Economist: Worlds most livable cities seem boring
Discussion
Once again the Economist has come out with its survey of the world's most livable cities.
http://www.cnngo.com/explorations/life/worlds-most...
Here are the top 10
(1) Melbourne
(2) Vienna
(3) Vancouver
(4) Toronto
(5) Calgary
(6) Adelaide
(7) Sydney
(8) Helsinki
(9) Perth
(10)Auckland
Now, I understand all the criteria, crime, transportation etc, but I wish they had one more additional mark for BORINGNESS...
I live in one of them and have been to most (Toronto- moderately boring)
I would rate them as:
Mebourne - boring
Vienna- sleepily boring
Vancouver-slightly boring
Toronto-moderately boring
Calgary-crashingly boring
Adelaide..no idea (sounds boring)
Sydney..not so boring
Helsinki-numbingly boring
Perth-probably boring
Auckland-possibly boring
Compared to living in big cities like London or NY, or small and very interesting smaller places like Montreal, Berlin, the tradeoff of safety and convenience seems pretty steep to me
.......
http://www.cnngo.com/explorations/life/worlds-most...
Here are the top 10
(1) Melbourne
(2) Vienna
(3) Vancouver
(4) Toronto
(5) Calgary
(6) Adelaide
(7) Sydney
(8) Helsinki
(9) Perth
(10)Auckland
Now, I understand all the criteria, crime, transportation etc, but I wish they had one more additional mark for BORINGNESS...
I live in one of them and have been to most (Toronto- moderately boring)
I would rate them as:
Mebourne - boring
Vienna- sleepily boring
Vancouver-slightly boring
Toronto-moderately boring
Calgary-crashingly boring
Adelaide..no idea (sounds boring)
Sydney..not so boring
Helsinki-numbingly boring
Perth-probably boring
Auckland-possibly boring
Compared to living in big cities like London or NY, or small and very interesting smaller places like Montreal, Berlin, the tradeoff of safety and convenience seems pretty steep to me
.......I've been to quite a few of these and concur, boring, not only is Perth boring it's about 2000miles away from any other big town or city. But then I wouldn't want to live in a cess pitt like London, Delhi, Beijing or New York either. Country boy me.
I'd pick Oslo as my favourite city.
I'd pick Oslo as my favourite city.
Only been to a couple on the list, but on that list many are at times too hot (Perth) or too cold (Calgary, Helsinki and Toronto), the local wildlife isn't pleasant (Perth, Adelaide, Sydney and Melbourne) and isn't Auckland pretty close to a major fault line and at risk of a large tsunami?
Then maybe extreme temperature, venomous creatures and geological dangers weren't considered in the selection.
Then maybe extreme temperature, venomous creatures and geological dangers weren't considered in the selection.
steviegunn said:
Only been to a couple on the list, but on that list many are at times too hot (Perth) or too cold (Calgary, Helsinki and Toronto), the local wildlife isn't pleasant (Perth, Adelaide, Sydney and Melbourne) and isn't Auckland pretty close to a major fault line and at risk of a large tsunami?
There are major faults that run the length of NZ, but Auckland's main issue is it's surrounded by volcanoes. I think Auckland is great.The problem with these sorts of reports is that they look at certain aspects of life and rate them from their perspective. In this case they rate the cities on:
Stability
Healthcare
Culture and environment
Education
Infrastructure
Whether those things are good or bad depends on who you are - if you live in a city with great public transport but you prefer your car and are taxed inside out to pay for things you don't use, you might not agree with their findings!
Stability
Healthcare
Culture and environment
Education
Infrastructure
Whether those things are good or bad depends on who you are - if you live in a city with great public transport but you prefer your car and are taxed inside out to pay for things you don't use, you might not agree with their findings!
After hearing how nice Vancouver is from a few people, I found there was not too much to do there. The views up to the mountains and its overall location are fantasic but there was never much going on. Calgary was sterile and being surrounded bythe praries does it no favours what so ever. Loved Sydney however.
Surely it just depends on what you like to do for fun. I've never been to a city I would say was intrinsically boring. I've met plenty of people with so little imagination as to find lots of places boring though 
Edit: also as a visitor to a city I don't tend to assume there's nothing going on just because I can't find out easily what's going on. I think a lot of us underestimate the value of local knowledge and word-of-mouth.

Edit: also as a visitor to a city I don't tend to assume there's nothing going on just because I can't find out easily what's going on. I think a lot of us underestimate the value of local knowledge and word-of-mouth.
Edited by ewenm on Thursday 16th August 08:57
The idea that you can produce objective criteria about "liveability" is complete and utter nonsense.
You have to adapt yourself to the city you live in.
Some people have very specific needs, like wheelchair access to lap dancing clubs, but those cannot possibly be captured in a bunch of statistics.
You have to adapt yourself to the city you live in.
Some people have very specific needs, like wheelchair access to lap dancing clubs, but those cannot possibly be captured in a bunch of statistics.
Mmmm, been to these cities?
Helsinki is many things, boring it is NOT. Worked for Finnish companies for many years and its a fascinating place. And they do a cracking night out...!
And Vienna - well, I can tell you of a few nights out there that involved champagne bars, being chased down the road by some big Russians and the rest is a bit of a blur. Boring? Hardly.
Helsinki is many things, boring it is NOT. Worked for Finnish companies for many years and its a fascinating place. And they do a cracking night out...!
And Vienna - well, I can tell you of a few nights out there that involved champagne bars, being chased down the road by some big Russians and the rest is a bit of a blur. Boring? Hardly.
I've spent a little bit of time in Perth, Sydney and Auckland on my travels. Perth was all very nice, but it's in the middle of bloody nowhere, so you're more or less stuck there unless you fly. I think you'd very quickly feel isolated were you to live there. Of the other two, I'd probably put Auckland above Sydney simply because I just found NZ a much nicer place generally. People seemed more relaxed, the climate is more reasonable, you have some stunning country on your doorstep and best of all, the wildlife isn't lethal! Given the choice of living in any of the three, I'd pick Auckland. That said, it's still a pretty small place by global standards, especially if you're used to London, so might get boring after a while. What you make it I suppose, but for all its problems, you could never accuse London of being dull.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




tty list. 




