Why do we hate radio presenters?
Why do we hate radio presenters?
Author
Discussion

durbster

Original Poster:

12,142 posts

253 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Something occurred to me in the Moyles thread. It seems radio presenters polarise opinion like nobody else.

It seems a rarity that anybody can sit on the fence when discussing them - it seems you either like a presenter, or you absolutely hate them.

The level of abuse heaped on a disliked radio presenter seems massively disproportionate to their crime. Before I clicked on the Moyles thread for the first time, I knew it would be littered with ferocious attacks on him (and it'd be the same if it was any radio presenter, particularly on Radio 1).

Is it because it's just a voice and it's difficult to trust? Is it because it's a one way conversation and that becomes instinctively frustrating if you're not following it? Or is it because Steve Wright is a tired, talentless prick who does nothing more than read stuff out for a living?

Jamie VTS

1,238 posts

178 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all


I can see no sensible reason to "hate" radio presenters.

smartphone hater

4,304 posts

174 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
They all annoy me, every one of them, because I don't see the need for them. I don't see why we cant have just music & a bit of news, the programmes could even be made in advance & played at a certain time.

I don't want to be entertained by Moyles, Wright or anyone, I don't want to hear Dave calling in from Nuneaton, I don't want to hear people playing stupid quizzes.

I don't understand why all our stations have to be the same format with a team of people doing a show, the beeb could save a fortune by sacking these people. I just want music & some traffic news.

smartphone hater

4,304 posts

174 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Jamie VTS said:

I can see no sensible reason to "hate" radio presenters.
When I drove for a living I used to rely on traffic news quite a lot. The local stations traffic news would cut in either while listening to a radio station or cd, but radio 2's traffic news doesn't but is the best because it covers the entire country.

I found myself hating many presenters & their teams because I had to listen to their stupid st for hours on end day after day after day.

Jamie VTS

1,238 posts

178 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
smartphone hater said:
When I drove for a living I used to rely on traffic news quite a lot. The local stations traffic news would cut in either while listening to a radio station or cd, but radio 2's traffic news doesn't but is the best because it covers the entire country.

I found myself hating many presenters & their teams because I had to listen to their stupid st for hours on end day after day after day.
With the greatest of respect you didnt *have* too, Im pretty sure Sally traffic is scheduled so could you not just turn over when she does her report? There is traffic websites and also traffic phone lines that you could use instead. All im trying to say is life is too short to sit shaking with anger being wound up by the radio. All IMO

RVVUNM

1,913 posts

240 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
What you need is an i-pod and a smart satnav. yes

smartphone hater

4,304 posts

174 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Jamie VTS said:
With the greatest of respect you didnt *have* too, Im pretty sure Sally traffic is scheduled so could you not just turn over when she does her report? There is traffic websites and also traffic phone lines that you could use instead. All im trying to say is life is too short to sit shaking with anger being wound up by the radio. All IMO
This was all back in the day before the latest technology so I didn't own a pc & satnav hadn't appeared on the market. smile You'd of thought Sally Traffic would be at set times but no, Sally will be back in approx 30 minutes, sally will be back in approx 20 minutes etc etc.

But my point was made in my first reply. I really don't see the need for them. smile

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Jamie VTS said:


I can see no sensible reason to "hate" radio presenters.
Sort of - unless you have a shared work area where the majority of staff play a station with presenters you don't like.

In your own car, then just switch to something else of course.

smartphone hater

4,304 posts

174 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
mrmr96 said:
In your own car, then just switch to something else of course.
Things are different now if you have digital radio but otherwise this is another problem if you drive across the UK. There are only, I think, four stations that are available nation wide which are Radio 1,2,4 & classic. Anything else lasts for a few miles & is lost.

Chris Type R

8,984 posts

280 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Did John Peel have many haters ?

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Chris Type R said:
Did John Peel have many haters ?
The fact he was stuck on in the middle of the night suggest he's wasn't what most people wanted. To me the question is should the BBC provide 'What most people want'.


mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
smartphone hater said:
Things are different now if you have digital radio but otherwise this is another problem if you drive across the UK. There are only, I think, four stations that are available nation wide which are Radio 1,2,4 & classic. Anything else lasts for a few miles & is lost.
There are more than that:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_radio_station...

durbster

Original Poster:

12,142 posts

253 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
smartphone hater said:
They all annoy me, every one of them, because I don't see the need for them. I don't see why we cant have just music & a bit of news, the programmes could even be made in advance & played at a certain time.
I don't understand that. Surely you would just stick in a CD, mp3, tape, 8-track and guarantee you'll be listening to what you like? One of the reasons I started listening to Moyles was because he played less music, which meant less of the Radio 1 playlist, which was a good thing (although I quite like the way it's gone in recent years).

Getting the traffic reports I can understand if you're on the road all day but satnavs can handle that. The news is rarely worth hanging around for and the weather's going to happen whether you know about it or not smile

P-Jay

11,423 posts

222 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
I hate that people seem to think "well if you don't like it, you can switch off" is a valid argument.

By-and-large driving in the UK is boring as hell, and in return for our licence fee / or heaven forbid listening to awful adverts we'd like to be entertained whilst we drive to work and home again. Choice is limited. I can get 8 stations to any great quality in my car, one's in Welsh which doesn't suit me, and I won't listen to Radio Wales on the grounds of safety, I'll ether fall asleep and hit the central reservation, or do so though choice.

I've got Radio 1 (for 15-30 year old)
Radio 2 ( for 40 to 90 year olds)
Nation Radio (which plays a lot of non-pop stuff which is good, but the presenters are aholes and there's WEBUYANYCAR!! WEBUYANYCAR!!WEBUYANYCAR!!WEBUYANYCAR!! After every other song) Capital (for idiots and children who like pop songs with added 'house beats')
Kiss (which is the same as Capital)

I think they're hated because they're so invasive. I can't speak for all, but I like to hear music, and not just music I already know and have heard a thousand times on my iPod / CD player. I'd like a song, 15 seconds chat, perhaps telling me the name of it, bit of trivia about it or the band and another song. Maybe every half hour the News, Weather and Traffic. This is what it used to be like, then the chat got a little longer, silly jingles came in, the cast grew to a team or Posse [SICK IN MOUTH]. Until the person whose job it was to choose music and press buttons became a Star and had someone else to choose music and press button for them.

The sharp end of this is Chris Moyles - who seems to despise playing music unless he desperately needs a piss or a fag, such is his love for his own voice and the unending praise from his arsekissing staff.

There's something about being a DJ that makes them a bit needy, never more so than when they do it for a living in Clubs, they like to think it's them that people want to hear, be it Nick Grimshaw last night talking to some new Pop princess about Photo shoots saying "yeah I hate it when they make you do stupid stuff" Yeah 'Grimmy' we get it, you're a minor celeb who has Photo Shoots too just like Jessie J!

You wouldn’t go to the Cinema and put up with the projectionist engaging in a “little chat and opinion” before and after the film, or more than likely talking over the first and last 15 mins in a desperate attempt to hold our attention.

/Rant.

Jamie VTS

1,238 posts

178 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Why is it not a valid argument that you can just turn it off or over?

Edit: If you are tired of your CD's buy some new ones? I have found a whole load of new music from the music forum on PH!

I think your example of going to the cinema is a poor example..

Edited by Jamie VTS on Friday 13th July 13:06

P-Jay

11,423 posts

222 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Jamie VTS said:
Why is it not a valid argument that you can just turn it off or over?

Edit: If you are tired of your CD's buy some new ones? I have found a whole load of new music from the music forum on PH!

I think your example of going to the cinema is a poor example..

Edited by Jamie VTS on Friday 13th July 13:06
Simply because it's a public service (especially the BBC stations) and if I don't like it I have every right to moan / complain about it rather than just deny myself something I enjoy. Just because my radio has an off button and a CD changer, it doesn't mean my opinion on radio is null and void because I have the choice to listen or not.

We could all take the decision to stop doing things we used to like, or liked more in the past but where does that lead?

With most media you can vote with your feet, don't like a particular newspaper, there are about a dozen to choose from, Television, probably over a 1000 channels these days (the argument of choice over quality has been covered elsewhere).

Radio isn't like that, there are much fewer stations, and very, very few that aren't spoilt by over-heavy advertisement especially broadcast in an analogue format.

So your choice is Music you already know, there's no "surprise and delight" or a few Radio choices - frankly if you're not prepared to surf stations endlessly between the ads your choice is Radio 1 or 2, and given the lack of choice, and the fact I and everyone else in the UK (chancers, the old and off-the-grid types aside) pays for them, I think they should do a better job of it.

You could put a picture of an off button or similar on any thread on this entire forum whereby someone is complaining about a service or product - it would add nothing to any of them.

StevieBee

15,513 posts

286 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Chris Moyles has not enjoyed the longevity he has for no reason. The fact is that he has captured a massive following and done what few other Radio 1 presenters has managed in extending the typical age band that tunes into the station. He may not be everybody's cup of tea (he's certainly not mine) but for those for whom he is, he does an exceptionally brilliant job. If he isn't your cup of tea, the chances are you are not his target demographic.

The one thing we are not short of in this country is choice of radio. It's a hugely fragmented media and practically every taste and need is served.

I present a weekly breakfast show and a drive time show on a community radio station. We 'have' to be generic in what we do and creating interesting and fresh content for a 3 hour show just once a week is no easy task.

Jamie VTS

1,238 posts

178 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
I think my picture did add to this topic, in my opinion more than your (well articulated) but largely pointless argument, if you dont like a certain TV programme, book, film or website then just dont use it, I dont see how it can be any more complicated or difficult. I dont enjoy Classical music so Classic FM never comes on in my car, that doesnt mean im narrow minded enough to "hate" it and spend my time moaning about it. I enjoy listening to Chris Moyles so I listen to that on my way into work. On the way home I listen to Radio 4, occasionaly listening to songs on the various other commercial stations available in the area I live (Heart, Reading Fm, Eagle, Kiss, Capital, BBC Berkshire). Sometimes, I even enjoy having a little bit of quiet time to think.

Cotty

42,281 posts

315 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Su Harrison - Heart FM

Don't hate her but its annoying that she has the opposite view to everyone else. Regardless of what they are talking about she will come up with an opposite argument.

LuS1fer

43,567 posts

276 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Radio 1 music is dire so what falls between it had better be good.

Chris Moyles is someone I could never understand being popular. His chat is tedious and banal, like some dull oaf at the pub namedropping famous names. As for his resignation, hit "Share" if you don't give a toss.

As for others generally, I think the human voice itself is polarising. I like Chris Evans but not his voice, I dsilike Jeremy Vine and his show and Steve Wright is possibly unique in being able to convey smugness in a voice.

I preferred the old 70s and 80s Radio 1 DJs - they seemed more interesting and knew when to shut up while a song was playing. It's all very shouty these days.