Claudia Winkleman is named Film 2010 host
Discussion
Claudia Winkleman is named Film 2010 host
I know that a lot of people don't like Ross, but I thought he did a great job of presenting Film. Can't say that I think Winkleman is an obvious choice.
I know that a lot of people don't like Ross, but I thought he did a great job of presenting Film. Can't say that I think Winkleman is an obvious choice.
Edited by MX7 on Monday 29th March 14:28
Has dumbing down gone too far?
I'll wait and see, we have to give her the opportunity to be good. She is a presenter, so if the research team behind her are good, it might not be a complete lost cause.
Ross was either a very enthusiastic movie critic, who really knew his stuff, or did an AMAZING job of convincing us he knew what he was talking about.
I'll wait and see, we have to give her the opportunity to be good. She is a presenter, so if the research team behind her are good, it might not be a complete lost cause.
Ross was either a very enthusiastic movie critic, who really knew his stuff, or did an AMAZING job of convincing us he knew what he was talking about.
Kermode was my choice too, but he is the obvious replacement. My only reservation about him is that I don't think he would view something trashy and fun, like a Stallone film, in the same way that Ross could.
DrTre said:
Am surprised at the vitriol against her, I think she's very good.
I think the point is that no one has ever considered her to be a fan of film. Personally, after Kermode, I think they should have considered some of the broadsheet/internet film critics. I'm sure some of them would be more than capable.Jesus Christ...when will tv execs get it into their fking tiny heads that professional tv presenters will never be as good at presenting as someone who has a genuine interest in the programme material???
FFS why noy get melinda messenger or Jordan to do it. Mark Kermode was the only choice.
Disgrace.
FFS why noy get melinda messenger or Jordan to do it. Mark Kermode was the only choice.
Disgrace.
Gassing Station | TV, Film, Video Streaming & Radio | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff