JP Morgan to claw back bonuses
Author
Discussion

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
[redacted]

Jasandjules

72,687 posts

260 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Well in my bank the bonuses were always noted as "discretionary".......


98elise

32,886 posts

192 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Well in my bank the bonuses were always noted as "discretionary".......
Most are, thats what makes them bonuses over pay. I don't work in the banking world, but my last company paid everyone bonuses based on your individual performance, and the companies performance. The base pay was slightly lower than average, but bonuses put you potential earnings at 20% above market rates.

It was a good way of rewarding those who performed well and sharing the benefits of a good year. On the other hand it kept costs down in a bad year.

johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Discretionary is different to 'clawback'.

I suppose it all boils down to contracts really.

SpeedMattersNot

4,506 posts

227 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
It's funny, in my experience bonuses are rarely ever paid for doing a "good job".

In the motor trade, if you're a mechanic at most main dealerships you are made aware of how important customer satisfaction is, but our only cash incentive is every on how many hours we can sell of labour, or how much we can up-sell.

Both involve ripping the customers off and I'm glad yesterday was my last day in the trade!

The front desk was measured personally on customer satisfaction, but again, their bonuses were orientated around up-sell of tyres and red/amber work. And of course, bonus could only be paid out if the whole site made money that month...

I can't imagine bankers bonuses are any less, transparent than the motor trade.

London424

12,946 posts

206 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
It's not a "good PR move". It's just what many of the companies have moved towards in the sector.

It won't stop or harm recruitment as everyone is aware of the policy going in. Without looking into the details I would even go as far as guessing that they aren't even clawing anything back. They are probably not going to pay out the "deferred" element that has been built into some bonus schemes.

A point that quite a few people seem to confuse is the use of "bonus". Some people seem to think that this is used to reward people for "going the extra mile" or "above and beyond expectations" or some other soft and cuddly expression. In most professional service type organisations a bonus is actually just used to mitigate costs and is seen as part of your guaranteed pay for the year.

For example, a job is worth 50k per year. Now, do I just pay them 50k or do I pay them 40k and give a "bonus" of 10k at the end of the year assuming the person is doing what they should be doing and the company has made money as well.

Hopefully you can see the benefit of minimising fixed costs.

Cheib

25,483 posts

206 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Bonuese are awarded and normally paid out over the following three years or so. All that will be happening is that anything not already actually paid will not be.

It's standrad in the terms of a contract that if you are fired with due cause they can cancel the bonus awards.

The interesting thing here is that some iof these employees may feel they are being made scapegoats as senior management will definitely have been aware of these positions and signed off. I am sure the lawyers will have a field day.

Benjurs

446 posts

209 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Hi Guys

When I worked in the city my bonus was made up of a salary (about 80% of my previous salary or market rate) and a bonus pool of which I was entitled to an amount based on a points system. For example I had 5 points which were worth £x per point based on the amount of money in the bonus pool or pot.

The advantage for the company was, obviously, lower salaries and E'r NIC (during the year) and then only paying the 100% (or less/more) of market rate if the company made money. Also if you left within the year then they would not pay out a bonus on a pro rata calculation.

The 'points' allocated were then used as an incentive system or penalty system dependent on the employees annual appraisal.

I left the company due to the fact that these 'points' were abused by the Directors as they were dangled in front of you all year or used to 'threaten' people into conforming to their, in my eyes, unreasonable demands.

I can't see how they could 'claw back' these cash bonuses after being paid, although I guess they could abuse the system by reducing your 'points' in the following year.

Crappy system and so open to abuse that they were the major reason stated on the leavers forms from employees who left.

KR

Ben

sidicks

25,218 posts

252 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
Benjurs said:
Hi Guys

When I worked in the city my bonus was made up of a salary (about 80% of my previous salary or market rate) and a bonus pool of which I was entitled to an amount based on a points system. For example I had 5 points which were worth £x per point based on the amount of money in the bonus pool or pot.

The advantage for the company was, obviously, lower salaries and E'r NIC (during the year) and then only paying the 100% (or less/more) of market rate if the company made money. Also if you left within the year then they would not pay out a bonus on a pro rata calculation.

The 'points' allocated were then used as an incentive system or penalty system dependent on the employees annual appraisal.

I left the company due to the fact that these 'points' were abused by the Directors as they were dangled in front of you all year or used to 'threaten' people into conforming to their, in my eyes, unreasonable demands.

I can't see how they could 'claw back' these cash bonuses after being paid, although I guess they could abuse the system by reducing your 'points' in the following year.

Crappy system and so open to abuse that they were the major reason stated on the leavers forms from employees who left.

KR

Ben
That doesn't sound like the way it typically works, at least at the more senior levels, from my experience.

Sidicks

Cheib

25,483 posts

206 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Deferred bonus payments are nearly always in the form of shares.

London424

12,946 posts

206 months

Friday 13th July 2012
quotequote all
And they won't ever be clawing back actual money from anyone. As said by others it will be from either the deferred element of the bonus or the LTI plans in place.