Is Breast Best? BBC1 now.
Author
Discussion

Dr Doofenshmirtz

Original Poster:

16,952 posts

231 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
It was going well until the bloke put breast milk on his Cornflakes yikes

Anyway...boobies and stuff. Excellent.

Nicol@

3,851 posts

267 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
I have recorded it, ready to watch and debate with my mum, as I am a breastfeeder and my mum is against it.

Hope it is an informative programme.

bexVN

14,698 posts

242 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
How can anyone be against breast? To not want to breastfeed is a personal choice but to be against it is a bit strange.

Hopefully it'll be on catch up, wouldn't mind seeing it.

DJRC

23,563 posts

267 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
bexVN said:
How can anyone be against breast? To not want to breastfeed is a personal choice but to be against it is a bit strange.

Hopefully it'll be on catch up, wouldn't mind seeing it.
Jeesh bex, get with the modern times girl!!! Dont you know anything? We know best now! Ignore the last 12000+ yrs of humanity successfully managing to raise its kids using the good old fashioned Mk1 mammary gland, we now have formula! Scientific formula!

The arrogance of modern humanity never ceases to make me laugh.

bexVN

14,698 posts

242 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
DJRC said:
bexVN said:
How can anyone be against breast? To not want to breastfeed is a personal choice but to be against it is a bit strange.

Hopefully it'll be on catch up, wouldn't mind seeing it.
Jeesh bex, get with the modern times girl!!! Dont you know anything? We know best now! Ignore the last 12000+ yrs of humanity successfully managing to raise its kids using the good old fashioned Mk1 mammary gland, we now have formula! Scientific formula!

The arrogance of modern humanity never ceases to make me laugh.
hehe Very true, though I should also have said 'or not be able to breastfeed' I had to mix feed my boy in the end as he wasn't thriving just by me, so I realise it's not a black and white subject, I just don't get how someone (esp a female) be actually against the idea!

Edited by bexVN on Wednesday 3rd October 09:59

Bacardi

2,235 posts

307 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
bexVN said:
I just don't get how someone (esp a female) be actually against the idea!
I think it has something to do with novel "Baby's Revenge' by Nora Tittsov. smile

I didn't see the first part of the show, or understand why younger women are against it. Is it something to do with keeping your breasts in better shape by not feeding, something of a fashion statement? But obviously, breast is best, as it should be for the child's earliest nutritional feeds.

I just happened to change channels just as some woman was pulling a nork out (which usually gets my attention), however, I'm not kinky and don't find breastfeeding some turn on. But an observation I have made, is how my friend's wives are quite open about breast feeding at least in front of me, if not in public generally. I have no problem with it, appreciate the kid may well need a feed at an awkward time and toilets are not nice places. If I do see it in public, I avert my gaze in a gentlemanly manner.

Like most heterosexual men, I like breasts. I know their primary function is for feeding, but they have another purpose in attraction, so it it's perfectly normal for us guys to want to look at them and we do at every opportunity. So I find it a little strange when women are happy to share them, when they wouldn't normally, as long as a baby is on them. If I asked a female friend who wasn't nursing, or If I saw a women I liked the look of out shopping and went up to her and said 'can I have a peep at your baps' more than likely, and quite rightly, I'd get a slap!

So again found it strange to see the, almost militant, group of women petitioning coffee shops and the like to support open breastfeeding in public places with stickers in the window etc. I find it a little exhibitionist the way they were going about it. If a woman sat at a table next to me breasting feeding it wouldn't bother me, it's a natural act after all, just like having a pee, but somethings should be kept a little more private, imo....

marcosgt

11,506 posts

207 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
I must admit, I can never see how (or why) anyone takes offence at a woman breastfeeding.

I must admit, now and then it can seem unexpected (maybe even inappropriate at times - say in a business meeting biggrin), but to suggest there's anything 'sexy' about a woman breastfeeding is (as the previous poster said) frankly odd.

I like women's breasts as much as the next man (I think), but I don't feel the slightest stirrings when I see a woman breastfeeding, any more than I do when I see a baby being bottlefed.

It's a perfectly natural thing, not 'exciting' or 'stimulating', but equally I don't feel women who don't breastfeed are 'bad', it's a choice they can make in my view. I understand it can be very painful!

M

Bacardi

2,235 posts

307 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
marcosgt said:
but to suggest there's anything 'sexy' about a woman breastfeeding is (as the previous poster said) frankly odd.
Except I said exactly the opposite....

sunnygym

1,082 posts

206 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
It's natural
It's free
It's sterile
It has ainti bodies
It's perfect formula
It help mum get back into shape
Can express and freeze for later date

But most importantly it means I dont have to get up at 4am to warm a bottle when my little one wakes up crying to be feed. Woop smile

Nicol@

3,851 posts

267 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
My mum sees breastfeeding as an inconvenience and that a baby can grow into a healthy adult on formula alone (as I did). Mum keeps telling me to stop breastfeeding because of its effects on me, but she has always been 'anti'.


bexVN

14,698 posts

242 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
That's ashame. You always hope Mums will support your decisions, esp ones like this.

bexVN

14,698 posts

242 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
That's ashame. You always hope Mums will support your decisions, esp ones like this.