Superhero Battle for the Ages
Author
Discussion

lexusboy

Original Poster:

1,101 posts

174 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
Having a discussion at work, basically who would win; Justice League of America( Superman, Wonder Woman, Green Lantern, Flash, Cyborg and Aquaman) or The Avengers (Thor, Hulk, Ironman, Captain America, Hawkeye and Black Widow plus the Avengers can have Spiderman).

Personally I would say The Avengers but ultimately it would come down to Superman vs The Hulk which I think The Hulk would defeat Superman.

rudecherub

1,997 posts

197 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
Nerd hat on...

Done to death on fan-boy forums, but basically DC characters are by and large imagined to be more powerful than Marvel.

Superman in most versions of his 70 year run could probably defeat the Avengers single handed.



Even the powered down iron-age version of Supes beat the hulk in DC vs Marvel, although IIRC that was done on the basis of fan votes.







...nerd hat off

Nimby

5,745 posts

181 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
But which superhero would be best at each Olympic event?

From my childhood I remember Flash beating Superman in a race because Superman couldn't avoid going through the time barrier. And maybe Aquaman can swim faster than either.

lexusboy

Original Poster:

1,101 posts

174 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
You are correct, Superman has beaten Hulk in a fan vote.

I still think a super enraged Hulk with Betty's life on the line would defeat Superman

rudecherub

1,997 posts

197 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
Nimby said:
But which superhero would be best at each Olympic event?

From my childhood I remember Flash beating Superman in a race because Superman couldn't avoid going through the time barrier. And maybe Aquaman can swim faster than either.
The is the Flash faster than Superman is another old chestnut. ie do we let Supers fly or must he run?

There have been a series of Superman vs Flash races over the years. Definitively saying one is faster than the other tends to release nerd rage from differing teams of fan-boys.

Recently the Flash was given the Speed Force which is a magic explanation for 'Speedsters' speed, this force negates the pesky physical constraints on speed.

So where as Superman flies very fast

- the unified theory of Superman's powers argues his 'super' power is mass manipulation see linky he does endure friction, displaces air ie creates a sonic boom.

The Flash with his magic pass doesn't.

But stuff changes as these stories are constantly tweaked. From the latest reboot. This year.




IIRC Aquaman's top swim speed is 175mph, which is less than Superman which is excess of 36,000 mph minimum, at full Silver Age power Supes can exceed the Speed of light, and travel in time.

But Aquaman can talk to fish.

rudecherub

1,997 posts

197 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
lexusboy said:
You are correct, Superman has beaten Hulk in a fan vote.

I still think a super enraged Hulk with Betty's life on the line would defeat Superman
Well as Frank Miller showed a creative writer can imagine a situation where a couple of human beings, armed with synthetic Kryptonite and a nuclear bomb can beat Superman down.

But generally speaking Superman and DC characters in general are just more powerful than Marvel's. Acknowledged in the Thor vs Superman match, in the DC world the dial goes up to 11.

If *insert hero* or Bond, or Indy Jones couldn't be defeated ( and we know they'll win in the end ) there is no dramatic tension.




Halb

53,012 posts

214 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
rudecherub said:
Well as Frank Miller showed a creative writer can imagine a situation where a couple of human beings, armed with synthetic Kryptonite and a nuclear bomb can beat Superman down.
hehe



Yeah, from what I have read the DC ones are super insane powerful, and the Marvel ones more realistic (still crazy). When it comes down to fan votes it goes nuts anyway. I think in the fan vote one, Supes hit Hulk so hard he split Hulk and Banner apart and they couldn't exist with out each other so he won that way.
I remember WWH Hulk beat BlackBolt and a tonne of nerds (nerdier than metongue out) were upset, but were placated because it was a Skullbiggrin