out some of the bhp or so the swedes saysmile
Not for me, 452din hp or around 420hp on a Chevy LT5 motor with an official quote of 405hp and that's with 19,000 miles on it.
(although I think the standard quote was with Corvette exhaust and emissions of which mine has neither).

GTRCLIVE

4,193 posts

312 months

Friday 7th November 2008
quotequote all
Trust GM Figures to be lower than acutal and Lets just say we know which side of the Figure the AS engines are.....

budala

Original Poster:

258 posts

216 months

Saturday 8th November 2008
quotequote all
738 driver said:
Bud, so given what you found what was the correction originally applied?

As already said though, and before AS bashing gathers momentum again, you do have to consider that after 3-4-5 years and several thousand miles, parts of the valve train may be well past their best......just normal fatigue on the highly stressed bits resulting in lost performance.

It appears to regularly be the case that high initial output NA SBC's soon go off peak and sometimes even fail.

IMHO anyone rebuilding their high HP, N/A SBC motor would be wise to focus most of their funds and time on the whole valve train. Every component from the cam right throught to the face of the valves! Then look after them carefully if you expect them to last.

If you cant or dont have the time/inclination then stick a blower of some sorts on it... or just go LS7!

Good luck with your new motor.

By the way, in the same afternoon, on the same bench and in same conditions, my Porsche 996 GT2
by Techart, 2002 and 31500 kms, deemed to be at least 600 hp reached 643 hp...

Either this bench was optimistic (and that's worse fot the 430 hp of the Ultima) or the german
engineers have better results that announced...

Edited by budala on Saturday 8th November 15:11

mogg

451 posts

287 months

Saturday 8th November 2008
quotequote all
Mmmm....almost certainly the correct answer is - the German engineers have better results than announced. When EVO magazine put a 997 GT3 on a rolling road it made around 430 BHP compared to the stated 409 BHP !!

LuckyP

6,243 posts

254 months

Saturday 8th November 2008
quotequote all
Budala, you have a GT2? Respect!! bow

Defo coming down for a trackday next year!!

Scuffers

20,887 posts

303 months

Saturday 8th November 2008
quotequote all
budala said:
By chance, I have competent guys around me and they give me some ideas and good advices.
Another example : they think an electric steering assistance could be mounted if wanted, using an Opel Corsa electric engine. That's what they do on their protos. Does someone allready tried that ?
there's a electro/mecanical one about I have seen used on some race cars, hardware is from a Rover of all things! (with bespoke electronics), they actually work really well, looking to fit one to the ProSport as the workload is quite high with slicks doing 3+ hour stints...

they basically are made to replace the top section of the steering column.



suntiger1965

3,547 posts

231 months

Saturday 8th November 2008
quotequote all
budala said:
738 driver said:
Bud, so given what you found what was the correction originally applied?

As already said though, and before AS bashing gathers momentum again, you do have to consider that after 3-4-5 years and several thousand miles, parts of the valve train may be well past their best......just normal fatigue on the highly stressed bits resulting in lost performance.

It appears to regularly be the case that high initial output NA SBC's soon go off peak and sometimes even fail.

IMHO anyone rebuilding their high HP, N/A SBC motor would be wise to focus most of their funds and time on the whole valve train. Every component from the cam right throught to the face of the valves! Then look after them carefully if you expect them to last.

If you cant or dont have the time/inclination then stick a blower of some sorts on it... or just go LS7!

Good luck with your new motor.

I agree.
In fact my "new" engine will be my actual motor with important improvements.

I'm not competent enough, either in engineering or english to explain it exactly.

But fortunately, I'm not only ten minutes far from the HTTT.
I'm also ten minutes far from ORECA (for performance parts), from Bullish Racing (competent for everything except engines and working for Alain Prost - Trophée Andros- or Ange Barde-Ferrari Challenge) and from Caldentey Engineering, one of the best US engines specialist in France.

For example, the bottom of my engine, sold new in 2003 by AS, is from 1979 !!! It will be changed for a "bow tie" (?) and upgraded to reach 580 hp at least.

By chance, I have competent guys around me and they give me some ideas and good advices.
Another example : they think an electric steering assistance could be mounted if wanted, using an Opel Corsa electric engine. That's what they do on their protos. Does someone allready tried that ?

Edited by budala on Friday 7th November 11:12


Edited by budala on Friday 7th November 11:13
if you look on ebay at 250320120854 it show a wiring loom for the corsa 2 and corsa 3 electric racks so you can vary the steering with wheel speed....i know a few guy who have fitted this with sucess along with an MGF steering which is electric as well...ideally you want the electric steering to turn off after 30mph otherwise you will loose your sense of steering... peugeot 106 is electric steering as well as corsa but different type
dom

Edited by suntiger1965 on Saturday 8th November 17:48