Get rid of the Road Fund License
Get rid of the Road Fund License
Author
Discussion

Mudgey

Original Poster:

683 posts

205 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
I have been thinking to myself that wouldn't it be better to simply increase fuel costs and just get rid of the road fund license, after a quick google I came across this which explains it better than I can:

http://www.govyou.co.uk/abolish-road-tax-discs/

Apart from the hundreds of people who would have to find another job is there any other reasons why this would be a bad idea? If they could raise the same amount of money from increasing fuel prices then they would be better off by whatever it costs to run the RFL section of the DVLA?

elster

17,517 posts

241 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
It is a way to track what cars are on the road and brings in a good revenue that is spread across everyone.

Increasing fuel prices puts the cost of everything up; food, equipment, everything.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
Mudgey said:
I have been thinking to myself that wouldn't it be better to simply increase fuel costs and just get rid of the road fund license, after a quick google I came across this which explains it better than I can:

http://www.govyou.co.uk/abolish-road-tax-discs/

Apart from the hundreds of people who would have to find another job is there any other reasons why this would be a bad idea? If they could raise the same amount of money from increasing fuel prices then they would be better off by whatever it costs to run the RFL section of the DVLA?
I agree. Putting the tax on to fuel hurts the people who drive more, and hurts the people with less efficient cars more. That's exactly the current aim of emissions based RFL and the road pricing plans.

If it was designed to be revenue neutral for commercial goods hauliers it wouldn't cost any more to deliver goods around the UK, and it would be a benefit to UK companies, because they would finally be on a level playing field with their continental counterparts as regards UK taxation.


RobDickinson

31,343 posts

285 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
elster said:
It is a way to track what cars are on the road
This. Its a control and information exercise now. even if it only paid for its own administration it would still exist.

b2hbm

1,301 posts

253 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
Of course it would, for exactly the reasons stated. 20yrs ago I agree it was the only real way to keep account of how many cars were legally insured, MoT'd and on the road. (or rather how many honest drivers were complying and paying their dues)

But now we have insurance databases the police could easily search, and if the car is 3yrs old we have a national MoT database as well. These days the tax disc serves no real purpose other than generating fines for not getting one on time or forgetting to SORN a vehicle. Paper shuffling bureaucracy, nothing more.

DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
Mudgey said:
I have been thinking to myself that wouldn't it be better to simply increase fuel costs and just get rid of the road fund license, after a quick google I came across this which explains it better than I can:

http://www.govyou.co.uk/abolish-road-tax-discs/

Apart from the hundreds of people who would have to find another job is there any other reasons why this would be a bad idea? If they could raise the same amount of money from increasing fuel prices then they would be better off by whatever it costs to run the RFL section of the DVLA?
It is the only sensible thing to do but won't happen because of the loss of all the unnecessary jobs, another plus in my opinion.

Totally unnecessary as a tracking system, many other ways to do that.

PeanutHead

7,839 posts

201 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
What about all those that buy fuel for gardening equipment and other machine plant that don't use the roads.
Would this higher cost be added to all fuel and what about electric motors and LPG they help damage the roads and should pay equally to maintain them.
I get the bus.

SLacKer

2,622 posts

238 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
Would stop tax dodgers.

It would be fantastic if they ditched it but they won't. Why tax once when you can tax twice.

Oldred_V8S

3,765 posts

269 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
RobDickinson said:
elster said:
It is a way to track what cars are on the road
This. Its a control and information exercise now. even if it only paid for its own administration it would still exist.
Pre 1973 vehicles are still tracked via RFL/Sorn, but the licence is zero cost.

98elise

32,882 posts

192 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
It you look at it from a pure logic perspective, the tax disc makes no sense. It used to be a means of checking that you had mot, tax, registration docs, but thats all electronic these days. Its a inefficient to administer and a pain to have to pay out a lump sum every 6 months.

Its sole purpose now is tax collection, so it makes sense for it to be added to petrol.

The reason this will never happen is that looks better to raise two sources of tax (RFL and Petrol)by a bit, rather than one by more (ie if petrol went up a lot wthe masses would be taking to the streets).

king arthur

7,903 posts

292 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
The reason it won't happen is pure economics - the higher the cost of fuel, the more ways we find to avoid buying it. You can't legally avoid taxing your car though so the revenue from RFL is fixed to a large degree.

Caulkhead

4,938 posts

188 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
Mudgey said:
I have been thinking to myself that wouldn't it be better to simply increase fuel costs and just get rid of the road fund license, after a quick google I came across this which explains it better than I can:

http://www.govyou.co.uk/abolish-road-tax-discs/

Apart from the hundreds of people who would have to find another job is there any other reasons why this would be a bad idea? If they could raise the same amount of money from increasing fuel prices then they would be better off by whatever it costs to run the RFL section of the DVLA?
People who want to abolish Road Fund Licence or Road Tax should remember neither have existed for some time - it's Vehicle Excise Duty now.

Adrian W

15,623 posts

259 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
Why do we still need the disc? and why when we tax a car online can't it run from that second to a second before the following year? it's a con and a DVLA job creation scheeme

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
PeanutHead said:
What about all those that buy fuel for gardening equipment and other machine plant that don't use the roads.
Would this higher cost be added to all fuel and what about electric motors and LPG they help damage the roads and should pay equally to maintain them.
I get the bus.
I don't normally like being pedantic, but that disc we commonly call "car tax" or "road tax" or "road fund license" is actually now called "vehicle excise duty" and the money doens't go into a pot to pay for the roads, it goes into general taxation.

Also electric cars have to have a VED disc, but it's free. LPG from petrol stations has vat and duty on it, and I assume this charge would be added.

You're right, though, that fuel for off-road use couldn't be excluded. (Like your machinery example, or trackdays etc.)

But in general I think it's a reasonable idea, and certainly worth looking at what the consequences would be. The way to price it, IMO, would be to add up the entire VED take, then subtract the cost of administering the system as it is, then add the cost of administering the new system (hopefully less) and that gives us the total tax take we'd need to get the same net income to public coffers. Then is the tricky bit; you could divide it by the total number of litres of fuel sold in total - but LPG you get less miles per litre, and diesel you get more; so you should probably pro-rate it. But basically spread the cost evenly. This will naturally result in some people paying more than they used to, and others paying less - but it would be proportional to miles driven and the economy of the car, AND the manner in which it's driven. So seems "fair" according to my personal definition of "fair" (on the assumption that this level of tax is fair, but that's a whole other question.)

PeanutHead

7,839 posts

201 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
Thanks mrmr96, as i'm not in the in the know it was just a few pointers i thought about but you cleared them up.
Could red diesel be used for these plant machines and lawnmowers and such that could be purchased and taxed differently?

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
PeanutHead said:
Thanks mrmr96, as i'm not in the in the know it was just a few pointers i thought about but you cleared them up.
Could red diesel be used for these plant machines and lawnmowers and such that could be purchased and taxed differently?
That sounds reasonable to me. Not sure about any problems in making it available to general public though, but I suppose those wanting to use it illegally are already doing so, so making it more available may not have too great an effect on losing more revenue.

993AL

1,939 posts

249 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
It would be good if it happened but it never will. Why?

Simple maths, the government knows how much revenue the current system generates and they know when they will receive it.

If you own more than one car the Gov’t won’t give up the revenue on the car that is not consuming fuel. i.e at the moment they’re getting full VED for a car that is doing very little annual mileage.

If you assume 12k/annum miles as the norm for the Gov’t to base their revenue calcs..and let’s say 35-40mpg for the same calcs. To raise the average £202 VED/annum it would add 13p-15p to a litre of fuel.

There would need to be a system to differentiate between fuelling cars and fuelling HGV’s as their VED can be up to £1850/annum unless there was an “across the board” cost for everybody… it’s unlikely that would happen.

Lastly, why would the Gov’t introduce such a scheme? Because it’s fair? At the moment they can get money from the motorist from both ends, VED and at the petrol pumps. They could add the 13p-15p anyway and we’d just moan but still pay it. They have the best of both worlds as it is, they’re not going to give up an easy revenue stream


PeanutHead

7,839 posts

201 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
Maybe they could have a license to purchase it, like the SIA license where they make the individual pay £220 every 3 years so they can keep their jobs.
That would also create an extra revenue.

Digga

48,611 posts

314 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
I've just come back from another Euro road trip. Each time I arrive back on our side of the channel I am appalled by the road conditions - congestion and potholes - and become increasingly convinced that we need to adopt a nationwide toll structure, especially with the increasing numbers of foreign trucks using the roads for free. Big trucks with touring tanks will by very little, if any fuel over this side of the channel.

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Monday 9th July 2012
quotequote all
Digga said:
I've just come back from another Euro road trip. Each time I arrive back on our side of the channel I am appalled by the road conditions - congestion and potholes - and become increasingly convinced that we need to adopt a nationwide toll structure, especially with the increasing numbers of foreign trucks using the roads for free. Big trucks with touring tanks will by very little, if any fuel over this side of the channel.
I don't want road pricing, I'd rather the money we have is re-prioritised.