Volume during TV Adverts
Discussion
Prof Beard said:
Dixie68 said:
Yep, I am too. But that's where my Tivo comes in handy as I just pause the programme for a while so I can skip through the adverts 
I agree, I also have a Tivo but it's still something you have to do (ie press buttons)
Actually, referring to a post above, my TV has that auto-level volume but I've never used it. I might give it a go.
Officially, they're still no louder (at peak) than the programme or surroundings ads. - the dynamic range has just been compressed to make the quiet bits louder. It's been a problem for a while : http://www.out-law.com/page-8114 : and has also infected recorded music to its detriment : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loudness_war
Example : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dcKDMBuGodU
Example : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dcKDMBuGodU
marshalla said:
Officially, they're still no louder (at peak) than the programme or surroundings ads. - the dynamic range has just been compressed to make the quiet bits louder. It's been a problem for a while : http://www.out-law.com/page-8114 : and has also infected recorded music to its detriment : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loudness_war
Example : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dcKDMBuGodU
That makes sense as an explanation - they need better rules then... Example : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dcKDMBuGodU
This drove me nuts with my old (analogue) TV but I haven't noticed it very much with the new (digital) one. Maybe the digital malarkey decodes it differently.
What I have noticed, though, is the tendency for adverts to have very annoying soundtracks, eg lots of repetitive sudden noises or children running about screaming - as if they know most people don't look at the screen these days and try to get attention that way. All it does is make you less likely to buy their product.
What I have noticed, though, is the tendency for adverts to have very annoying soundtracks, eg lots of repetitive sudden noises or children running about screaming - as if they know most people don't look at the screen these days and try to get attention that way. All it does is make you less likely to buy their product.
thinfourth2 said:
You watch adverts
That is so last decade
Look into a PVR type affair as they completely change your relationship with the idiot box as you choose what to watch and when instead of plonking your arse down waiting for the next thing to start
I have a PVR and a TiVo - they still record the adverts...That is so last decade
Look into a PVR type affair as they completely change your relationship with the idiot box as you choose what to watch and when instead of plonking your arse down waiting for the next thing to start
Certainly in music there is an increasing trend to avoid this (I think a crappy Metallica album triggered the backlash).
In TV it is quite hard, the commercials come from a number of different sources and these days there are less people per channel to keep an eye on things. Plus the turnaround is quite short, frequently just hours.
However there are quite a few bits of hardware to ensure that excessively loud/perceived loud commercials are corrected.
But in the end it's a cultural change in the ad agencies that's needed. Bigger/brighter/louder does not equal better!
In TV it is quite hard, the commercials come from a number of different sources and these days there are less people per channel to keep an eye on things. Plus the turnaround is quite short, frequently just hours.
However there are quite a few bits of hardware to ensure that excessively loud/perceived loud commercials are corrected.
But in the end it's a cultural change in the ad agencies that's needed. Bigger/brighter/louder does not equal better!
Gassing Station | TV, Film, Streaming & Radio | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



