3D televisions - worth it?
Discussion
I'm thinking of buying one today.
Some of them can convert standard 2d Tv/Games into 3d.
There's two main types Active and Passive. I think i'm going for an active one. The picture is meant to be that bit better (More pop out for the 3d)but the downside is the glasses are more expensive and require batteries/charging.
Some of them can convert standard 2d Tv/Games into 3d.
There's two main types Active and Passive. I think i'm going for an active one. The picture is meant to be that bit better (More pop out for the 3d)but the downside is the glasses are more expensive and require batteries/charging.
I'm of the opinion that it's a fad, and largely a waste of time, but it's nowhere near approaching it's peak yet. As for 3DTVs, there's good and bad, but pay close attention to the panels when comparing them with the non-3D versions - for example my Panasonic 3DTV has a vastly superior panel than it's non-3D sibling, and handles 2D content much, much better. It's stunning, rather than pretty good. I'd go so far as to say it's one of the very few that can outshine the sorely missed Pioneer Kuros of old.
In terms of 3D content, there's good and bad, but from what I've seen there's far more of the latter and virtually none of the former unfortunately. A few, such as TT3D - have done a great job of using the 3D stuff to add something to the experience, but most of the releases so far [particularly the animated or CGI heavy ones] just have the odd scenes where they've lazily thrown in a heavy dash of 3D stuff (usually early in the film) and rather than adding to the experience, it just changes it for no real gain. I also think it cheapens the 2D viewing experience as you can instantly identify the lack of continuity between the 3D content and the rest of the movie.
I certainly wouldn't buy a TV purely based on how good the 3D content is, as there's precious little of it and 95% of what's available is garbage to date. Just buy whatever looks best to you. Unless it's a low budget you'll probably find what looks best just so happens to be 3D capable anyway. Given how little 3D content is out there, you'd be a fool to buy purely for the 3D experience - either the novelty will wear off, or you'll run out of content. Unless you want to pay for Sky 3D, which is also crap, frankly.
In terms of 3D content, there's good and bad, but from what I've seen there's far more of the latter and virtually none of the former unfortunately. A few, such as TT3D - have done a great job of using the 3D stuff to add something to the experience, but most of the releases so far [particularly the animated or CGI heavy ones] just have the odd scenes where they've lazily thrown in a heavy dash of 3D stuff (usually early in the film) and rather than adding to the experience, it just changes it for no real gain. I also think it cheapens the 2D viewing experience as you can instantly identify the lack of continuity between the 3D content and the rest of the movie.
I certainly wouldn't buy a TV purely based on how good the 3D content is, as there's precious little of it and 95% of what's available is garbage to date. Just buy whatever looks best to you. Unless it's a low budget you'll probably find what looks best just so happens to be 3D capable anyway. Given how little 3D content is out there, you'd be a fool to buy purely for the 3D experience - either the novelty will wear off, or you'll run out of content. Unless you want to pay for Sky 3D, which is also crap, frankly.
I work in broadcast and 90% of my work is within sport which was supposed to be the real market driver for 3d in TV. 2 years ago, it was all over our major tradeshows, right now nobody gives a toss.
Gaming might have some uptake, movies again, might have a small uptake, but it's no going to be that popular.
So, I'd say don't buy a TV based on the fact that it's 3d. If the TV you like happens to have 3d, happy days, otherwise don't put any value in it.
Gaming might have some uptake, movies again, might have a small uptake, but it's no going to be that popular.
So, I'd say don't buy a TV based on the fact that it's 3d. If the TV you like happens to have 3d, happy days, otherwise don't put any value in it.
Stu R said:
I'm of the opinion that it's a fad, and largely a waste of time, but it's nowhere near approaching it's peak yet. As for 3DTVs, there's good and bad, but pay close attention to the panels when comparing them with the non-3D versions - for example my Panasonic 3DTV has a vastly superior panel than it's non-3D sibling, and handles 2D content much, much better. It's stunning, rather than pretty good. I'd go so far as to say it's one of the very few that can outshine the sorely missed Pioneer Kuros of old.
In terms of 3D content, there's good and bad, but from what I've seen there's far more of the latter and virtually none of the former unfortunately. A few, such as TT3D - have done a great job of using the 3D stuff to add something to the experience, but most of the releases so far [particularly the animated or CGI heavy ones] just have the odd scenes where they've lazily thrown in a heavy dash of 3D stuff (usually early in the film) and rather than adding to the experience, it just changes it for no real gain. I also think it cheapens the 2D viewing experience as you can instantly identify the lack of continuity between the 3D content and the rest of the movie.
I certainly wouldn't buy a TV purely based on how good the 3D content is, as there's precious little of it and 95% of what's available is garbage to date. Just buy whatever looks best to you. Unless it's a low budget you'll probably find what looks best just so happens to be 3D capable anyway. Given how little 3D content is out there, you'd be a fool to buy purely for the 3D experience - either the novelty will wear off, or you'll run out of content. Unless you want to pay for Sky 3D, which is also crap, frankly.
Totally agree with this, I compared a 2D and 3D Panasonic and the 3D version has a much better screen compared with the 2D version. Also bought last years model so ended up being the same price anyway, don't care that it's 3D more that the picture quality is superb. In terms of 3D content, there's good and bad, but from what I've seen there's far more of the latter and virtually none of the former unfortunately. A few, such as TT3D - have done a great job of using the 3D stuff to add something to the experience, but most of the releases so far [particularly the animated or CGI heavy ones] just have the odd scenes where they've lazily thrown in a heavy dash of 3D stuff (usually early in the film) and rather than adding to the experience, it just changes it for no real gain. I also think it cheapens the 2D viewing experience as you can instantly identify the lack of continuity between the 3D content and the rest of the movie.
I certainly wouldn't buy a TV purely based on how good the 3D content is, as there's precious little of it and 95% of what's available is garbage to date. Just buy whatever looks best to you. Unless it's a low budget you'll probably find what looks best just so happens to be 3D capable anyway. Given how little 3D content is out there, you'd be a fool to buy purely for the 3D experience - either the novelty will wear off, or you'll run out of content. Unless you want to pay for Sky 3D, which is also crap, frankly.
My unlce got a 3D TV pretty soon after they came out. They soon got fed up of wearing glasses, on top of glasses. And, as the glasses cost around £20-£30 each, for an extra pair, the 3D function is not used at all when family are over.
Personally, i'm not a fan. Don't like watching films at the cinema in 3d either, pretty much a complete waste of time imo...
Personally, i'm not a fan. Don't like watching films at the cinema in 3d either, pretty much a complete waste of time imo...
Art0ir said:
Disagree with it being "no good". The high end Active 3D sets combined with 3D Bluray is just fantastic.
Agree with it being a fad though.
This, (well not all this!) Agree with it being a fad though.
I was a complete sceptic until I saw the beginning of "Hugo" on a decent Sony set.
I was pricing up 3D projectors to replace my 2D one that night, bad news is it's another 2.5K to early adopt to 3D like it was to adopt 1080P!
Also for gaming it means that two people can play on the same screen full screen without seeing each other.
However, I'm waiting for a year or so to see if any more really good 3D films come out, Hugo was breathtaking, I can only compare the depth to (in theory) actually being there, the smoke and snow felt like they were filling the entire room at times and the people on the train platforms was like actually being on one, very immersive.
I have also watched two other 3D sets in stores that weren't worth anything (one was also active!) maybe it was Samsung, or the choice of film, either way if I hadn't seen the Sony I would have dismissed immediately it as totally flawed technology.
I don't see it disappearing though, I just see it as a feature that all TV sets will have eventually, hopefully the calibre of 3D offerings will be high and poor quality 3D wont be worth the effort of the studios, the fad will die but the feature will hopefully remain.
I have one but it was more a case of the TV i wanted having it rather than looking for a TV with it.
Had it 6 months before noticing the Tennis was available in 3D on a BBC channel. Fired up the glasses and watched. It did add something different (Serena Williams is ten times more frightening in 3D) but I wouldn't ever pay extra for a TV with it.
Like someone said above, most big TVs have it anyway. I wouldn't base your purchase on 3D but if it has it then it can be interesting now and again.
Had it 6 months before noticing the Tennis was available in 3D on a BBC channel. Fired up the glasses and watched. It did add something different (Serena Williams is ten times more frightening in 3D) but I wouldn't ever pay extra for a TV with it.
Like someone said above, most big TVs have it anyway. I wouldn't base your purchase on 3D but if it has it then it can be interesting now and again.
freecar said:
This, (well not all this!)
I was a complete sceptic until I saw the beginning of "Hugo" on a decent Sony set.
I was pricing up 3D projectors to replace my 2D one that night, bad news is it's another 2.5K to early adopt to 3D like it was to adopt 1080P!
Also for gaming it means that two people can play on the same screen full screen without seeing each other.
However, I'm waiting for a year or so to see if any more really good 3D films come out, Hugo was breathtaking, I can only compare the depth to (in theory) actually being there, the smoke and snow felt like they were filling the entire room at times and the people on the train platforms was like actually being on one, very immersive.
I have also watched two other 3D sets in stores that weren't worth anything (one was also active!) maybe it was Samsung, or the choice of film, either way if I hadn't seen the Sony I would have dismissed immediately it as totally flawed technology.
I don't see it disappearing though, I just see it as a feature that all TV sets will have eventually, hopefully the calibre of 3D offerings will be high and poor quality 3D wont be worth the effort of the studios, the fad will die but the feature will hopefully remain.
I was involved with a very large electronics retailer around the time the new generation of 3D tv's came about. When they were first launched they were very heavily marketed for about a year, then no one seemed to care any more. The manufacturers are pushing it harder this time because they've invested a lot more, I still can't see them becoming a standard feature though. There's nowhere near the same interest in them as say 1080p HD.I was a complete sceptic until I saw the beginning of "Hugo" on a decent Sony set.
I was pricing up 3D projectors to replace my 2D one that night, bad news is it's another 2.5K to early adopt to 3D like it was to adopt 1080P!
Also for gaming it means that two people can play on the same screen full screen without seeing each other.
However, I'm waiting for a year or so to see if any more really good 3D films come out, Hugo was breathtaking, I can only compare the depth to (in theory) actually being there, the smoke and snow felt like they were filling the entire room at times and the people on the train platforms was like actually being on one, very immersive.
I have also watched two other 3D sets in stores that weren't worth anything (one was also active!) maybe it was Samsung, or the choice of film, either way if I hadn't seen the Sony I would have dismissed immediately it as totally flawed technology.
I don't see it disappearing though, I just see it as a feature that all TV sets will have eventually, hopefully the calibre of 3D offerings will be high and poor quality 3D wont be worth the effort of the studios, the fad will die but the feature will hopefully remain.
Doesn't this revival in 3D happen every other decade? Remember those shonky 3D films from the 80s (Freddie Kreuger..., in 3D!!). Or Nintendos VirtuaBoy from the 90s. I think the issue is that everyone has a different experience. My girlfriend has poor vision in one eye and whilst the RealD stuff works for her at the cinema I don't think the home versions will. Are they still using those glasses with the headache inducing shutters?
D_G said:
Jibber Jabber said:
Serena Williams is ten times more frightening in 3D

It's fun but I doubt I'd watch much in 3D. I like to be immersed in my films by ignoring everything outside of my eyes and brain. 3D glasses are "always" on your mind IMO.
I bet I'll watch other stuff in 3D though

Gassing Station | TV, Film, Streaming & Radio | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


