Getting on the ladder, then chopping off the rungs
Discussion
Our road is a typical suburban road in South East England. There's 120 1930's houses, mostly semi-detached, with a few terraced.
When we moved here 7 years ago, there were a handful which had extensions or loft conversions. Since then, we've had a loft conversion and single-storey extension, as have our adjoining neighbours. Our non-adjoining neighbours have added an extension (they already had a loft conversion), and [i]their adjoining neighbours have done both. In total, probably a third of the houses now have loft conversions, and there are more being started pretty much on a weekly basis.
Traditionally, people would've bought a small house or flat to start with (as we did), then moved to somewhere like this as step two (again, as we did), then moved to somewhere larger once they'd got a bit more cash and wanted a bit more space.
This last step just doesn't seem to be happening any more.
Houses in our area typically go for around £300k un-extended, and around £360k extended, which is pretty much the cost of getting the work done. Between stamp duty at 3%, estate agents' fees at around 1.5%, solicitors' fees, surveys, searches, removals, mortgage valuation fees and all the other stuff involved, we'd be looking at probably a third of the cost of the extension before we'd paid so much as a penny towards the cost of actually buying a larger house, so what's the point?
At the same time, however, there's only so long that people can keep doing this before the 3-bed house as a natural second step on the ladder has been completely replaced (around here at least) by 5 bedroom properties occupied by people who might like to move to a nicer house, but don't actually have to move for more space as their families grow. As such, even if younger people manage to scrape together the insane amounts of capital required to get on the housing ladder these days, they're faced with a shortage of properties to buy, as our level has been sat here moving our own properties up the ladder and chopping off the rung below, rather than climbing up the ladder.
I don't really see how this is sustainable in the long term?
When we moved here 7 years ago, there were a handful which had extensions or loft conversions. Since then, we've had a loft conversion and single-storey extension, as have our adjoining neighbours. Our non-adjoining neighbours have added an extension (they already had a loft conversion), and [i]their adjoining neighbours have done both. In total, probably a third of the houses now have loft conversions, and there are more being started pretty much on a weekly basis.
Traditionally, people would've bought a small house or flat to start with (as we did), then moved to somewhere like this as step two (again, as we did), then moved to somewhere larger once they'd got a bit more cash and wanted a bit more space.
This last step just doesn't seem to be happening any more.
Houses in our area typically go for around £300k un-extended, and around £360k extended, which is pretty much the cost of getting the work done. Between stamp duty at 3%, estate agents' fees at around 1.5%, solicitors' fees, surveys, searches, removals, mortgage valuation fees and all the other stuff involved, we'd be looking at probably a third of the cost of the extension before we'd paid so much as a penny towards the cost of actually buying a larger house, so what's the point?
At the same time, however, there's only so long that people can keep doing this before the 3-bed house as a natural second step on the ladder has been completely replaced (around here at least) by 5 bedroom properties occupied by people who might like to move to a nicer house, but don't actually have to move for more space as their families grow. As such, even if younger people manage to scrape together the insane amounts of capital required to get on the housing ladder these days, they're faced with a shortage of properties to buy, as our level has been sat here moving our own properties up the ladder and chopping off the rung below, rather than climbing up the ladder.
I don't really see how this is sustainable in the long term?
I said this in 2000 when they were building flats by the Thames off plan for £150,000 per 2 bedroomed apartment with only a £5k holding deposit. "No way can the prices rise anymore" I said, so my then FiL took over the contract and a year later when they were finished he sold immediately for £280,000.
They are now around the £500,000+ mark
We struggled to raise the money for our house when it was £170,000 back in '98 and now they go for £700,000+ and they get snapped up, usually by young couples. I have no idea where they get the cash. I certainly could not afford even a studio in this area now.
The prices I'm talking about gets you a 3 bedroomed Victorian cottage with a kitchen extension and a loft conversion, usually a 4th bedroom and an ensuite.
They are now around the £500,000+ mark

We struggled to raise the money for our house when it was £170,000 back in '98 and now they go for £700,000+ and they get snapped up, usually by young couples. I have no idea where they get the cash. I certainly could not afford even a studio in this area now.
The prices I'm talking about gets you a 3 bedroomed Victorian cottage with a kitchen extension and a loft conversion, usually a 4th bedroom and an ensuite.
That is an interesting post. I've quite a number of colleagues and older friends with children who are doing this: extending rather than moving, and I confess that the possible implications of this process hadn't occurred to me.
I wonder what the market will look like in three or four years time? Might have a deposit by then.
I wonder what the market will look like in three or four years time? Might have a deposit by then.
It's not just those properties; people just aren't moving so much at the moment. Mortgages are hard to come by so people are making do and extending where necessary. The problem is that the very top of the market is still quite buoyant due to the influx of foreign money into London property, which does eventually filter through to the real market.
I live on a small street with 12 houses on either side (dead end due to train line), all Victorian terrace. I think it's just one other house along with me that hasn't been extended or had a loft conversion. I bought mine with a view to converting the loft should the extra space be needed, don't see myself being able to afford detached property in SW London anytime soon hence so I got the biggest place with potential for expansion I could afford without completely crippling myself financially.
Most houses on my street have been extended in some way too. In fact, ours is pretty much the only one which hasn't. We'd like to extend into the loft but as we don't actually need the space (2 people in a 3 bed 30s semi) it's not a priority and would only really be so we could have a quieter sleeping space not facing over the road.
I'm in a fairly affluent area in Essex and houses in the same range as ours are selling slowly. I've seen some really lovely Victorian semis and detached houses languish on the market for months. Part of this is because the difference in price in a very small area is huge - houses on the most desirable road of our area can be up to £200K more than a comparable house on a neighbouring road.
ETA: The owner of a 3 bed Victorian house near me (which itself is on the market for £410K despite needing a lot of work doing), built another, smaller house in the sideway which is on the market for over £300K. This new house was completed over a year ago and remains unsold. It has 1.5 bedrooms and is totally overlooked by a block of flats. It's no more than about 8.5 feet wide. I've been in it and it's tiny. The only possible benefit of buying it over a flat is that it's freehold but given the fact it was originally on the market for £390K and they've dropped the price by nearly £100K suggests they realised they were being unrealistic.
I'm in a fairly affluent area in Essex and houses in the same range as ours are selling slowly. I've seen some really lovely Victorian semis and detached houses languish on the market for months. Part of this is because the difference in price in a very small area is huge - houses on the most desirable road of our area can be up to £200K more than a comparable house on a neighbouring road.
ETA: The owner of a 3 bed Victorian house near me (which itself is on the market for £410K despite needing a lot of work doing), built another, smaller house in the sideway which is on the market for over £300K. This new house was completed over a year ago and remains unsold. It has 1.5 bedrooms and is totally overlooked by a block of flats. It's no more than about 8.5 feet wide. I've been in it and it's tiny. The only possible benefit of buying it over a flat is that it's freehold but given the fact it was originally on the market for £390K and they've dropped the price by nearly £100K suggests they realised they were being unrealistic.
Edited by Silver on Monday 16th July 19:31
Let's face it the low base rate alongside the fact that there are a lot of interest only mortgages out there is keeping the market high.
Like some of our European neighbours we are due a correction but the government are doing their upmost to stop this happening.
Prices are still over infalted compared to the average income. Something needs to give.
Like some of our European neighbours we are due a correction but the government are doing their upmost to stop this happening.
Prices are still over infalted compared to the average income. Something needs to give.
Quite a few in my road have been extended, usually due to having kids/them getting older. The real pisser for me is when they turn the garage into part of the house, then at least 2 kids per house hit driving age and you end up with a proliferation of small french dented hatchbacks cluttering the street up because each property only has one space left within the boundary.
To add to my previous post, all the houses in my street that have extended into the side return and garden in order to make a small kitchen into a large kitchen diner have sold even before the sign has been put up outside the house, but my neighbour who has done the loft only and the house and garden are perfect is having trouble selling as everyone wants the kitchen/diner.
His is on the market for far less taking this into account but no one appears to want the builders in.
His is on the market for far less taking this into account but no one appears to want the builders in.
croyde said:
To add to my previous post, all the houses in my street that have extended into the side return and garden in order to make a small kitchen into a large kitchen diner have sold even before the sign has been put up outside the house, but my neighbour who has done the loft only and the house and garden are perfect is having trouble selling as everyone wants the kitchen/diner.
His is on the market for far less taking this into account but no one appears to want the builders in.
Despite what many potential buyers might say to estate agents the vast majority do not want to do work to a property - especially if they are in the market for a family home. They just want to move in and at worst apply a lick of paint. Most buyers would have to be shown two originally identical houses back to back, one unextended/modified, the other after work had been done in order to see what could be achieved. And even then many wouldn't experience an Archimedes moment.His is on the market for far less taking this into account but no one appears to want the builders in.
So, since it's kitchens and bathrooms that sell houses, some otherwise lovely houses can stick as they are neither sufficiently bad and cheap to attract the genuine doer uppers, nor immediately attractive enough for Mr and Mrs Smith with busy lives and 2.4 children in tow.
I got a good deal on my house specifically because of this, needed a new "family" bathroom and the kitchen, whilst a good size, did need a revamp. I quite enjoyed being able to do the designs myself and I know someone that works for Wickes so kitchen and bathroom were sourced and fitted for a hell of a lot cheaper than the difference I would have paid for a done up house.
Would be interested to know if it's the same out of London though, I'd be looking at a serious bit of property if I was outside this ridiculous bubble.
Would be interested to know if it's the same out of London though, I'd be looking at a serious bit of property if I was outside this ridiculous bubble.
Use Psychology said:
unfortunately what will happen as you chop the rungs off is that the ladder will no longer have any strength, will start to wobble, and the people at the top will all fall off and hurt themselves.
This is a very common problem that is well-known in the industry.Builders are "leaned on" to provide cheap "starter homes." Within a few years, they've all been extended and nobody new to the market can afford one, so there are no "starter homes" any more.
And then the cycle has to start again
We did the same when moving up was out of our price bracket, then when stamp duty got stupid.
We started with a 2 bed, one bath, one reception bungalow. 15 years later its a 4 bed, 3 bath, 3 reception chalet bungalow.
I really can't see us moving when stamp duty costs more than a decent secondhand car.
We started with a 2 bed, one bath, one reception bungalow. 15 years later its a 4 bed, 3 bath, 3 reception chalet bungalow.
I really can't see us moving when stamp duty costs more than a decent secondhand car.
the whole market has gone to pot simply due to an undersupply of new houses and an overpriced current stock.
whats needed is a shed load of "350-400k" houses to be built to get people moving up the chain- don't build loads of s
tty cheap houses because you just end up with slums.
F-in-law lives in a lovely 19c red brick terrace house in a surrey commuter belt town. When they moved in 35 years ago (late twenties), the price was 2.5 times his salary. ON discussion we felt our salaries were roughly equitable between then and now. To buy that same house now would take 9 times my salary.
whats needed is a shed load of "350-400k" houses to be built to get people moving up the chain- don't build loads of s
tty cheap houses because you just end up with slums. F-in-law lives in a lovely 19c red brick terrace house in a surrey commuter belt town. When they moved in 35 years ago (late twenties), the price was 2.5 times his salary. ON discussion we felt our salaries were roughly equitable between then and now. To buy that same house now would take 9 times my salary.
Our Third House was in L37 which is an overpriced dormitory town 12 miles North Of Liverpool, where at one end of the town you can pay £3 or £4 Million for a moderate Footballers house. In fact Gerard lives only a mile from us.
We paid £57K in 1998 for this small 3 bed house with a shared drive and tiny garage, when I was earning £25K. I was worried about overstretching our finances, so this was possibly the cheapest in the area.
The 2 requirements I had for a house was space for a garage, and loft height, for a later extention.
When in 2000 a relative died we used the small inheritance and an extension of £6K on the Mortgage to build a 4 metre square loft room.
House prices then 'TOOK OFF'
So in 1998, the difference between a 3 bed semi and a 4 bed detatched was maybe £50K. At the Peak in 2007/8 the difference was maybe £200K.
Now my salary had risen by £10K, so there was no way we'd be able to jump to a larger house.
So, we just paid the mortgage off quicker, and saved money to give to our kids for their first deposit. I've told both kids that if they need to they can 'rent' the house off us, and we'll add a kitchen and bathroom to the loft, and live in a 'loft apartment'.
The only way I can imagine getting my double garage with a pit is for my parents and in laws to die very prematurely but nobody wants that do they .
We paid £57K in 1998 for this small 3 bed house with a shared drive and tiny garage, when I was earning £25K. I was worried about overstretching our finances, so this was possibly the cheapest in the area.
The 2 requirements I had for a house was space for a garage, and loft height, for a later extention.
When in 2000 a relative died we used the small inheritance and an extension of £6K on the Mortgage to build a 4 metre square loft room.
House prices then 'TOOK OFF'
So in 1998, the difference between a 3 bed semi and a 4 bed detatched was maybe £50K. At the Peak in 2007/8 the difference was maybe £200K.
Now my salary had risen by £10K, so there was no way we'd be able to jump to a larger house.
So, we just paid the mortgage off quicker, and saved money to give to our kids for their first deposit. I've told both kids that if they need to they can 'rent' the house off us, and we'll add a kitchen and bathroom to the loft, and live in a 'loft apartment'.
The only way I can imagine getting my double garage with a pit is for my parents and in laws to die very prematurely but nobody wants that do they .
PugwasHDJ80 said:
the whole market has gone to pot simply due to an undersupply of new houses and an overpriced current stock.
whats needed is a shed load of "350-400k" houses to be built to get people moving up the chain- don't build loads of s
tty cheap houses because you just end up with slums.
I disagree. Building more homes simply to move the market is bad planning. You are applying a long term solution to a short term problem. whats needed is a shed load of "350-400k" houses to be built to get people moving up the chain- don't build loads of s
tty cheap houses because you just end up with slums. There are a lot of reasons why the housing market is the way it is at the moment, housing supply is not one of them , IMO, the issue is a combination of uncertain/depressed salaries, lack of 100% mortgages, the seemingly insatiable demand from people who believe it's their right to own property no matter what their circumstances and high rents.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


