The EU are bored again
Author
Discussion

andyroo

Original Poster:

2,469 posts

241 months

eharding

14,648 posts

315 months

Sunday 22nd July 2012
quotequote all

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Sunday 22nd July 2012
quotequote all
eharding said:
November 2011?
Sounds more like it's Andy that's bored.

Xerstead

724 posts

209 months

Monday 23rd July 2012
quotequote all
From an article I read back then about it went deeper into the reasoning. IIRC as they put it, drinking water treats the symptoms of dehydration, it does not cure it.

Wikipedia said:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dehydration
Physiologically, dehydration, despite the name, does not simply mean loss of water, as water and solutes (mainly sodium) are usually lost in roughly equal quantities to how they exist in blood plasma.
Drinking pure water will not replace the electrolytes (salt) in your body leaving you with hypotonic dehydration.

So drinking pure water does not cure all forms of dehydration, so the ruling is correct (technically).

Mojooo

13,291 posts

211 months

Monday 23rd July 2012
quotequote all
There was a discussion about this at the time.

It was to do with health claims being made on food. A new law has come in that says you can only make health claims that are permited, so 2 guys thought they would be smart and submitted one about water preventing dehydration (or whatever it is)

The EU basically came back and said no you can't use that claim in the specified way. No big deal.

Although the papers make a mockery of the fact that it took so many professors to ocme to thatdecision isn;t it better than approving the claim and then having all the large drinks companies using it to their advantage to bend the truth and make exxagerated claims about their products?


Unfortunatley its a 'ripe' as the bendy banana story for newspapers to spout as anti EU talk.

Mojooo

13,291 posts

211 months

Monday 23rd July 2012
quotequote all
One of the posts fro mthe article:

The specific health claim tested is outlined in the ruling: The regular consumption of significant amounts of water can reduce the risk of development of dehydration and of concomitant decrease of performance. The claim wasn't submitted for a genuine product, but was created as a deliberate 'test' exercise by the two professors, who were apparently already unhappy with the European Food Standards Authority. The panel were well aware of it's absurdity too, noting drily that "the proposed risk factors," the conditions addressed by the hypothetical product, in this case water loss, "are measures or water depletion and thus are measures of the disease (dehydration)." Leaving that aside, there are two major problems with the claim: drinking water doesn't prevent dehydration, and drinking-water doesn't prevent dehydration. Firstly, "regular consumption" of water doesn't reduce the risk of dehydration any more than eating a pork pie a day reduces the risk of starvation. If I drink half a pint of bottled water while running through a desert in the blistering sun, I'll still end up dehydrated, and if I drink several bottles today, that won't prevent me from dehydrating tomorrow. The key is to drink enough water when you need it, and you're not going to get that from any bottled water product unless it's mounted on a drip. Secondly, dehydration doesn't just mean a lack of water, or 'being thirsty'; electrolytes like sodium are important too. If salt levels fall too far, the body struggles to regulate fluid levels in the first place. That's why hospitals use saline drips to prevent dehydration in patients who can't take fluids orally, and why people with diarhhoea are treated with salt-containing oral rehydration fluids. Presumably the next big investigation at the Express will expose the shocking waste of NHS money on needless quantities of saline solution, when jolly old tap water would work just as well.

andyroo

Original Poster:

2,469 posts

241 months

Monday 23rd July 2012
quotequote all
eharding said:
November 2011?
Apologies - on the mobile version it shows it as half a month old!