The $750 million Thief
Discussion
True, but if he had kept on the straight and narrow after the first scam had paid out and he had repaid people, he would have probably earned just as much legitimately. It was more the fact he had to have the trappings of success immediately.
Sorry, documentary was about Marc Dreier, New York lawyer who was convicted of stealing $400 million from Hedge Funds.
Sorry, documentary was about Marc Dreier, New York lawyer who was convicted of stealing $400 million from Hedge Funds.
mercfunder said:
True, but if he had kept on the straight and narrow after the first scam had paid out and he had repaid people, he would have probably earned just as much legitimately. It was more the fact he had to have the trappings of success immediately.
Sorry, documentary was about Marc Dreier, New York lawyer who was convicted of stealing $400 million from Hedge Funds.
That is the nature of fraud. Sorry, documentary was about Marc Dreier, New York lawyer who was convicted of stealing $400 million from Hedge Funds.
A fraudster starts on a path of deception -
finds they have got away with it -
does it again -
and again -
the amounts get bigger and start to accumulate
Eventually the scheme collapses because it gets too big and impossible to hide.
If you follow any fraud - whether it is an employee in a corner shop dipping into the till or a fund manager running a Ponzi scheme - you will see that same patterns of behaviour emerge.
Eric Mc said:
mercfunder said:
True, but if he had kept on the straight and narrow after the first scam had paid out and he had repaid people, he would have probably earned just as much legitimately. It was more the fact he had to have the trappings of success immediately.
Sorry, documentary was about Marc Dreier, New York lawyer who was convicted of stealing $400 million from Hedge Funds.
That is the nature of fraud. Sorry, documentary was about Marc Dreier, New York lawyer who was convicted of stealing $400 million from Hedge Funds.
A fraudster starts on a path of deception -
finds they have got away with it -
does it again -
and again -
the amounts get bigger and start to accumulate
Eventually the scheme collapses because it gets too big and impossible to hide.
If you follow any fraud - whether it is an employee in a corner shop dipping into the till or a fund manager running a Ponzi scheme - you will see that same patterns of behaviour emerge.
Watching it ow on iPlayer.
It seems the initial motivation was a form of jealousy. He was a fairly ordinary lawyer employed by a law firm on a decent wage and felt he wasn't getting the "rewards" he "deserved" and he saw the lifestyles his clients were achieving and wanted some of that for himself.
It seems the initial motivation was a form of jealousy. He was a fairly ordinary lawyer employed by a law firm on a decent wage and felt he wasn't getting the "rewards" he "deserved" and he saw the lifestyles his clients were achieving and wanted some of that for himself.
I thought he came across incredibly badly on the whole.
Didn't seem overly sorry for what he'd done or the people he'd abused, kept banging on how about much charity work he'd done (with other people's money) then kept whining on about how much he'd hurt his kids etc.
Talking with his lawyer near the end and saying "I'm no Madoff. I only had 26 victims and only stole $400 million". Arguing for a low security prison and "I'm not working 8 hrs in a kitchen".
utter military grade cock-end.
Didn't seem overly sorry for what he'd done or the people he'd abused, kept banging on how about much charity work he'd done (with other people's money) then kept whining on about how much he'd hurt his kids etc.
Talking with his lawyer near the end and saying "I'm no Madoff. I only had 26 victims and only stole $400 million". Arguing for a low security prison and "I'm not working 8 hrs in a kitchen".
utter military grade cock-end.
arfur sleep said:
I thought he came across incredibly badly on the whole.
utter military grade cock-end.
I didn't think that, he was willing to do the time and accepted he had done wrong.utter military grade cock-end.
Remember he said he sat in Dubai with $100 million in the bank and could have just chosen not to return, also he knew the game was up in Toronto, yet still went back.
I reckon anybody looking at prison would be looking for the softest option.
What does come across is that, all through the period the fraud was being perpetrated, there doesn't seem to have been a smidgen of guilt or doubt in what he was doing.
Obviously, once the fraud collapsed - as such large frauds are bound to do - the reality of the situation hit him and, to his credit, he owned up and is doing the time.
However, he still doesn't REALLY seem to think that what he did was all that bad. And he doesn't seem to have any inkling of the serious character flaws that served as his motivation.
Obviously, once the fraud collapsed - as such large frauds are bound to do - the reality of the situation hit him and, to his credit, he owned up and is doing the time.
However, he still doesn't REALLY seem to think that what he did was all that bad. And he doesn't seem to have any inkling of the serious character flaws that served as his motivation.
Marf said:
Without wishing to minimise what he did even the Judge agreed with that assertion.
No argument from me on that however he still stole over $400m from various people and his actions led directly to hundreds if not thousands of the people losing their jobs and suffering financial hardship whilst he was complaining about being under house arrest in his "prison" of a penthouse apartment getting good food delivered whenever he wanted, reading the papers and watching TV.arfur sleep said:
No argument from me on that however he still stole over $400m from various people and his actions led directly to hundreds if not thousands of the people losing their jobs and suffering financial hardship whilst he was complaining about being under house arrest in his "prison" of a penthouse apartment getting good food delivered whenever he wanted, reading the papers and watching TV.
You know where I said "without wanting to minimise what he did", that was intended to avoid you going off on one about his crime in response to my comment, which was solely on the comparison between him and Madoff 
Criminals are always wont to compare their particular crime with those they consider to have committed, in their eyes, a worse crime. It helps them feel better about what they have done.
Perhaps they would do better to compare their crime with those who HAVEN'T committed a crime.
In essence, their moral and ethical yardstick is broken or simply non-existant.
Perhaps they would do better to compare their crime with those who HAVEN'T committed a crime.
In essence, their moral and ethical yardstick is broken or simply non-existant.
Eric Mc said:
Criminals are always wont to compare their particular crime with those they consider to have committed, in their eyes, a worse crime. It helps them feel better about what they have done..
Or it helps them to better understand the sanction they face...So with all that in mind, how do you view sentencing as a concept? Surely there has to be some kind of gradation of crime otherwise sentencing should be equal for all frauds, all murders, all assaults etc etc?
Again, not seeking to minimise his crime, but it strikes me as perfectly natural in terms of our natural survival instinct that he would compare his crimes to those of others in an attempt to understand the likely punishment.
Is this unpalatable? Perhaps. Is it understandable? Totally.
Often this comparison has no other function other than to make the criminal feel better about themselves. You see it even when people get stopped for a minor motoring offence. They will often have a go at the police officer for not spending their time better catching "real criminals". It's the same thought process.
Sentencing is a different (although linked) issue. Dreier did well to "only" get 20 years for what he did, considering how harshly fraud is normally treated in US courts. Of course, in the UK he would have got 2 years suspended for being silly and geting a bit careless.
Sentencing is a different (although linked) issue. Dreier did well to "only" get 20 years for what he did, considering how harshly fraud is normally treated in US courts. Of course, in the UK he would have got 2 years suspended for being silly and geting a bit careless.
mercfunder said:
I didn't think that, he was willing to do the time and accepted he had done wrong.
Remember he said he sat in Dubai with $100 million in the bank and could have just chosen not to return, also he knew the game was up in Toronto, yet still went back.
I reckon anybody looking at prison would be looking for the softest option.
There was a passage where he was talking about his motivation and he couldn't or didn't just say Remember he said he sat in Dubai with $100 million in the bank and could have just chosen not to return, also he knew the game was up in Toronto, yet still went back.
I reckon anybody looking at prison would be looking for the softest option.
"I wanted the money so I took it" he talked around it, about how he'd not been as successful as he'd hoped and he wanted to run his own company but didn't have funds & couldn't secure loans because he wasn't "known". So he stole the money rather than working harder, better, smarter for it.
And then sat there and said most of us would do the same if presented with the opportunity to do the same and "get away with it".
Really?
No, not really. Just those who are arrogant enough to think that they can will Mark, and that's a small club you're in.
Eric Mc said:
Often this comparison has no other function other than to make the criminal feel better about themselves. ..... Sentencing is a different (although linked) issue. Dreier did well to "only" get 20 years for what he did, considering how harshly fraud is normally treated in US courts.
Leaving aside what I've trimmed from your post... Granted, but when the judicial system makes the same comparisons for reasons of sentencing it's not surprising that criminals will seek to understand their likely sanction whether or not that is to make themselves feel better about their punishment or simply to rationalise their future.I'm not sure I agree he did well to only get 20 years, it seems proportional set against Madoff's fraud which was perpetrated for 40 odd years and affected the lives of many more when the house of cards came tumbling down.
Edited by Marf on Thursday 6th September 13:46
Eric Mc said:
Often this comparison has no other function other than to make the criminal feel better about themselves. You see it even when people get stopped for a minor motoring offence. They will often have a go at the police officer for not spending their time better catching "real criminals". It's the same thought process.
Sentencing is a different (although linked) issue. Dreier did well to "only" get 20 years for what he did, considering how harshly fraud is normally treated in US courts. Of course, in the UK he would have got 2 years suspended for being silly and geting a bit careless.
There is an arrogance of the powerful that sometimes leads them to think that the rules are not for them, I think. You see it just as much with high flying CEOs who enrich themselves for short term gains and underinvest in the future. Evidently they are not criminals, but they do share that sense of being demigods. I agree that the 20 year sentence was very light indeed. Sentencing is a different (although linked) issue. Dreier did well to "only" get 20 years for what he did, considering how harshly fraud is normally treated in US courts. Of course, in the UK he would have got 2 years suspended for being silly and geting a bit careless.
Gassing Station | TV, Film, Streaming & Radio | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


