Abuse of the courts
Author
Discussion

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,023 posts

279 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
http://www.change.org/petitions/ukhomeoffice-stop-...

It's O'Dwyer.

That hideous brought in by the worst Home Sec I worked under, Blunkett, and given some of them that is some accolade. We have a kid who committed no offence, or at least not one serious enough for the CPS to consider prosecuting him for, but it seems it is alright for us to send him to the USA for upsetting them but using legislation supposedly for use against terrorists.

julian64

14,325 posts

285 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
Not sure what they are after him for.

Can we assume he fraudulently charged people to see copywritten American TV broadcasts?

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,023 posts

279 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
julian64 said:
Not sure what they are after him for.

Can we assume he fraudulently charged people to see copywritten American TV broadcasts?
No, he didn't. He posted adverts on his site. He provided links. He followed normal procedure and when informed of infringement of copyright he removed said articles (and I read on another report, without evidence of ownership). As someone whose copy and images have been used by other sites I have to say that this is far, far from the norm.

julian64

14,325 posts

285 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
julian64 said:
Not sure what they are after him for.

Can we assume he fraudulently charged people to see copywritten American TV broadcasts?
No, he didn't. He posted adverts on his site. He provided links. He followed normal procedure and when informed of infringement of copyright he removed said articles (and I read on another report, without evidence of ownership). As someone whose copy and images have been used by other sites I have to say that this is far, far from the norm.
If thats true what loss are they pursuing him for?

With all due respect I think I'm missing something here. Americans aren't that daft when it comes to money, they aren't going to spend a few million extraditing this chap unless he has a pot of gold to go after, or has done something to harm their interests.

Their are hundreds of millions on the internet linking to what could be called copywritten material on legitimate sites with no fear of anyone taking an interest. It could be seen as free advertising for the legitimate material, so whats their actual beef with him?

singlecoil

35,871 posts

277 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
julian64 said:
If thats true what loss are they pursuing him for?
I was wondering the same thing. The article in the link is obviously written from a single POV.

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,023 posts

279 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
julian64 said:
If thats true what loss are they pursuing him for?

With all due respect I think I'm missing something here. Americans aren't that daft when it comes to money, they aren't going to spend a few million extraditing this chap unless he has a pot of gold to go after, or has done something to harm their interests.

Their are hundreds of millions on the internet linking to what could be called copywritten material on legitimate sites with no fear of anyone taking an interest. It could be seen as free advertising for the legitimate material, so whats their actual beef with him?
The Americans are making a big push on internet copyright/control. They see it as a major cost to Hollywood amongst others. They also see Britian as a risk. Their pursuit of this lad has already made a lot of people concerned about what they are doing. This lad was an easy target and is being chased for something which, in this country at least, is regarded as minor. It is a bit of the old Empire: sending a gunboat to shell a few huts.

Marf

22,907 posts

272 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
Indeed, between this and doing their Team America© bit over Megaupload they're basically waging war against anyone they feel is damaging their economy, no matter how flimsy the pretext.

Hopefully this will fall apart as it seems the case against Megaupload is.

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
I think the problem this guy faces is very straightforward. He was running a business whose prime intention was to make it easier for people to access material which breached copyright.

I guess it's very roughly equivalent to the crime of "handling stolen goods". You didn't nick anything, you haven't kept anything, but you've facilitated the process.

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
As for censorship of the internet, see the links which identify many thousands of government requests for Google censorship.

http://uk.reuters.com/article/2012/06/18/oukin-uk-...

http://googlepublicpolicy.blogspot.co.uk/2012/06/m...

manic47

737 posts

196 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
Ozzie Osmond said:
I think the problem this guy faces is very straightforward. He was running a business whose prime intention was to make it easier for people to access material which breached copyright.

I guess it's very roughly equivalent to the crime of "handling stolen goods". You didn't nick anything, you haven't kept anything, but you've facilitated the process.
That's my view - he made a relatively large amount of money by providing access to copyrighted material.
If I understand it correctly, that (the commercial aspect) moves you into the realms of criminal law rather than civil?

Whatever you feel about the rights of people to download, share films and so on, he had a clear warning when the US shutdown his previous domains, if he carried on regardless he's due whatever is coming to him.

Randy Winkman

22,803 posts

220 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
manic47 said:
Ozzie Osmond said:
I think the problem this guy faces is very straightforward. He was running a business whose prime intention was to make it easier for people to access material which breached copyright.

I guess it's very roughly equivalent to the crime of "handling stolen goods". You didn't nick anything, you haven't kept anything, but you've facilitated the process.
That's my view - he made a relatively large amount of money by providing access to copyrighted material.
If I understand it correctly, that (the commercial aspect) moves you into the realms of criminal law rather than civil?

Whatever you feel about the rights of people to download, share films and so on, he had a clear warning when the US shutdown his previous domains, if he carried on regardless he's due whatever is coming to him.
If that's the case, wasn't his "prime intention" to make money for himself?

Murph7355

42,067 posts

287 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
manic47 said:
That's my view - he made a relatively large amount of money by providing access to copyrighted material.
If I understand it correctly, that (the commercial aspect) moves you into the realms of criminal law rather than civil?

Whatever you feel about the rights of people to download, share films and so on, he had a clear warning when the US shutdown his previous domains, if he carried on regardless he's due whatever is coming to him.
What about search engines etc?

Presumably they are all about making it easier for people to find "stuff". If that is all this guy has done, and hasn't suggested it is right to do said things or even take part himself, how is the distinction being made?

julian64

14,325 posts

285 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
I think the area of gaining copywritten material and using/viewing it is a very grey one, and I would hate to see everything on the internet copywritten as it would effectively destroy the internet.

However I would draw the line at making a profit on someone elses work. If thats what happened here I have no sympathy.

rohrl

8,984 posts

176 months

Tuesday 26th June 2012
quotequote all
When are Larry and Sergey up in court then? Surely Google links to more copywritten content than anyone else and has advertising all over it.

Jasandjules

72,686 posts

260 months

Tuesday 26th June 2012
quotequote all
My concern is he is a UK Citizen. The crime, if any, was not committed on US soil. If there is to be any prosecution, it should be by the UK. This is a really worrying matter for all UK citizens IMHO.

philthy

4,697 posts

271 months

Wednesday 27th June 2012
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
My concern is he is a UK Citizen. The crime, if any, was not committed on US soil. If there is to be any prosecution, it should be by the UK. This is a really worrying matter for all UK citizens IMHO.
Quite.
The actions of our very large bullying cousin, are disturbing.

Sonic

4,008 posts

238 months

Wednesday 27th June 2012
quotequote all
philthy said:
Jasandjules said:
My concern is he is a UK Citizen. The crime, if any, was not committed on US soil. If there is to be any prosecution, it should be by the UK. This is a really worrying matter for all UK citizens IMHO.
Quite.
The actions of our very large bullying cousin, are disturbing.
Precisely - we have our own laws in this country.

Are the US going to be extraditing shop owners who sell alcohol to 19 year olds as-well? Despite it being perfectly legal in this country, but not in theirs.

0000

13,966 posts

222 months

Wednesday 27th June 2012
quotequote all
Murph7355 said:
What about search engines etc?

Presumably they are all about making it easier for people to find "stuff". If that is all this guy has done, and hasn't suggested it is right to do said things or even take part himself, how is the distinction being made?
If you're a large American corporation, it's all good. If you're not, they're coming to get you?