Monty Python was old school tie unfunny crap
Monty Python was old school tie unfunny crap
Author
Discussion

M138

Original Poster:

1,119 posts

16 months

It was never funny. Plenty of false laughter from goons who made out it was hilarious.

Smint

3,077 posts

60 months

It was when you were a schoolboy at the time, it was something quite new.
Comedy often comes from University days, Fry/Laurie being fine examples from more recent era, good for them they made a kings fortune from it, haven't clue what the current trend in comedy is gave up on television years ago.

Times and trends move on, whats on message this week will be scorned in due course too.

Austin Prefect

2,124 posts

17 months

Most of it wasn't funny. But some of it was very good indeed, and it was something very different which is why it got such a reaction at the time. Who would the OP regard as consistently funny?

hammo19

7,274 posts

221 months

Still funny now.

CanAm

13,277 posts

297 months

M138 said:
It was never funny. Plenty of false laughter from goons who made out it was hilarious.
You are too young to have appreciated it when it was first introduced. You need to compare it with mainstream comedy of the time in order to appreciate that it was a breath of fresh air.

Douglas Quaid

2,623 posts

110 months

You’ll have to go back in time and tell the young me who laughed at it that I was incorrect and should stop laughing then.

Roofless Toothless

7,259 posts

157 months

I can only contribute this.


fridaypassion

11,386 posts

253 months

Funny is subjective. Rosie Jones has a career I mean I don't find her funny at all but people must pay to see her shows.

Slightly less doubt above Monty Python though. The Holy Grail I must gave seen 20 times and its still funny and a lot of it still relevant. I remember rolling round in tears as a 10 year old watching it whilst my father a normally very dour man similarly tickled. Not much comedy that spans generations in that way.

paulguitar

34,365 posts

138 months

It was inconsistent, definitely, but the best stuff was exceptional and holds up very well to this day.


Anyone who is not amused by their best stuff must surely just not have any sense of humour.

GAjon

4,021 posts

238 months

“Is this the five minute argument or full half hour?”

Skyedriver

22,585 posts

307 months

Python was must watch comedy back when it was fresh. Loved it, the silliness, the word play, the outfits, great humour and I don't recall any swearing either.
Times change, some of it is less funny now, maybe I'm just used to it. Very little on TV now is really new comedy and funny too. Everyone is so scared about "offending" someone whereas in the 70's it was considered normal.
Poster above mentioned Rosie Jones, I don't find her funny in the slightest, another is Sarah Millican who hails from my area. On the other hand, I saw a bit of a Seth Meyer stand up routine on TV a few nights ago and found him refreshingly funny.

Sporky

10,860 posts

89 months

paulguitar said:
It was inconsistent, definitely, but the best stuff was exceptional and holds up very well to this day.
And it was, as has been said, new and different. I think Milligan and The Goon Show had already done surreal, but Python (in the good bits) cemented it.

Edited by Sporky on Sunday 17th May 09:29

ExBoringVolvoDriver

11,486 posts

68 months

M138 said:
It was never funny. Plenty of false laughter from goons who made out it was hilarious.
In your opinion - for those of us old farts who can remember when it first came out, it was (And for now something completely) different from the Sit Coms of the time.

Yes, it was off the wall and perhaps required a certain sense of humour which is always unique to individuals.

I could name a load of comedy shows which people rave about where people find hilarious.

I never found The Goons funny.

paulguitar

34,365 posts

138 months

GAjon said:
Is this the five minute argument or full half hour?
I've told you once.

fridaypassion

11,386 posts

253 months

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZmInkxbvlCs

You can't watch this without a chuckle come on!

Getragdogleg

9,938 posts

208 months

Don't watch it again then.

If I don't like something I don't do it again and that seems to solve the problem for me.

Give it a whirl.

Essel

582 posts

171 months



Could be an aged thing. It was funny to us, so stayed funny.

Mr Pointy

12,979 posts

184 months

M138 said:
It was never funny. Plenty of false laughter from goons who made out it was hilarious.
You're wrong, but never mind. How about you post a list of who you think is funny?

BigMon

6,112 posts

154 months

paulguitar said:
It was inconsistent, definitely, but the best stuff was exceptional and holds up very well to this day.


Anyone who is not amused by their best stuff must surely just not have any sense of humour.
Exactly. I've never seen that military parade sketch above and that made me laugh just now.

mogg

411 posts

283 months

paulguitar said:
It was inconsistent, definitely, but the best stuff was exceptional and holds up very well to this day.


Anyone who is not amused by their best stuff must surely just not have any sense of humour.
+1 Absolutely !