Treasury Select Committee v Bob Diamond
Discussion
Pretty poor show from the MPs - especially from Conservative Expenses fiddler David Ruffley.
Why Bob hasn't said
"..the way MPs behaved when nobody was watching was poor too. The difference is we sacked our bad apples..."
The committee is a disgraceful waste of public money. Half of them don't seem to know that BD wasn't even CEO until Jan 2011, yet a number of them suggested the LIBOR fixing 'happened on your watch'.
Doh.
Why Bob hasn't said
"..the way MPs behaved when nobody was watching was poor too. The difference is we sacked our bad apples..."
The committee is a disgraceful waste of public money. Half of them don't seem to know that BD wasn't even CEO until Jan 2011, yet a number of them suggested the LIBOR fixing 'happened on your watch'.
Doh.
Mermaid said:
Naive to believe he did not know what was going on - complicit or negligent.
How?If setters were even bothering to succumb to traders' whinings about the rate, the communications seem to suggest traders and setters were talking about differences in LIBOR estimates in the order of +- 0.01%.
So, how was Bob supposed to look at that weeks LIBOR figures and go, "...hmmm I smell a rat boys. This LIBOR is 3.47 and we submitted 3.49...Quick, call the FSA.."
johnfm said:
How?
If setters were even bothering to succumb to traders' whinings about the rate, the communications seem to suggest traders and setters were talking about differences in LIBOR estimates in the order of +- 0.01%.
So, how was Bob supposed to look at that weeks LIBOR figures and go, "...hmmm I smell a rat boys. This LIBOR is 3.47 and we submitted 3.49...Quick, call the FSA.."
He mentions he knew about rates being high- you have to know the exact rates in his business, that's the business. And his version that he only knew about rigging recently did not seat well with the MP's.If setters were even bothering to succumb to traders' whinings about the rate, the communications seem to suggest traders and setters were talking about differences in LIBOR estimates in the order of +- 0.01%.
So, how was Bob supposed to look at that weeks LIBOR figures and go, "...hmmm I smell a rat boys. This LIBOR is 3.47 and we submitted 3.49...Quick, call the FSA.."
Edited by Mermaid on Wednesday 4th July 17:28
I agree. Bob kept his cool, but his assertion that he did not know about the LIBOR fiddling until this month is not credible.
The reality I suspect, is that he knew Barclays were doing it, all the other banks were doing it, and the Bank of England knew about it.
What I don't understand is why Bob doesn't just say that. He's hinted at it, but then he blows his credibility by categorically stating he wasn't aware of the LIBOR fixing.
The reality I suspect, is that he knew Barclays were doing it, all the other banks were doing it, and the Bank of England knew about it.
What I don't understand is why Bob doesn't just say that. He's hinted at it, but then he blows his credibility by categorically stating he wasn't aware of the LIBOR fixing.
whoami said:
Alex said:
I agree. Bob kept his cool, but his assertion that he did not know about the LIBOR fiddling until this month is not credible.

He found out in the last three days?

That's a different affair to the individual traders doing naughty things, not sure how he would know that even from mbwa since the traders involved would hardly be expected to undergo spontaneous confession. As such, the 3 day awareness may relate to this element of libor fixing but to confirm or otherwise exactly what he said it would help to see a transcript of his evidence.
Edited by turbobloke on Wednesday 4th July 18:09
Alex said:
..
The reality I suspect, is that he knew Barclays were doing it, all the other banks were doing it, and the Bank of England knew about it.
What I don't understand is why Bob doesn't just say that. He's hinted at it, but then he blows his credibility by categorically stating he wasn't aware of the LIBOR fixing.
^ ThisThe reality I suspect, is that he knew Barclays were doing it, all the other banks were doing it, and the Bank of England knew about it.
What I don't understand is why Bob doesn't just say that. He's hinted at it, but then he blows his credibility by categorically stating he wasn't aware of the LIBOR fixing.
turbobloke said:
Apparently he knew, or strongly suspected, that it was happening in other banks post-Tucker, but never thought to take a peek inside his own bank to see what was going on...perhaps that's a bit wide of the mark. The shred of credibility in there from the corporate side is that he may have thought that Whitehall pressure via BoE to get Barclays 'back in the pack' indicated that Barclays was being honest when others were not. So the position is that he would know all about the corporate side and believed that prior to Tucker they were being honest, but that afterwards they were merely doing Whitehall's bidding.
That's a different affair to the individual traders doing naughty things, not sure how he would know that even from mbwa since the traders involved would hardly be expected to undergo spontaneous confession. As such, the 3 day awareness may relate to this element of libor fixing but to confirm or otherwise exactly what he said it would help to see a transcript of his evidence.
It was fairly clear from having watched the whole thing that he understood the question (regarding when he was made aware).That's a different affair to the individual traders doing naughty things, not sure how he would know that even from mbwa since the traders involved would hardly be expected to undergo spontaneous confession. As such, the 3 day awareness may relate to this element of libor fixing but to confirm or otherwise exactly what he said it would help to see a transcript of his evidence.
Edited by turbobloke on Wednesday 4th July 18:09
With understandable incredulity, the questioner took the trouble of clarifying Diamond's answer with him.
whoami said:
It was fairly clear from having watched the whole thing that he understood the question (regarding when he was made aware).
With understandable incredulity, the questioner took the trouble of clarifying Diamond's answer with him.
I don't recall that clarification being sufficiently detailed as to distinguish between 'corporate libor policy post-Tucker' and trader shenanigans which are separate elements.With understandable incredulity, the questioner took the trouble of clarifying Diamond's answer with him.
What I do recall is the clarification about not being aware of libor issues until recently...but aware of which of the two elements? He wasn't cross examined sufficiently forensically in my view to establish this but again a transcript would help.
turbobloke said:
whoami said:
It was fairly clear from having watched the whole thing that he understood the question (regarding when he was made aware).
With understandable incredulity, the questioner took the trouble of clarifying Diamond's answer with him.
He wasn't cross examined sufficiently forensically .With understandable incredulity, the questioner took the trouble of clarifying Diamond's answer with him.
Most of them weren't bright enough to get to the bottom of the issues.
martin84 said:
0a said:
And Ed Balls
Steady on. If you believe Ed Balls took any part in financial fraud or any sort of conspiracy you'd be crediting him with being able to do something.Meanwhile Labour's own Mann, he of the committee, thinks there won't be much of an issue with Balls and Clown as per his contribution on Sky just now. Well he would say that, but I'll keep an open mind.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



