May setting out plans to monitor internet use in the UK
May setting out plans to monitor internet use in the UK
Author
Discussion

superkartracer

Original Poster:

8,959 posts

253 months

s1962a

7,696 posts

193 months

Thursday 14th June 2012
quotequote all
If a criminal uses TOR or an annonymous VPN service, how will the government know who it is?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onion_routing

PoleDriver

29,624 posts

225 months

Thursday 14th June 2012
quotequote all
Good idea!
Anything which aids in the capture/prosecution of criminals has got to be good!

Cue swarm of outraged 'human-rights' objectors!


bobbylondonuk

2,206 posts

221 months

Thursday 14th June 2012
quotequote all
What happens when the smart guys go all analog in the digital age? Sending letters...biglaugh

0000

13,966 posts

222 months

Thursday 14th June 2012
quotequote all
It seems to me that this doesn't affect what they can access, just whether they have to ask someone independent if they think it's reasonable.

Why remove that step unless you're after something that's not reasonable?

s1962a

7,696 posts

193 months

Thursday 14th June 2012
quotequote all
PoleDriver said:
Good idea!
Anything which aids in the capture/prosecution of criminals has got to be good!
Only if the idea is actually workable.

Say you were said criminal. You want to communicate with a buddy of yours about some criminal activity you are planning. You both use TOR or an annoymous VPN to access email accounts, that were also created whilst hiding your IP addresses. This email server is located anywhere outside of the UK. You email each other and go about your business.

What will the government store in this instance? The answer, nothing!

1) They can't tell you are from the UK as you have masked where you're actually connecting from
2) email servers are outside of the UK
3) They can't actually see what you're doing from your computer as most likely your connection to TOR/VPN is encrypted

See why it won't work?

On the other hand, if your tech savvy granny is sending an email to her friend mavis about her cat, that will definately get picked up and stored for good - in case it helps stop criminals or terrorists.

Marf

22,907 posts

272 months

Thursday 14th June 2012
quotequote all
PoleDriver said:
Good idea!
Anything which aids in the capture/prosecution of criminals has got to be good!

Cue swarm of outraged 'human-rights' objectors!


Eric Mc

125,928 posts

296 months

Thursday 14th June 2012
quotequote all
PoleDriver said:
Good idea!
Anything which aids in the capture/prosecution of criminals has got to be good!

Cue swarm of outraged 'human-rights' objectors!

And you think it will achieve this noble objective?

0000

13,966 posts

222 months

Thursday 14th June 2012
quotequote all
s1962a said:
Only if the idea is actually workable.

Say you were said criminal. You want to communicate with a buddy of yours about some criminal activity you are planning. You both use TOR or an annoymous VPN to access email accounts, that were also created whilst hiding your IP addresses. This email server is located anywhere outside of the UK. You email each other and go about your business.

What will the government store in this instance? The answer, nothing!

1) They can't tell you are from the UK as you have masked where you're actually connecting from
2) email servers are outside of the UK
3) They can't actually see what you're doing from your computer as most likely your connection to TOR/VPN is encrypted

See why it won't work?

On the other hand, if your tech savvy granny is sending an email to her friend mavis about her cat, that will definately get picked up and stored for good - in case it helps stop criminals or terrorists.
There are options in this scenario available to the intelligence agencies at least, but they're only worth taking if very targeted and with good reason. Not a fishing exercise which this seems to be.

s1962a

7,696 posts

193 months

Thursday 14th June 2012
quotequote all
0000 said:
s1962a said:
Only if the idea is actually workable.

Say you were said criminal. You want to communicate with a buddy of yours about some criminal activity you are planning. You both use TOR or an annoymous VPN to access email accounts, that were also created whilst hiding your IP addresses. This email server is located anywhere outside of the UK. You email each other and go about your business.

What will the government store in this instance? The answer, nothing!

1) They can't tell you are from the UK as you have masked where you're actually connecting from
2) email servers are outside of the UK
3) They can't actually see what you're doing from your computer as most likely your connection to TOR/VPN is encrypted

See why it won't work?

On the other hand, if your tech savvy granny is sending an email to her friend mavis about her cat, that will definately get picked up and stored for good - in case it helps stop criminals or terrorists.
There are options in this scenario available to the intelligence agencies at least, but they're only worth taking if very targeted and with good reason. Not a fishing exercise which this seems to be.
Yep, agree with that. If it's a certain individual their targetting then i'm sure there are ways of working this out. But if you're applying this to the whole population - surely you don't have the manpower to decrypt every single encrypted connection to see what their up to, and record it?

12gauge

1,274 posts

205 months

Thursday 14th June 2012
quotequote all
You have to realize the political class HATE us, they FEAR us. They assume everything we do is to kill them. They are driven by their own fears, as they know what they have done to the country is criminal.

Take this, man brakes down in vicinity of Westminster. Stazi jump the entirely logical idea he could actually have broken down, assume the most nefarious doings, and EXPLODE his car.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2158737/Po...

We have a government, a parliament, driven not by logic, but by contempt and hatred for the people they steal from. Its too late for us, but its why the yanks should NEVER give up their guns.

PoleDriver

29,624 posts

225 months

Thursday 14th June 2012
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
And you think it will achieve this noble objective?
If it catches one criminal it would be a good thing!

In answer to your question... Not a chance!

Jasandjules

72,686 posts

260 months

Thursday 14th June 2012
quotequote all
PoleDriver said:
If it catches one criminal it would be a good thing!
Oh dear.

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Thursday 14th June 2012
quotequote all
Presumably, if you're not doing anything wrong you don't have anything to worry about. As usual...

Einion Yrth

19,575 posts

275 months

Thursday 14th June 2012
quotequote all
AJS- said:
Presumably, if you're not doing anything wrong you don't have anything to worry about. As usual...
Other than my private communications potentially being read by nosey bds with no business doing so, you mean?

heppers75

3,135 posts

248 months

Thursday 14th June 2012
quotequote all
AJS- said:
Presumably, if you're not doing anything wrong you don't have anything to worry about. As usual...
Ahh yes... Nothing to hide, nothing to fear.... That has always proven to be a sound footing to base a society on has it not! rolleyes

IainT

10,040 posts

269 months

Thursday 14th June 2012
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
PoleDriver said:
If it catches one criminal it would be a good thing!
Oh dear.
Indeed... at 2 billion per conviction it's money well spent. Spending that much on more coppers would have little or no effect.

roachcoach

3,975 posts

186 months

Thursday 14th June 2012
quotequote all
The best part are people supporting it whilst posting under pseudonyms on forums jester

Yeah, nothing to fear at all.

mondeoman

11,430 posts

297 months

Thursday 14th June 2012
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
PoleDriver said:
If it catches one criminal it would be a good thing!
Oh dear.
Better that everyone hangs rather than one criminal escape ...

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Thursday 14th June 2012
quotequote all
It's an easy one to get through, isn't it. Anyone opposed is a pedophile or terrorist.