Engineering giants. BBC2 8PM
Author
Discussion

BliarOut

Original Poster:

72,863 posts

270 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
Season 1. Episode 1 of 3. New series. The inner workings of some of the world's biggest machines. Engineer-turned-comedian Tom Wrigglesworth and mechanical engineer Rob Bell watch as a 14-year-old Boeing 747 jumbo jet is taken apart and reassembled in an aircraft hangar in Cardiff, and learn what its component parts reveal about how it works. They also visit an aeroplane salvage centre in the Cotswolds to discover what happens to aircraft at the end of their working lives

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
I suspect the electrical engineer has stuck his fingers in high voltage sockets one too many times judging by his hair!! ;-)

rohrl

8,984 posts

176 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
I'm watching this too. I live in Swansea and I've seen 747's flying in circles over S. Wales and the Bristol Channel obviously being tested or shaken down out of the Rhoose service facility. I wonder if I've seen this one.

hyperblue

2,916 posts

211 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
Wanted to watch this, but I've got some Olympic swimming tosh on BBC2 instead. Is this a Wales thing?

Parsnip

3,287 posts

219 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
Watching it now, seems pretty light on engineering content, but still cool stuff to look at.

Zad

13,024 posts

267 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
It is no wonder kids don't want to be engineers when they use people like that to front programmes.

At least they got the operation of wings correct. Most shows just go with the Bernoulli effect.

hyperblue

2,916 posts

211 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
Zad said:
It is no wonder kids don't want to be engineers when they use people like that to front programmes.
Doesn't help that everyone in the whole factory seems to be called an engineer.

Parsnip

3,287 posts

219 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
8/10

Had no issues with the guys presenting it - quite liked them infact - they knew what they were talking about and didn't feel the need to patronise or ham anything up for TV (thinking of the dire engineering connections thing Richard Hammond did a while back). I would have preferred some more geeky engineering content, but I know this isn't what the BEEB would be shooting for at 8pm on a Sunday - think they got it pretty close to spot on. Wasn't sure about the tears in the eyes, pride in your work bit at the end, but I guess it's true and I feel the same about projects I'm involved with - I guess you want the guys bolting your plane together to care about what they are doing smile

Still a little surprised at cables and pulleys being used - would have thought it would all be electro hydraulic. Wouldn't mind a shot of 747 fuselage demolition either - the speed that claw munched it up looked hugely satisfying smile

Looking forward to the next one - any ideas what they are looking at next? Phone rang right at the end when I guess they would have announced it

Parsnip

3,287 posts

219 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
hyperblue said:
Doesn't help that everyone in the whole factory seems to be called an engineer.
I noticed this too, I know the majority of them will actually be technicians by job title, but calling them engineers doesn't really annoy me. Sky engineers on the other hand... wink

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
I enjoyed this, good show and nice to see how much care is taken with the planes.

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
Zad said:
It is no wonder kids don't want to be engineers when they use people like that to front programmes.

At least they got the operation of wings correct. Most shows just go with the Bernoulli effect.
It would have been nice if they had perhaps had a little stab at explaining AOA and the Lift/Drag characteristic for a wing however. I can't help feeling it would have been a better program if it were on BBC4.


It was also funny how many different people used the "can't be too careful, there are no lay-bys at 30,000 feet you know" line........ ;-)

GTIR

24,741 posts

297 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
That was really interesting.

Always wondered how the bogs worked!

Should have been longer. yes

DoubleSix

12,573 posts

207 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
The Welsh really do go in for the whole pride thing like no other countryfolk...

honest_delboy

1,774 posts

231 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
Great program i thought, really interesting and well thought out.

I never knew the bogs worked like that, a fat lady sat on the seat once and flushed and she got sucked inside out - FACT.

GTIR

24,741 posts

297 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
honest_delboy said:
Great program i thought, really interesting and well thought out.

I never knew the bogs worked like that, a fat lady sat on the seat once and flushed and she got sucked inside out - FACT.
True.
Her scuba diving husband was scooped up by a forest fire fighting plane and dumped inland. yes

AnotherClarkey

3,698 posts

220 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
I really enjoyed it - even though it was obviously quite simplified it was (as far as I could tell) accurate. They took the trouble to point out that the Bernoulli effect is not the only reason lift is generated and that the fan creates most of the thrust rather than the exhaust gases.

GTIR

24,741 posts

297 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
So, if you got a jet engine and strapped enough fuel to it, pointed it up, max throttle, would it "fly"?

Parsnip

3,287 posts

219 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
GTIR said:
So, if you got a jet engine and strapped enough fuel to it, pointed it up, max throttle, would it "fly"?
Yes, but not for long - zero stability but bags of thrust to weight - probably like a rocket with no stabilising fins - would get off the ground, become slightly unbalanced, spear off in a direction and then end up hitting the ground at speed.

On VTOL planes, the lift during take-off isn't from the wings, but from the engines being vented downwards - so basically your scenario, but much more controlled smile



Zad

13,024 posts

267 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
GTIR said:
So, if you got a jet engine and strapped enough fuel to it, pointed it up, max throttle, would it "fly"?
What, like this?



Or perhaps this?



I'm afraid Rolls-Royce and NASA got there before you smile


Djdan

573 posts

179 months

Sunday 15th July 2012
quotequote all
Quite enjoyed it, i work on the industrial side of the RB211 engines so was good to have a peek at the aero engines. With the picture above with the 2 Derwents flying vertical i find it fascinating that Royce kept on trying crazy things even after Rolls was the first brit to die in a powered airplane flight.

Next weeks is a North Sea Platform decommision (the other side of our industrial turbines!!)