How does this organisation have any credibility left?
Discussion
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-1792...
So despite lying in 2010 about his involvement in the 1975 abuse case, not informing the police and then covering it up for 30 odd years, Cardinal Brady still reckons has no reason to resign....
Senior Vatican Prosecutor Monsignor Charles Scicluna has defended Cardinal Brady, "....My second point is that in the interest of the Church in Ireland, they need to have Cardinal Brady as the archbishop of Armagh because he has shown determination in promoting child protection policies. You need to have leaders who have learned the hard way and are determined to protect children."
You have got to be kidding. (no pun intended)
So despite lying in 2010 about his involvement in the 1975 abuse case, not informing the police and then covering it up for 30 odd years, Cardinal Brady still reckons has no reason to resign....
Senior Vatican Prosecutor Monsignor Charles Scicluna has defended Cardinal Brady, "....My second point is that in the interest of the Church in Ireland, they need to have Cardinal Brady as the archbishop of Armagh because he has shown determination in promoting child protection policies. You need to have leaders who have learned the hard way and are determined to protect children."
You have got to be kidding. (no pun intended)

Steffan said:
In a word NO. No credibility whatsoever.
That will not affect the priests from continuing their evil dishonesty and revolting abuse. It seems to be entirely apposite within Catholicism. Says an awful lot about that religion.
So, in a word NO.
When you consider their proven links with the Mafia, supporting of Hitler in WW2, institutional covering up of criminal acts across many countries and many decades, centuries of opposition to female priest/bishops, hatred of homosexuals, propagation of AIDS and other STD's in Africa by banning condom usage....it just goes on and on.That will not affect the priests from continuing their evil dishonesty and revolting abuse. It seems to be entirely apposite within Catholicism. Says an awful lot about that religion.
So, in a word NO.
My flabber is well and truly gassted that anyone of any intelligence could even begin to want to be an RC....whether you're born into it or not.
Just look what Murdoch is going thru for hacking a few Z list celebs voicemails....
Jimbeaux said:
Like any huge organization, much less a worldwide one, there is good and bad. Sadly, only the bad makes news; therefore, all of the good goes unnoticed. Simple.
Quite a long history of some quite bad events wouldn't you agree though?? And in total opposition to their own stated position of being the moral keepers of society and conveying "God's" word to man. If there's one organisation that HAS to be whiter than white (or holier than thou if you prefer) to have any credibility, it's a religious one. djstevec said:
Jimbeaux said:
Like any huge organization, much less a worldwide one, there is good and bad. Sadly, only the bad makes news; therefore, all of the good goes unnoticed. Simple.
Quite a long history of some quite bad events wouldn't you agree though?? And in total opposition to their own stated position of being the moral keepers of society and conveying "God's" word to man. If there's one organisation that HAS to be whiter than white (or holier than thou if you prefer) to have any credibility, it's a religious one. I have never understood why the religious are so forgiving of criminality and abuse within the priesthood. It seems to me to defy any sense. But they do and the Catholic church is amongst the worst for this.
MP's are calling for the head of Rupert Murdoch for allowing illegal telephone tapping. How does this compare with child abuse in the Catholic church?
Surely many times worse. Yet no action is taken. Utterly disgraceful and wrong. But apparently entirely acceptable, providing you are Catholic?
djstevec said:
Jimbeaux said:
Like any huge organization, much less a worldwide one, there is good and bad. Sadly, only the bad makes news; therefore, all of the good goes unnoticed. Simple.
Quite a long history of some quite bad events wouldn't you agree though?? And in total opposition to their own stated position of being the moral keepers of society and conveying "God's" word to man. If there's one organisation that HAS to be whiter than white (or holier than thou if you prefer) to have any credibility, it's a religious one. 
djstevec said:
Jimbeaux said:
Like any huge organization, much less a worldwide one, there is good and bad. Sadly, only the bad makes news; therefore, all of the good goes unnoticed. Simple.
Quite a long history of some quite bad events wouldn't you agree though?? And in total opposition to their own stated position of being the moral keepers of society and conveying "God's" word to man. If there's one organisation that HAS to be whiter than white (or holier than thou if you prefer) to have any credibility, it's a religious one. Jimbeaux said:
Steffan said:
I have never understood why the religious are so forgiving of criminality and abuse within the priesthood. Yet no action is taken.
Activity such as that, if proven, is the territory of the law to correct, is it not?I would have thought any Christian would denounce such evil outright. Or do Christians only militate against proven criminals. Is there no more Sin to denounce?
Apparently not. Hence the complete lack of credibility in the Catholic Church.
DJRC said:
djstevec said:
Jimbeaux said:
Like any huge organization, much less a worldwide one, there is good and bad. Sadly, only the bad makes news; therefore, all of the good goes unnoticed. Simple.
Quite a long history of some quite bad events wouldn't you agree though?? And in total opposition to their own stated position of being the moral keepers of society and conveying "God's" word to man. If there's one organisation that HAS to be whiter than white (or holier than thou if you prefer) to have any credibility, it's a religious one. edited for bad speeling
Edited by djstevec on Wednesday 2nd May 15:07
Steffan said:
Jimbeaux said:
Steffan said:
I have never understood why the religious are so forgiving of criminality and abuse within the priesthood. Yet no action is taken.
Activity such as that, if proven, is the territory of the law to correct, is it not?I would have thought any Christian would denounce such evil outright. Or do Christians only militate against proven criminals. Is there no more Sin to denounce?
Apparently not. Hence the complete lack of credibility in the Catholic Church.
BTW, I am not a Catholic; too much ceremony.I'm Catholic (Right now I can feel the PH vultures ready to pounce on me...!
)
However, I 100% agree that the number of criminal activities within the priesthood has gone too far to be seen as a few isolated cases. The Church needs to step up and deal with this once and for all. Additionally, a great deal of Catholics feel the same. It's a disgrace and totally takes away from what the Church should be doing.
I agree that there are a number of the policies in place that don't make sense (Comdoms in Africa can certainly be seen as one of those) but, and I know someone has already mocked this point, there are a GREAT deal of priests/nuns/lay Catholics out there doing amazing work for the poor and vunerable of society which is really what the Church should be doing.
Yes the past of the Church is littered with major issues but you show me a country or organisation that doesn't have some blots on its copybook? However, the child abuse case has gone on too long with too little done about it and it needs someone in the Church to step up, admit the problem and tackle it head on and forcefully by de-frocking/excumonicating those involved who had knowledge of the abuse and then assisting in a police investigation.
)However, I 100% agree that the number of criminal activities within the priesthood has gone too far to be seen as a few isolated cases. The Church needs to step up and deal with this once and for all. Additionally, a great deal of Catholics feel the same. It's a disgrace and totally takes away from what the Church should be doing.
I agree that there are a number of the policies in place that don't make sense (Comdoms in Africa can certainly be seen as one of those) but, and I know someone has already mocked this point, there are a GREAT deal of priests/nuns/lay Catholics out there doing amazing work for the poor and vunerable of society which is really what the Church should be doing.
Yes the past of the Church is littered with major issues but you show me a country or organisation that doesn't have some blots on its copybook? However, the child abuse case has gone on too long with too little done about it and it needs someone in the Church to step up, admit the problem and tackle it head on and forcefully by de-frocking/excumonicating those involved who had knowledge of the abuse and then assisting in a police investigation.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





