Who played/plays the best Doctor Who?
Who played/plays the best Doctor Who?

Poll: Who played/plays the best Doctor Who?

Total Members Polled: 190

William Hartnell: 4
Patrick Troughton: 5
Jon Pertwee: 30
Tom Baker: 79
Peter Davison: 1
Colin Baker: 4
Sylvester McCoy: 7
Christopher Eccleston: 34
David Tennant: 51
Matt Smith: 26
Author
Discussion

Morningside

Original Poster:

24,147 posts

260 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
I am going to ignore the Paul McGann version and film adaptations.

So who is/was the best Doctor?

This is NOT for discussion of the current series.
You want this thread for that!
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

Morningside

Original Poster:

24,147 posts

260 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
I gave it multiple choice. Mainly because I cannot choose between Jon Pertwee or Tom Baker. (From my childhood).

stephen300o

15,464 posts

259 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
Although I think Smith is the best of the new three, I voted Tom Baker over all.

CooperD

3,204 posts

208 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
Difficult choice for me as I remember Jon Pertwee and Tom Baker from my distance youth but for me Jon Pertwee just shades it.

Jezz172

792 posts

210 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
Tricky one - Tenant brought it back to the main stream but Baker was/is the man smile

PeanutHead

7,839 posts

201 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all

Morningside

Original Poster:

24,147 posts

260 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
PeanutHead said:
Did not see that.

Wonder if things will change not that Matt Smith has been the Doctor longer.

PeanutHead

7,839 posts

201 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
Morningside said:
Did not see that.

Wonder if things will change not that Matt Smith has been the Doctor longer.
Both polls looking quite balanced though, maybe matt smith isn't as good.

jet_noise

6,109 posts

213 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
Dear MS,

I am the only supporter of Pat Troughton although I have a soft spot for Tom Baker's Brian Blessed stylings. ISTM there is an overwhelming preference for the lighter portrayer, I much prefer the darker more irascible characterisation.

Of the modern era this is why I plump for Chris Ecclestone. I was very disappointed when he chose to move on after just the one series.

Rose Tyler: If you are an alien how come you sound like you're from the North?
The Doctor: Lots of planets have a North!

regards,
Jet

Eighteeteewhy

7,259 posts

199 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
I've never been much of a Dr Whoie?

What are Dr Who fans called?

But I did enjoy Tennant. As for this new one.....

poing

8,743 posts

231 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
Only really watched it in recent years so Tenant and Smith are both my faves.

marshalla

15,902 posts

232 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
I thought it had been agreed that polls of this type only really tell you about the age of the participants ?

Famous Graham

26,553 posts

256 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
Eighteeteewhy said:
I've never been much of a Dr Whoie?

What are Dr Who fans called?

But I did enjoy Tennant. As for this new one.....
Whovians

Teppic

8,104 posts

288 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
From the Classic series - Tom Baker.

Since it came back in 2005 - David Tennant

TheHeretic

73,668 posts

286 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
Baker and Smith.

stephen300o

15,464 posts

259 months

Sunday 2nd September 2012
quotequote all
marshalla said:
I thought it had been agreed that polls of this type only really tell you about the age of the participants ?
The older generally have more choice in who they choose. But You'd have to presume people can be objective rather than pick whoever was playing him when they were ten years old. (for me that was Pertwee but I rate Smith above him).

Caruso

7,559 posts

287 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
Tom Baker is Dr Who for me.

When I was about 10 I met him while they were filming 'The Seeds of Doom' he ended our conversation by saying how he had to go the the BBC canteen as "even Time Lords have to eat."

Legend.

munky

5,328 posts

279 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
Tom Baker.

I absolutely loved it when he was, temporarily, the voice of the BT text to voice service. I would send messages to the landlines of everyone I knew saying, "hello. I am the Doctor". It amused me, anyway.

Pints

18,451 posts

225 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
Skipped voting.

I've never watched an episode of Doctor Who.

John_S4x4

1,364 posts

288 months

Tuesday 4th September 2012
quotequote all
Just to be stupid, I think it's a bit like who played the best James Bond

David Tennant is a Pierce Brosnan
Jon Pertwee is Roger Moore
Peter Davidson is a Daniel Graig
William Hartnell is a George Lazenby
Tom Baker is a Sean Connery