Downton Abbey - are the cars authentic ?
Downton Abbey - are the cars authentic ?
Author
Discussion

AAGR

Original Poster:

918 posts

192 months

Monday 17th September 2012
quotequote all
Was watching the first episode of the latest Downton Abbey series last evening. Good hokum, great production values - but I'm puzzled about the cars.

The scenario was set in 1920 (a sub-title told us as much), yet I reckon a number of cars used were rather more modern than that. I'm not an expert on this period, but surely at least two of the machines could not have been built before 1925 at least ?

Comments ?

AAGR


stevejh

799 posts

235 months

Monday 17th September 2012
quotequote all
Well I don't know about the new series but apparently thay've got form in the first series where a 1921 Model T was shown when the programme was set in 1912!

http://channelhopping.onthebox.com/2011/10/10/the-...

AAGR

Original Poster:

918 posts

192 months

Monday 17th September 2012
quotequote all
You mustn't blame Julian Fellowes for many of these mistakes. The errors are/were almost all due to the lack of knowledge, or even interest, of the set dresser/location adviser/continuity staff ....

[And, believe me, I have been in touch with such people, whose main object is (their words) 'to make good TV'. A recent example is of a TV company which called me to ask for details of the 1954 RAC rally, saying that they intended to use a TR6 to re-create some of the run. When I pointed out that the rally was actually won by a TR2, I was brushed off imperiously ....]

AAGR


Morningside

24,147 posts

260 months

Monday 17th September 2012
quotequote all
If making a period drama they really should make an effort to sort all parts for authenticity.

I suppose it does not matter too much if the wrong model or a couple of years out BUT not like this humongous gaff like this classic from "Ashes to Ashes"

Gaspode

4,167 posts

227 months

Monday 17th September 2012
quotequote all
Morningside said:
If making a period drama they really should make an effort to sort all parts for authenticity.
Ok, so how much extra would you be prepared to pay on your weekly food shop to fund the cost of this drive to authenticity?

Does it really bother you that the soup bowl they used in the dining room scene was painted in a design that wasn't actually available until 1 week after the episode was set, or that the drawing room curtains had been dyed with a modern synthetic dye, or that Lord Whatisname's waistcoat had been sewn with a nylon thread?

The car gaffes only bother us because we know about cars, but in every programme there must be loads of people spotting inaccuracies in some little detail. Mrs Gaspode knows textiles inside out, and is forever pointing out minor details which I don't give a stuff about.

It's a story. It didn't really happen, so it's impossible for it ever to be a historically accurate recreation.

Morningside

24,147 posts

260 months

Monday 17th September 2012
quotequote all
No, I mean having the right stitching for example would be silly BUT I am talking about fairly major gaffs more than small ones. I mean the mid 1990s Rover has got to be a major balls up by any standard.

I understand that there needs to be some artistic licence but would you say the same about the history of Churchill for instance? Wrong aircraft but close example or giving his famous speeches into a 1960s microphone.


Although I do know someone who took the Sinclair story on the BBC a few months back exactly word for word!


Edited by Morningside on Monday 17th September 19:06

LukeSi

5,780 posts

192 months

Monday 17th September 2012
quotequote all
Morningside said:
If making a period drama they really should make an effort to sort all parts for authenticity.

I suppose it does not matter too much if the wrong model or a couple of years out BUT not like this humongous gaff like this classic from "Ashes to Ashes"
I can beat that, not got a picture but in one scene I saw a modern BMW parked in the background, can't remember if it was an E60 or an E65.

Gaspode

4,167 posts

227 months

Monday 17th September 2012
quotequote all
Morningside said:
I am talking about fairly major gaffs more than small ones. I understand that there needs to be some artistic licence.

But would you say the same about the history of Churchill for instance? Wrong aircraft but close example or giving his famous speeches into a 1960s microphone.
The size of the gaffe is purely dictated by the observer. Mrs Gaspode couldn't give a monkey's frolic about the years of the cars, but watch her jump and shout if she spots a man-made fabric.

As to the Churchill analogy, I would say it depends on the intent of the programme. If it's trying to be a detailed and accurate representation of the actual situation, then it should be done right. If it's a dramatised account of the nature of his character, then probably not.

Downton Abbey is just a bit of escapist fluff. Highly entertaining, but not particularly historically accurate - witness the late 20th C speech patterns in the script. It's designed to be accessible by people who don't have a clue what life was really like in the first quarter of the 20th century.

Morningside

24,147 posts

260 months

Monday 17th September 2012
quotequote all
Hmmm. True. I suppose it was a case of 'get me a mid wartime car'.
Same applied to "Heartbeat" where it seemed to drift from 1960-69 without any logic.

Not Downton, but I swear on another period drama you could see a sticker showing what car show it had been in.

Zad

13,024 posts

267 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
Morningside said:
If making a period drama they really should make an effort to sort all parts for authenticity.

I suppose it does not matter too much if the wrong model or a couple of years out BUT not like this humongous gaff like this classic from "Ashes to Ashes"
The A2A (and Life On Mars) anachronisms were sort-of explained by the premise of the series. It wasn't really happening in the past, but in the main character's head. Of course the same can't be said of Downton, but they are hardly glaring errors.

Morningside

24,147 posts

260 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
Nice try smile I mean, who the hell would think of a mid nineties Rover.

Johnnytheboy

24,499 posts

217 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
On a related note, in 'Withnail and I' when they are returning to London they pass an M25 sign - I suppose about 20 years too early.

nickdrinkwater

839 posts

221 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
Dark Blue is the worst (film about police corruption starring Kurt Russel). It's set in the early 1990s and features the LA Riots etc. but about 5 minutes in you see a wide shot and its full of Ford Focuses and modern Honda Accords. Spoiled it for me sadly.

oldbanger

4,328 posts

269 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
The BBC Robin Hood series was dreadful for this. Why were they wearing woodland camo, desert boots and gap hoodies?

MadMullah

5,299 posts

224 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
...or robin hood the film starring crowe and the landing craft...