George Osborne, Egalitarian - We're All In This Together
George Osborne, Egalitarian - We're All In This Together
Author
Discussion

0a

Original Poster:

24,160 posts

225 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
Quite an interesting piece on The Independent's blog site. It looks at IFS data that shows that the rich have borne the brunt of the financial crisis and not the poor as conventional wisdom suggests.

Worth remembering when you hear the "rich get richer" rhetoric repeated time and time again.

John Rentoul In The Indi said:
Britain has become a more equal society, according to the Institute for Fiscal Studies, in important research published three weeks ago, on 15 June, which went almost entirely unreported.

It showed that post-tax incomes fell sharply in the first year of the coalition Government (April 2010 to April 2011). That part was widely reported (Daily Mail: “Biggest drop in our incomes in 50 years”). But higher incomes fell more than lower incomes, resulting in a markedly more equal distribution. Of national print newspapers, only The Daily Telegraph reported this finding, although it did not carry the headline, “George Osborne, egalitarian.”

I cannot understand why the Conservatives and Liberal Democrats have not made more of this. The figures, an IFS re-crunch of official data, are in fact a tribute to the success of Labour Government policy, reflecting tax and benefit changes made by Alistair Darling. But they suggest that the coalition started with a more favourable trend that runs counter to popular assumptions.

The findings apply across the income distribution, and include the richest one per cent, although that might partly reflect avoidance of the new 50p top rate of income tax.

But the study is a classic example of the “prism media” theory. It runs so counter to the prevailing assumptions – the rich get richer, the poor bear the brunt of the financial crisis – that it has been neither reported nor discussed. The IFS spends quite a lot of time saying “we don’t know” what is happening since April 2011, but the evidence suggests that until then the rich bore the brunt and that poverty was declining.* But that simply cannot be seen through the prism of the media.

Hence there is much more coverage of Danny Dorling’s out-of-date and anti-Labour interpretation, which says that income is now more unequal than at any time since 1940 (the IFS says recent highs, before the most recent fall, were the highest since 1961). Dorling glosses over the Great Thatcher Decade of Division, about which some people have written whole books, which is when inequality markedly increased in Britain. Dorling says, “Since 1979 these inequalities have risen dramatically and continue to rise.” No, they rose dramatically and then stayed more or less the same, rising slightly and unevenly but nothing like they did in the Thatcher period.

And Dorling’s assertion that, “as each year passes … the richest one per cent get richer still” is now flatly contradicted by the IFS data.

  • Poverty in modern rich countries has to be measured on a relative scale. Once people have enough to eat, what matters is how well-off you are in relation to others, or the extent to which the poor can afford things that others take for granted.

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
It's not hard to keep most of what you had when you had fk all to lose in the first place.

0a

Original Poster:

24,160 posts

225 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
The idea is that repeatedly saying "the rich get richer" isn't true and that concentrating on the 50p rate when allowances are changing and there is a recession on is misleading.

speedy_thrills

7,979 posts

274 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
There is probably an optimum balance to be achieved but, as far as I know, there has been no comprehensive study on the optimum level of disparity for economic growth.

In my view a lot of arguments about sub-aspects of social equality (welfare, education, health etc.) miss this bigger picture that social services are a tool for economic optimisation. If your a classic capitalist you'll say this is a disingenuous socialist argument for social welfare; if you are a classic socialist you'd probably accuse me of a lack of empathy. Can a government ever translate this into practical policy in a dispassionate way however when our political system is built on parties taking opposing sides even if their view on a sub-aspect of the argument is irrational? Tune in later to find out.

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
Earnings between £100k - £116k now have an effective tax rate of 62%.

turbobloke

117,560 posts

291 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
The wealth gap is a convenient tool for relative poverty disciples to preach a never ending message about redistribution of wealth. If the lowest paid worker has enough money after tax to pay for a comfortable lifestyle then that's about as good as it gets. There needs to be incentive to do better by upskilling, effort, and measured risk taking or the source of work for those lowest paid folk via enterpreneurs and job creation is going to dry up even faster than technology can remove jobs on its own.

If meritocracy has an always decreasing role here via Toynbee-esque egalitarian delusion then in an international context we will settle down to a state of uniform mediocrity to the detriment of everyone. That route may well lead to failure and penury unless and until a left-ish government finds that elusive money tree. The last Labour gov't thought it had a Bonsai version at least via taxes flowing from the City but that infamous light touch tripartite regulatory system and abolition of boom and bust didn't last very long.

This is with regard to income, wealth being a different matter but with similar connotations if the State is going to start appropriating wealth as Polly and the over-promoted Sir Vincent of Cable seem to wish for with their populist and envyist mansion tax malarkies.

Mr GrimNasty

8,172 posts

201 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
Statistics can easily be manipulated to show whatever you want.

I also find it hard to believe that anything that comes out of the IFS is neutral these days. If you look at the career of Paul Johnson and know that he was an active member of in the Labour party whilst still at school.

I'm sure it was pure coincidence that a series of negative reports emerged in quick succession after the last Labour government was ousted, reports that could easily have been released before the election.

Jasandjules

72,686 posts

260 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
However, when the poor lose money they can't eat. The rich lose out they can't afford a nanny as well as the gardener.................. It's hardly comparing like with like..

turbobloke

117,560 posts

291 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
However, when the poor lose money they can't eat. The rich lose out they can't afford a nanny as well as the gardener.................. It's hardly comparing like with like..
That's true enough - the rich are prepared to cut out back on Bensons and Stella so they can keep the nanny wink

Derek Smith

50,024 posts

279 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
Mr GrimNasty said:
Statistics can easily be manipulated to show whatever you want.

I also find it hard to believe that anything that comes out of the IFS is neutral these days. If you look at the career of Paul Johnson and know that he was an active member of in the Labour party whilst still at school.

I'm sure it was pure coincidence that a series of negative reports emerged in quick succession after the last Labour government was ousted, reports that could easily have been released before the election.
The report is via the SSRC as was and now ESRC, a quango that is not under threat as it is not one designed for consumer protection. However, one wonders if such a status might be downgraded if they became critical of the government.

The report responds to careful reading.

"Income inequality in the UK fell sharply in 2010–11 . . . the largest one-year fall since at least 1962, returning the Gini coefficient to below its level in 1997–98. Although this reverses the increase in this measure of income inequality that occurred under the previous Labour government, it still leaves it much higher than before the substantial increases that occurred during the 1980s."

And, on the drop in top earnings:

"The largest falls in income took place at the very top of the income distribution, with income at the 99th percentile falling by 15% in 2010–11. This is likely to be partly due to the temporary effects of the introduction in April 2010 of the 50% marginal income tax rate on incomes exceeding £150,000 per annum. HMRC estimates that the 50% tax rate resulted in substantial income ‘forestalling’ – the bringing forward of income from 2010–11 to 2009–10 in an effort to avoid the higher marginal rate of tax in 2010–11. This forestalling would have raised top incomes in 2009–10 and depressed top incomes in 2010–11. We would also expect the reform to have had some permanent effects on top incomes, via the direct impact of the tax rise lowering net incomes and the indirect impacts via (for example) reduced labour supply. It is uncertain exactly how much of the overall response reflects permanent behavioural change and how much is temporary."

In essence, tax avoidance corrupting the figures.

The report is not a simple case of the rich getting poorer at a higher rate than the poor are.

There is an interesting precis of measuring poverty.

So not as one sided as the report above would suggest.

http://www.ifs.org.uk/comms/comm124.pdf

turbobloke

117,560 posts

291 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
In essence, tax avoidance corrupting the figures.
Surely not, tax avoidance involves lawfully paying no more tax than required, which almost everybody does, so the figures were hardly corrupted. That type of language reveals the political bias you appeared to be arguing against.

Derek Smith

50,024 posts

279 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
turbobloke said:
Derek Smith said:
In essence, tax avoidance corrupting the figures.
Surely not, tax avoidance involves lawfully paying no more tax than required, which almost everybody does, so the figures were hardly corrupted. That type of language reveals the political bias you appeared to be arguing against.
The figures quoted purport to be, in the article quoted, a response to year on year statistics. However, the conclusion cannot be justified, as the report itself admits, because a number of the rich moved income from one year to another in order to avoid tax. So far, my statement was literal.

Corrupting has been interpreted by you to mean something political. I could quote your final sentence back at you.

Corrupting can mean distorting and the figures are, as the report suggests, distorted by this tax avoiding movement of income. In other words we cannot trust the conclusion because it is corrupted by undependable, perhaps one-off, data.

Don't read into postings more than is there. Read the report and it will all become clear to you.

The figures are corrupted.

Mr GrimNasty

8,172 posts

201 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
The report is via the SSRC as was and now ESRC, a quango that is not under threat as it is not one designed for consumer protection. However, one wonders if such a status might be downgraded if they became critical of the government.
Well obviously there can be bias with the researchers, and/or in the of commissioning the research.

turbobloke

117,560 posts

291 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
turbobloke said:
Derek Smith said:
In essence, tax avoidance corrupting the figures.
Surely not, tax avoidance involves lawfully paying no more tax than required, which almost everybody does, so the figures were hardly corrupted. That type of language reveals the political bias you appeared to be arguing against.
The figures quoted purport to be, in the article quoted, a response to year on year statistics. However, the conclusion cannot be justified, as the report itself admits, because a number of the rich moved income from one year to another in order to avoid tax. So far, my statement was literal.

Corrupting has been interpreted by you to mean something political. I could quote your final sentence back at you.
Not at all. HNWIs move income and assets in various ways all the time, the claimn is spurious. More movement or less is probably down to how greedy the government is, not how greedy bankers are.

dereksmith said:
Don't read into postings more than is there. Read the report and it will all become clear to you.

The figures are corrupted.
I didn't and they're not.

Mr Snap

2,364 posts

188 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
turbobloke said:
Derek Smith said:
In essence, tax avoidance corrupting the figures.
Surely not, tax avoidance involves lawfully paying no more tax than required, which almost everybody does, so the figures were hardly corrupted. That type of language reveals the political bias you appeared to be arguing against.
Er, not quite 'everyone'. Try to avoid paying tax when you're on PAYE...



powerstroke

10,283 posts

191 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
Mr Snap said:
turbobloke said:
Derek Smith said:
In essence, tax avoidance corrupting the figures.
Surely not, tax avoidance involves lawfully paying no more tax than required, which almost everybody does, so the figures were hardly corrupted. That type of language reveals the political bias you appeared to be arguing against.
Er, not quite 'everyone'. Try to avoid paying tax when you're on PAYE...
Easy !!! ebaying boot sales ,doing forigners/part time jobs cash in hand,

turbobloke

117,560 posts

291 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
powerstroke said:
Mr Snap said:
turbobloke said:
Derek Smith said:
In essence, tax avoidance corrupting the figures.
Surely not, tax avoidance involves lawfully paying no more tax than required, which almost everybody does, so the figures were hardly corrupted. That type of language reveals the political bias you appeared to be arguing against.
Er, not quite 'everyone'. Try to avoid paying tax when you're on PAYE...
Easy !!! ebaying boot sales ,doing forigners/part time jobs cash in hand,
Which is something the report also missed mentioning, given the lower incomes represented will often be topped up by cash in hand. There's mention of how high incomes supposedly reacted but where is there a detailed coverage of how the black shadow economy shifted as times got tough?

The idea that people can have only one source of income, PAYE or not PAYE, is way off the mark.

There appears to be a ridiculous notion held by some that an alternative scenario - which might have been true but isn't - is more real than reality.

There are usually flaws in the methodology of reports, bias is a flaw in the reporters and both are present with the case in point.

Mojocvh

16,837 posts

293 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
turbobloke said:
I didn't and they're not.
That's you told Derek bigmouthrofl

turbobloke

117,560 posts

291 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
Mojocvh said:
turbobloke said:
I didn't and they're not.
That's you told Derek bigmouthrofl
yes

Wishing for an alternative reality to report on never made sense even in a report.

dandarez

14,042 posts

314 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
powerstroke said:
Mr Snap said:
turbobloke said:
Derek Smith said:
In essence, tax avoidance corrupting the figures.
Surely not, tax avoidance involves lawfully paying no more tax than required, which almost everybody does, so the figures were hardly corrupted. That type of language reveals the political bias you appeared to be arguing against.
Er, not quite 'everyone'. Try to avoid paying tax when you're on PAYE...
Easy !!! ebaying boot sales ,doing forigners/part time jobs cash in hand,
That's 'evading' not avoiding!