What would be a fair payment for a GP's time.
What would be a fair payment for a GP's time.

Poll: What would be a fair payment for a GP's time.

Total Members Polled: 115

£5: 11%
£10: 14%
£15: 5%
£20: 17%
£25: 16%
£30: 6%
£40: 10%
£50: 10%
£100: 3%
More, my health is important.: 8%
Author
Discussion

Bill

Original Poster:

58,913 posts

286 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
Not sure this will work at all, but here goes...

Assume the system is as it should be at the moment: ten minute appointments, but if you need more time the GP will overrun (it will mean they often run late though). The building, support staff, tests and medication are paid for by the NHS so this fee purely covers 10-60 minutes of face to face time with a well qualified and experienced professional and any further letters or phone calls required.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
You didn't put an option for £0.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
Let's say the average appointment ran to 20 minutes, and the doctor was available to see patients for 7 hours in a day with 20 minutes taken off for people shuffling about. That's 20 appointments at, say, £20 each, giving £400 for a day.

Assuming a 20 day working month, that's £8000 a month, or £96,000 a year.

Seems fair enough to me.

mondeoman

11,430 posts

297 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
Do you pay if you don't turn up?

Bill

Original Poster:

58,913 posts

286 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
Let's say the average appointment ran to 20 minutes, and the doctor was available to see patients for 7 hours in a day with 20 minutes taken off for people shuffling about. That's 20 appointments at, say, £20 each, giving £400 for a day.

Assuming a 20 day working month, that's £8000 a month, or £96,000 a year.

Seems fair enough to me.
You're going about it the wrong way biggrin

I should probably state my bias as SWMBO is a GP, so I know roughly how many people she sees in a non-stop 9-6.30 day including paperwork, telephone triage and a few home visits to those who can't come in.

Which is why I'd rather people take a genuine stab at what they feel a professional's time is worth.

That said a fee would weed out the time wasters and worried well so your 20 minute average could easily become the minimum.

ETA on call is 8-8 btw.

phumy

5,829 posts

268 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
They can charge what ever they want for private work, i went for a medical to work overseas 10 years ago, so had the medical it took 35 minutes, some sit down face to face questioning and some physical, eyes, ears, nose, throat, height and weight, bend over, cough, cough......

He said is your future employer paying or are you paying yourself, i asked why does it make it any diffierence, his reply was yes about 75 pounds worth, it was 75 pound if i paid and 150 pounds if the company was paying.....So i paid 75 pounds and claimed it back from my perspective company.

That was ten years ago, i dread to think what you would have to pay for it now.

Bill

Original Poster:

58,913 posts

286 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
mondeoman said:
Do you pay if you don't turn up?
Dunno tbh. If it was my rules and NHS I'd say no, but you only get one more chance. Non-NHS then yes.

Digga

48,606 posts

314 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
For the pupose of this discussion:

I've got two dogs. They're rescue all-sort breed (25kg and 35kg) and are nutters. We usually see the vet a few times a year taking annual checks plus unscheduled visits into account.

For a pet insurance premium of about £160 per year each I get:
  • All 'general' jabs
  • Free worming tablets
  • Operations, emergency or otherwise but (I guess) excluding cosmetic
  • Appointments to see the vet 99.99% on the same day
  • And at weekends in the case of emergency
GP's only have to worry about humans. Okay, so humans tend to answer back a bit more (although they're not generally know or allowed to bite)and have 'opinions' and require treatment for conditions which, frankly, you'd normally deal with by lethal injection in pets or farm animals, but still...

Bill

Original Poster:

58,913 posts

286 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
That's not the question wink

And for those who've said £5 this is meant to be the GP's wage. Nothing on top, so please chip in with your justification.

ninja-lewis

5,507 posts

221 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
phumy said:
They can charge what ever they want for private work, i went for a medical to work overseas 10 years ago, so had the medical it took 35 minutes, some sit down face to face questioning and some physical, eyes, ears, nose, throat, height and weight, bend over, cough, cough......

He said is your future employer paying or are you paying yourself, i asked why does it make it any diffierence, his reply was yes about 75 pounds worth, it was 75 pound if i paid and 150 pounds if the company was paying.....So i paid 75 pounds and claimed it back from my perspective company.

That was ten years ago, i dread to think what you would have to pay for it now.

yes

Each practice already has a scale of fees for non-NHS work. It used to be coordinated by the BMA but they were sailing very close to wind then with regards to accusations of price fixing.

Charges for a 1 hour private consultation can vary from from £150 to more than £260.

Bill

Original Poster:

58,913 posts

286 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
When do you want them to work? I don't know a surgery that's not open 8-7 most days and Saturday mornings, how many clients do you meet outside those sorts of hours? (Genuine question btw, IME it's rare for people to want to see me outside those hours.)

TimmyArt

1,425 posts

249 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
My wife (GP) see her first patient one of her days at 7.30 having got in at 7am and won't leave until 7+pm that day. She had a busy day yesterday, going in for 7.30 start, 8am first patient and left there at 8.15.

Justayellowbadge

37,057 posts

273 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
Surely it depends.

If I've got a bit of an ouchy finger, maybe a fiver.

If the doc spots something that prevents a massive stroke killing me, it's gotta be worth a score.

Digga

48,606 posts

314 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
I would like to see - and would be likely to subscribe to - a service which allows one to opt out of the NHS as far as GP services are concerned, provided it gave greater flexibility of access hours and faster appointments.

P-Jay

11,421 posts

222 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
Justayellowbadge said:
Surely it depends.

If I've got a bit of an ouchy finger, maybe a fiver.

If the doc spots something that prevents a massive stroke killing me, it's gotta be worth a score.
Sounds more like a tip to me ha ha.

P-Jay

11,421 posts

222 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
I feel strongly the NHS should stick to being free at the point of need.

But... a £20 fee would seriously cut down on the number of people who I see in my GP's waiting room seemingly there for a chat, my GP's office is pretty good at cutting down on that - if you want to see a GP for a non-acute issue, it's a 10 day wait, if you're actually ill you can usually be seen the same day.

I had some private work done a little while back; to see a Consultant Surgeon it will cost you £100 per 20 mins – but they will over-run at no extra charge if it calls for it.

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
Fair price?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_Menger

There isn't really such thing. Prices have to be set by supply and demand to reach a level that represents a net gain for both sides.

Bill

Original Poster:

58,913 posts

286 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
So the appointments are there (to a degree) but you're beaten to it, that's the problem with sharing the system with the hoi polloi. Drinkers like the early slots, the retired like to get appointments over and done with and plenty of people can take time off for appointments.

What, if I can be so rude, did you get paid for those appointments?

The big problem with extending GP hours is that most people who take advantage don't have the need you do, although it is a PITA for those with busy jobs and long commutes.

whoami

13,201 posts

271 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
That's a major source of irritation for me.

They close the whole place (c8 GP's plus umpteen support staff) for 1.5 hours each lunchtime.

A joke.

Digga

48,606 posts

314 months

Thursday 21st June 2012
quotequote all
The crux of the problem we are now discussing is that there are people who have a chronic, ongoing 'need' (whether percieved, hypocondric or real is immaterial) and there are the 'busy' rest of us who rarely go, other than on a very urgent basis. since 'prime' appointements are no priced (because the whole system is 'free') thay all book up swiftly.