John Carter, Was it really that bad???
John Carter, Was it really that bad???
Author
Discussion

Streetrod

Original Poster:

6,484 posts

237 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
OK I watched John Carter on Blu Ray last night and apart from being a bit long I actually liked it as a bit of harmless fun. The critics absolutely creamed the movie and it lost countless millions for Disney. Am I the only one who likes it? It had Lynn Collins looking gorgeous for goodness sake

garrykiller

5,670 posts

189 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
I watched it on the plane a couple of weeks ago. I thought it was pretty terrible, shocking actually.

Guvernator

14,502 posts

196 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
No I am in agreement with Streetrod on this one. As a family freindly action yarn I didn't think it was too bad. Some of the CGI effects were a little ropey but nothing too bad. Ok it did take a few liberties with the source material but then what Hollywood movie doesn't? I would say it was slightly above average summer blockbuster movie and certainly not dreadful enough to get the universal panning. Trust me, I've seen much worse.

51mes

1,557 posts

231 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
Guvernator said:
No I am in agreement with Streetrod on this one. As a family freindly action yarn I didn't think it was too bad. Some of the CGI effects were a little ropey but nothing too bad. Ok it did take a few liberties with the source material but then what Hollywood movie doesn't? I would say it was slightly above average summer blockbuster movie and certainly not dreadful enough to get the universal panning. Trust me, I've seen much worse.
Yeah Me and SWMBO saw it in the cinema - didn't quite get where the panning came from....

papercup

2,502 posts

250 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
51mes said:
Guvernator said:
No I am in agreement with Streetrod on this one. As a family freindly action yarn I didn't think it was too bad. Some of the CGI effects were a little ropey but nothing too bad. Ok it did take a few liberties with the source material but then what Hollywood movie doesn't? I would say it was slightly above average summer blockbuster movie and certainly not dreadful enough to get the universal panning. Trust me, I've seen much worse.
Yeah Me and SWMBO saw it in the cinema - didn't quite get where the panning came from....
+1

I enjoyed it. Good bit of fun. Made a change from all the 'reboots'.....

rudecherub

1,997 posts

197 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
It was a little disjointed in places, and the prologue on Earth too long, but an okay too good movie. And I enjoyed it.

Should have been better. Should have had *much* better marketing.

Considering this story is the daddy of Superman, Grand Daddy of Star Wars, and Avatar. Deserved better.

That said it has quietly made Disney its money back internationally, not the block buster result they were looking for though.

MissChief

8,020 posts

199 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
i quite enjoyed it and can't help but think Disney did something to ps off the critics so they panned it in revenge or something?!

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
It wasn't "Pearl Harbor" bad, but it was pretty weak. There was just far too much plot to get into the film to make it make sense.

r1flyguy1

1,575 posts

207 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
papercup said:
+1

I enjoyed it. Good bit of fun. Made a change from all the 'reboots'.....
+1, watched on a flight too, passed a couple of hours and thought it was ok,

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
It was better then transformers

TheHeretic

73,668 posts

286 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
I've read the books, and it was very different to what I expected, but as a jolly Conan-esque space fantasy type thing, I enjoyed it. It was certainly nowhere near as bad as what I expected. Granted, it is no LOTR or Star Wars, but I am looking forward to the sequel.

stew-S160

8,021 posts

269 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
It was OK. Definitely over hyped, but by no means did it deserve the slating it got.

130R

7,124 posts

237 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
It was better then transformers
It really wasn't ..

It's a lot better than "Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance" though. What were you thinking Nic.

clonmult

10,529 posts

240 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
TheHeretic said:
Granted, it is no LOTR or Star Wars, but I am looking forward to the sequel.
Thought it had bombed so badly in the cinema that a sequel was unlikely?

Agreed that its no LOTR, but come on - while I do like Star Wars, no way does it deserve to be put on the same level as LOTR.

In fact, something about John Carter reminds me of Episode 1. Not necessarily bad, but it does seem to drag.

Oakey

27,984 posts

247 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
I absolutely hated the look of this and thought it was going to be terrible but ended up watching it out of boredom and was surprised I enjoyed it more than I expected to.

Meoricin

2,880 posts

200 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
I honestly think it was as bad as the Asylum version. A hell of a lot worse if you compare budgets.

Halb

53,012 posts

214 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
MissChief said:
i quite enjoyed it and can't help but think Disney did something to ps off the critics so they panned it in revenge or something?!
Freezing his head and putting all that secret gay imagery into his cartoons did it.

DJRC

23,563 posts

267 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
Watched this at the weekend.

Er...wtf were the blue, random shape shifting bad dudes all about? What was their point? Wtf were they actually trying to do?

Rick_1138

3,954 posts

209 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
I bought this on BR and watched it with the mrs, she isnt a sci-fi fan but enjoyed it, especially the dog alien thing hehe.

I actually wanted to see this film in the cinema, but for varius reasons missed the run, but a few mates saw it and said it was good, so i couldnt understand the hate coming from the press.

However after a bit of digging, it seems the marketing manager for this film was from magazines or something and had no movie marketing expertise at all, and he was adamant it should be done his way, the main thing removing the "of Mars" from the title was seen as a bad idea as most people would have eiher recognised the name from the books, or got a hint it was a sci-fi from the mars ref, so more folk would have gone on a whim to see a sci-fi, but to many "John Carter" could have been a legal drama.

They re-released the film along with the avengers and it made a load more cash, so its actually sitting at about £235m from a £208m budget so its made money, hopefully it will be a dvd money maker as i would like a sequal.

The problem nowadays is Avatar, many who saw the trailer felt it was an avatar clone, the green aliens looking like Na'vi apparently!!, the irony is Avatar was based on this story!!

The whole film was teribly marketed, hopefully its not a dead franchise, but batman soon so that next smile

Guvernator

14,502 posts

196 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
DJRC said:
Watched this at the weekend.

Er...wtf were the blue, random shape shifting bad dudes all about? What was their point? Wtf were they actually trying to do?
^^^^ This. While I did enjoy most of the film I really didn't understand what the end goal for these bad guys where. Whatever the role was for these guys in the books, I think it got lost in translation somewhere or lost on the cutting room floor. There plans seemed to make Dr Evil's nefarious plotting seem quite sane.