The Hobbit to be a Trilogy
Discussion
RobDickinson said:
"allows us to tell the full story of the adventures of Bilbo Baggins "
Its a short book damned you! It better be done well, dragging it out for 3 payments at the box office is bad form.
A typical screenplay runs to 100 pages. "The Hobbit" is roughly 300 pages. It works out quite nicely really. Its a short book damned you! It better be done well, dragging it out for 3 payments at the box office is bad form.

Mmm.. not sure about this.
I enjoyed the LOTR at the time, but when I have watched them again on the TV, three things jump out at me..
1. The action scenes are great.
2. They have aged quite well
3. They do go on a bit. The final 40 minutes or so of the last one seems to last an eternity. Several scenes pass where you think " is that the end?" only to find it carries on again, and again, and again..
..and again...
If you are making three more, then fine. But a bit of brevity would be welcome.
I enjoyed the LOTR at the time, but when I have watched them again on the TV, three things jump out at me..
1. The action scenes are great.
2. They have aged quite well
3. They do go on a bit. The final 40 minutes or so of the last one seems to last an eternity. Several scenes pass where you think " is that the end?" only to find it carries on again, and again, and again..
..and again...
If you are making three more, then fine. But a bit of brevity would be welcome.

Welshbeef said:
You have to explain here to the naive.
The Silmarillion goes from the creation of the world/universe through first and second ages and a bit of the 3rd. Given LOTR and the hobbit are based in a few years of the end of the third age this may give some sense of timescale/scope..RobDickinson said:
Welshbeef said:
You have to explain here to the naive.
The Silmarillion goes from the creation of the world/universe through first and second ages and a bit of the 3rd. Given LOTR and the hobbit are based in a few years of the end of the third age this may give some sense of timescale/scope..RobDickinson said:
Welshbeef said:
LOTR is a thick book to read how many volumes is is the Silmarion?
Pretty sure its less pages, not sure we can equate that with being a shorter 'story' though as LOTR is quite wordy and has a fair bit of filler. Silmarion at times isnt even a story...Don't worry Welshbeef....
It doesn't make much more sense once you've read the damn thing
The Silmarillion is not really a story, it's more of a chronicle that explains the time in Middle Earth from the beginning leading up to the Hobbit & Lord of the rings books.
Reading the The Silmarillion is like reading the Bible. Same writing style.
It doesn't make much more sense once you've read the damn thing

The Silmarillion is not really a story, it's more of a chronicle that explains the time in Middle Earth from the beginning leading up to the Hobbit & Lord of the rings books.
Reading the The Silmarillion is like reading the Bible. Same writing style.
RobDickinson said:
Pretty sure its less pages, not sure we can equate that with being a shorter 'story' though as LOTR is quite wordy and has a fair bit of filler. Silmarion at times isnt even a story...
I would go as far as to say its mostly drivel......only the most hardened of tolkeinists can get even mildly excited by it. The unfinished tales possibly more so (except for one of em - which is great and then bloody annoying cos it's unfinished!)The Silmarillion is largely Tolkien showing his working - essentially an enormous mythological back-story creating the world in which the published novels are played out. The kind of thing that's notably lacking from things like Lost or the Alien franchise and shows up in the impression that the back story is being reinvented to suit the writer making it up as he goes along.
davepoth said:
RobDickinson said:
"allows us to tell the full story of the adventures of Bilbo Baggins "
Its a short book damned you! It better be done well, dragging it out for 3 payments at the box office is bad form.
A typical screenplay runs to 100 pages. "The Hobbit" is roughly 300 pages. It works out quite nicely really. Its a short book damned you! It better be done well, dragging it out for 3 payments at the box office is bad form.

Either that or the modern film goer cannot sit still that long

Gassing Station | TV, Film, Streaming & Radio | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


