Timewatch: Queen Elizabeths Lost Guns
Timewatch: Queen Elizabeths Lost Guns
Author
Discussion

Ouze

Original Poster:

17 posts

173 months

Sunday 10th June 2012
quotequote all
Did anyone else watch it this evening? (BBC2 8-9pm)

Another good documentary by the BBC, heads up for those who didn't see it and now have the opportunity to do so on iPlayer.

Follows a team proving a theory that 47 years after the mis-matched guns of the Mary Rose the Navy had a co-ordinated/consistent weapons system.

FourWheelDrift

92,396 posts

315 months

Sunday 10th June 2012
quotequote all
Great programme but after seeing the firing test of that Elizabethan period cannon now I want to see someone build a cross section of a later Trafalgar period ship of the line fully kitted out and with proper dummies. Then cast 48 cannon of correct sizes and mount them in 3 rows just like a first rate and fire a full broadside into the target cross section. Just to see the damage done to the ship and people inside.

Plus it would be fun. smile

DJRC

23,563 posts

267 months

Monday 11th June 2012
quotequote all
FourWheelDrift said:
Great programme but after seeing the firing test of that Elizabethan period cannon now I want to see someone build a cross section of a later Trafalgar period ship of the line fully kitted out and with proper dummies. Then cast 48 cannon of correct sizes and mount them in 3 rows just like a first rate and fire a full broadside into the target cross section. Just to see the damage done to the ship and people inside.

Plus it would be fun. smile
48 cannon?

1st rate ships of the line carried more than 48 cannon on a triple decked broadside!
As to their firepower, well even a 3rd rate ship of the line usually carried more firepower in a broadside than most of Bonapartes' armies put into the field. Siege guns were usually 32lb guns and were very rare in a land army because they were a pain in the arse to cart around the field. To broach somewhere like Badajoz consider this:

"Wellington only ordered the creation of a siege train for the attack on Badajoz on 18 April. Major Alexander Dickson, the officer appointed to command the artillery, had to take his guns from the fortress of Elvas. By the end of April he had managed to find 23 guns, of which the worst were nearly 200 years old and the best outdated 18th century pieces."

In contrast a Ship of the Line Captain had at his instant command between 74 and 132 guns from a smattering 12lbs to main guns of 30 and 32lbs, even 42lbs and 64lb carronades.

A single broadside from say Victory would have levelled an entire section of Badajoz.

FourWheelDrift

92,396 posts

315 months

Monday 11th June 2012
quotequote all
DJRC said:
48 cannon?
Rough average of what we had at Trafalgar in the line (big guns not including smaller top deck swivel mounted cannons) some guns on the top deck could be used to fire on either side.

At Trafalgar HMS Victory had 100 guns and could fire ~62 guns on one broadside. (other 100s being Britannia and Royal Sovereign)
There were 4x 98 gun ships
There was 1x 80 gun ship
There were 16x 74 gun ship of the line which could fire 34-37 guns on one broadside
There were 3x 64 gun ships.
Then the smaller 36 gun ships I'm not counting.

So most ships would have been firing a 34-37 gun broadside only 8 ships firing more (up to 62).

I just took a rough average based on the biggest and the most common broadsides. 62 + 35 then divide by 2 = 48.5 since you can't get half a gun I said 48.

Or to put it another way, 100 gun ship, 50 guns on both sides minus a couple of swivel mounts on both sides not used on a main broadside = 48. Which is what I did last night, the numbers above are just convenient. smile