Ideal Top Gear presenter line-up
Ideal Top Gear presenter line-up
Author
Discussion

MadCaptainJack

Original Poster:

1,723 posts

68 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
I stumbled across Jason Cammisa's videos on Youtube recently, and instantly thought to myself "He should be presenting Top Gear."

After a few days of thinking...

..I reached the conclusion that I'd like to see Chris Harris, Jason Cammisa, and Henry Catchpole present the next series of Top Gear.

What's your ideal line-up?

mk1coopers

1,448 posts

180 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
Waits for first vote of Clarkson, Hammond and May….. coffee

Zarco

20,859 posts

237 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
Chris Harris on his own.

jameswills

3,583 posts

71 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
Woollard, Clarkson, Tiff.


Jenny Tailor

1,727 posts

65 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
Just wondering when its days will be numbered.

We now have everyday electric cars that can humiliate hypercars in 1/4 mile.
Over time the tech will trickle down to be affordable to everyone.

Can you imagine a never ending parade of 17 year old kids ready for the traffic light Grand Prix?

The presenters will end up saying "And ina drag race it crossed the finish line.... exactly the same as every other electric car"

Legislation will kick in....
Anyway - Clarkson, May, Hammond.

As I kid I grew up with Woodard, Young Clarkson etc.
"The boot space of this car is 0.15 cubic meters bigger than that car".. No thanks. I only had 3 channels.




jameswills

3,583 posts

71 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
The old original Top Gears were perfect, informative simple and to the point. Cars then did develop on the same plane for the latter part of the 90s and into the 2000s and Clarkson and Co recognised this and invented New Too Gear. Nothing has really changed since 2005 in car tech apart from marketing. As you can see from the current Top Gear episodes. I’d rather watch the Polar special than anything from TG in the last 10 years, and add to that the Grand Tour. They are all flogging a dead horse

If it’s entertaining though, does it really matter?

resolve10

1,236 posts

73 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
Chris Harris
Henry Catchpole
Sam from Seen Thru Glass

Nickp82

3,908 posts

121 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
Louise Redknapp, Stacey off Eastenders, Harriet Kemsley

FiF

48,559 posts

279 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
Bovingdon has to be in with a shout somewhere in all this.

frisbee

5,573 posts

138 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
Mike Brewer, some random tosser from Youtube and the chairman of Brake!

jameswills

3,583 posts

71 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
frisbee said:
Mike Brewer, some random tosser from Youtube and the chairman of Brake!
Gets my vote!

Red9zero

11,105 posts

85 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
Katie Price, Yellowjack, Elon Musk

MadCaptainJack

Original Poster:

1,723 posts

68 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
mk1coopers said:
Waits for first vote of Clarkson, Hammond and May….. coffee
Has-beens.

I spent a long, long time trying to decide between Harry Metcalfe and Catchpole before concluding that Harry probably wouldn't want the full presenting gig anyway, and would be better suited to a regular in-studio spot giving an update on the latest developments in e-fuel/hydrogen/ammonia, plus a more in-depth segment every second or third episode.

HustleRussell

26,429 posts

188 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
jameswills said:
Nothing has really changed since 2005 in car tech apart from marketing.
Nothing, in 17 years?

daqinggregg

5,335 posts

157 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
Tim Shaw, passion, Chris Harris, ability and Freddie Flintoff, have a go, enthusiasm.

Dromedary66

1,924 posts

166 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
James Cordon
Jack Whitehall
Rylan Clark

cuprabob

19,334 posts

242 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
Nadiya Hussain
Nikki Fox
Zoe Ball

LunarOne

7,281 posts

165 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
resolve10 said:
Sam from Seen Thru Glass
The last person I would want to see, with the exception of that Schmeeer guy. God it would be bloody awful.

I'd go with Henry Catchpole, Matt Farah and Harry Metcalfe.

cavebloke

650 posts

255 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
Chris Harris
Richard Porter
Jonny Smith

resolve10

1,236 posts

73 months

Friday 15th April 2022
quotequote all
LunarOne said:
The last person I would want to see, with the exception of that Schmeeer guy. God it would be bloody awful.

I'd go with Henry Catchpole, Matt Farah and Harry Metcalfe.
Schmee is a bit too cheesy for my tastes but I'd still take him, JWW, TGE and STG over the likes of Paddy McGuiness and Matt LeBlanc. The YouTube guys are actually passionate about cars, for the other guys it's just work.

STG was my pick of the bunch as he seems the most genuine and down to earth of them all.