Google pays just £6m UK tax on revenue of £3.95bn
Google pays just £6m UK tax on revenue of £3.95bn
Author
Discussion

Fittster

Original Poster:

20,120 posts

244 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
"Anger over the amount of tax paid by Google in the UK could escalate after documents showed the web giant contributed just £6m to the exchequer in 2011 on UK revenues of £3.95bn.

The search giant reported a loss after tax of £24.1m, according to documents filed at Companies House, after it booked a £51.4m charge for share awards to its employees.

The disclosure threatens to once again raise scrutiny of Google's tax practices. The company faced criticism last year when it emerged the UK business had paid £935,000 of tax on revenues of £2.39bn.
In the six years to the end of 2010, Google paid just £8m of corporation tax in the UK, but in the 2011 calendar year, that rose to £6.09m."

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/google/94609...

Not really sure we have an effective tax system.

Jasandjules

72,690 posts

260 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Well if google is agreeing to store all our searches etc so UK Govt can spy on our activities then there must be a Quid Pro Quo - looks like we've found it...

ralphrj

4,134 posts

222 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
You don't appear to understand the difference between revenue and profit.

They are 2 completely different things.

Google actually made a loss in the UK.


Edit: You should ask the mods to amend the title to 'Google pays £6m UK tax on £18m loss'.

Defcon5

6,479 posts

222 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
ralphrj said:
Google actually made a loss in the UK.
On purpose to reduce tax liability?


Marf

22,907 posts

272 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Defcon5 said:
On purpose to reduce tax liability?
Is there any evidence to support this, or is it baseless speculation?

How much do they contribute to the exchequer through employee NI and Tax?

iphonedyou

10,425 posts

188 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Thread title needs changed quickly. It's completely misleading. Well, wrong is a better word.

ralphrj

4,134 posts

222 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Defcon5 said:
ralphrj said:
Google actually made a loss in the UK.
On purpose to reduce tax liability?
You can't make up expenses to reduce your profit (and therefore tax liability) - they have to be either real expenses or, in the case of provisions for future costs, realistic.

If they chose to pay staff bonuses to reduce their profit then the bonuses would be taxable - and at higher rate than corporation tax.

bobbylondonuk

2,206 posts

221 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
So the media gets angry over the headline tax figure, but no explanation of the accounts in detail to base their anger on.

I guess it works for the majority of the people who dont understand how accounts work. I shall pass on this topic...not really worthy of the 'anger'.

HundredthIdiot

4,477 posts

315 months

Adrian W

15,623 posts

259 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
iphonedyou said:
Thread title needs changed quickly. It's completely misleading. Well, wrong is a better word.
Why? it is completely correct, however no mention of profit, I think you would need a team of accountants to fully understand their tax return

pokethepope

2,667 posts

219 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Don't hate the player, hate the game.

Oakey

27,984 posts

247 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Marf said:
Is there any evidence to support this, or is it baseless speculation?
Why not? Hollywood does it, I mean, 30yrs on and Star Wars has yet to make a profit.

Legend83

10,595 posts

253 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Yep, bds. Shut Google down. NOW!

rolleyes

ralphrj

4,134 posts

222 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Adrian W said:
Why? it is completely correct, however no mention of profit, I think you would need a team of accountants to fully understand their tax return
It has been changed. The OP originally claimed Google paid £6m tax on £3.95bn profit.

Fittster

Original Poster:

20,120 posts

244 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
ralphrj said:
Adrian W said:
Why? it is completely correct, however no mention of profit, I think you would need a team of accountants to fully understand their tax return
It has been changed. The OP originally claimed Google paid £6m tax on £3.95bn profit.
The OP linked to a Telegraph headline.

Do you really not think Google makes a profit in the UK?

HundredthIdiot

4,477 posts

315 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
pokethepope said:
Don't hate the player, hate the game.
I'll hate both of them, if that's OK with you.

Google's tax avoision is shameful, regardless of legality. I don't even think it is legal, but the Irish govt turns a blind eye because its in their interest to do so.

ralphrj

4,134 posts

222 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Fittster said:
The OP linked to a Telegraph headline.
The OP linked to a Telegraph article which said revenue but created a topic stating profit.

Fittster said:
Do you really not think Google makes a profit in the UK?
Not according to their audited accounts (assuming that the Telegraph article is correct).

Do you have evidence that both Google and their auditors have deliberately created misleading and fraudulent accounts?

Adrian W

15,623 posts

259 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
Fittster said:
ralphrj said:
Adrian W said:
Why? it is completely correct, however no mention of profit, I think you would need a team of accountants to fully understand their tax return
It has been changed. The OP originally claimed Google paid £6m tax on £3.95bn profit.
The OP linked to a Telegraph headline.

Do you really not think Google makes a profit in the UK?
I think their consolidation is probably so complex the revenue couldn’t work it out and it’s an arbitrary amount, like BP and Vodaphone

Fittster

Original Poster:

20,120 posts

244 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
"And so with Google. The UK really is its Treasure Island. Almost from the moment it started selling advertising space on its search engine here, the revenues generated have been more than 10% of its total – the only country in the world where that’s the case. You can find out for yourself on Google’s financials page, which goes back to 2004 (when it first began detailing results). For the most recent quarter, announced last week, the UK made up 11% of revenue; the US was only 47%.

That amazing concentration of internet activity here means Google UK will easily overtake ITV as the biggest recipient of advertising expenditure this year; it’s on course to be worth much more than £2.4bn at current growth rates. Not that ITV is hanging about, but our analysis – which includes the confounding element of “traffic acquisition costs” (TAC), or how much it costs Google to get the adverts or how much it has to pay partners – already allows for that.

TAC, by the way, is a large part of why Microsoft is losing money hand over fist with its Bing search engine: last year it was spending roughly for every of advertising it got. Google, by contrast, has pushed TAC down to 25 cents per . That might be partly why Microsoft loses roughly 0m every quarter on Bing, while Google is cruising past bn per quarter.

Even better for Google is that this sceptred isle is probably much more profitable for it than the US operation: it doesn’t have a huge headquarters with endlessly circulating electric buses (though it does have two nice offices near London’s Victoria station) and it doesn’t require server farms to work across huge distances as in the US. We’re a high-spending, highly connected country with a lot of people who speak the same language as its home country. Perhaps the surprise is that we’re only 11% of its revenue.

http://www.psfk.com/2011/04/why-does-google-make-m...


Really not making any money in the UK or hiding behind accountancy. If the country is broke, then revenue needs to be acquired form operating here. If they don't make any profit I'm sure they would object to being blocked.

HundredthIdiot

4,477 posts

315 months

Wednesday 8th August 2012
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
In the case of Google, revenues generated by serving ads to UK ip addresses plus revenue generated from intellectual property developed by UK-domiciled engineers minus a share of costs proportional to the size of that UK market.

As a first approximation.