Tony Nicklinson Loses High Court Right-To-Die Case
Tony Nicklinson Loses High Court Right-To-Die Case
Author
Discussion

Stedman

Original Poster:

7,475 posts

223 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
Pretty moving interview too.

Mods - I do hope you agree with it being here. Thanks

scenario8

8,008 posts

210 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
Such a sad case. I have always been minded to side towards the rights of the individual to choose - but obviously I can see the pitfalls.

I just hope to God (in an admittedly entirely very selfish way) I am never personally caught up in such a case and having to make decisions were they availbale to me. I can't possibly perceive how I would feel if it was my wife or one of our kids involved.

Newc

2,197 posts

213 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
The Court did the right thing. Their point is that Mr Nicklinson would be unable to take his own life – someone else would actively have to do something, which constitutes murder, and it is not the role of the courts to alter the law to make that permissible, it has to be Parliament.

However, we are clearly at a point in medical development where people can be kept alive indefinitely against their will. The law does need to be altered to allow people to exercise their choice to die. I fear that Mr Nicklinson will see an ECHR appeal under Family Life or Torture sections as a quicker approach than campaigning for legislative change, which is the right outcome for him but the wrong outcome for broader society.

Unfortunately, given the instant nonsense being offered by the religious goons – sample quote “Compassion and solidarity are the humane and caring responses to locked-in syndrome” – a sensible approach to legislative change does seem to be a long way away.



Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
On the BBC News webpage there was a picture of a placard at a demo saying 'Free Assange'.

Below was the story of Nicklinson. The thought that crossed my mind was that I'd go along with Free Nicklinson.

I too can see the problems but this is a specific case. I don't think the state has the right to punish this man furhter.

Stedman

Original Poster:

7,475 posts

223 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
Newc said:
I believeThe Court did the right thing. Their point is that Mr Nicklinson would be unable to take his own life – someone else would actively have to do something, which constitutes murder, and it is not the role of the courts to alter the law to make that permissible, it has to be Parliament.
EFA smile

There really does need to be legislative change. It's such a shame this can't be viewed on a case-by-case basis.


FurtiveFreddy

8,577 posts

268 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
I hope when those judges go home tonight they think very carefully about how their lives would be if they were in the same position as Mr Nicklinson.

It's time the law was changed to take into account special cases such as this. Why should a judge have the right to sentence an innocent man to a life of torture?

Soovy

35,829 posts

302 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
On the BBC News webpage there was a picture of a placard at a demo saying 'Free Assange'.

Below was the story of Nicklinson. The thought that crossed my mind was that I'd go along with Free Nicklinson.

I too can see the problems but this is a specific case. I don't think the state has the right to punish this man furhter.
I agree.

Legally of course the decision is correct, and it must be Parliament alone which makes such changes to the Law, and yet............



Poor poor b stards. I weep for them.

ewenm

28,506 posts

276 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
FurtiveFreddy said:
I hope when those judges go home tonight they think very carefully about how their lives would be if they were in the same position as Mr Nicklinson.

It's time the law was changed to take into account special cases such as this. Why should a judge have the right to sentence an innocent man to a life of torture?
It is time the law changed. It is not the job of judges to change the law though; it's the job of parliament. Lobby your MP.

Blue62

10,587 posts

183 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
Newc said:
The Court did the right thing. Their point is that Mr Nicklinson would be unable to take his own life – someone else would actively have to do something, which constitutes murder, and it is not the role of the courts to alter the law to make that permissible, it has to be Parliament.

However, we are clearly at a point in medical development where people can be kept alive indefinitely against their will. The law does need to be altered to allow people to exercise their choice to die. I fear that Mr Nicklinson will see an ECHR appeal under Family Life or Torture sections as a quicker approach than campaigning for legislative change, which is the right outcome for him but the wrong outcome for broader society.

Unfortunately, given the instant nonsense being offered by the religious goons – sample quote “Compassion and solidarity are the humane and caring responses to locked-in syndrome” – a sensible approach to legislative change does seem to be a long way away.
Good post, can't disagree with any of that, whatever one feels for this poor man, it's not really a matter for the courts, but surely now something has to change.

Soovy

35,829 posts

302 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all

NewC said:
we are clearly at a point in medical development where people can be kept alive indefinitely against their will
Indeed, and I cannot fathom any worse torture than that.

Poor b stards.

DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
Newc said:
The Court did the right thing. Their point is that Mr Nicklinson would be unable to take his own life – someone else would actively have to do something, which constitutes murder, and it is not the role of the courts to alter the law to make that permissible, it has to be Parliament.

However, we are clearly at a point in medical development where people can be kept alive indefinitely against their will. The law does need to be altered to allow people to exercise their choice to die. I fear that Mr Nicklinson will see an ECHR appeal under Family Life or Torture sections as a quicker approach than campaigning for legislative change, which is the right outcome for him but the wrong outcome for broader society.

Unfortunately, given the instant nonsense being offered by the religious goons – sample quote “Compassion and solidarity are the humane and caring responses to locked-in syndrome” – a sensible approach to legislative change does seem to be a long way away.
On the contrary, the judges did the wrong thing I would say, in the opinion of most people.

They may have made a correct decision under the current law but we all know what that's worth.


rhinochopig

17,932 posts

229 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
FurtiveFreddy said:
I hope when those judges go home tonight they think very carefully about how their lives would be if they were in the same position as Mr Nicklinson.

It's time the law was changed to take into account special cases such as this. Why should a judge have the right to sentence an innocent man to a life of torture?
As Newc says above I don't think it's within the judges power to sanction assisted suicide. The law needs to be changed and it should have been a while back if it wasn't for the religious aholes in the House of Lords that blocked it. Those are the people to which any ire should be directed; the fking clowns whose imaginary friend tells them it's wrong to let someone end their own life.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/4763067.stm

scenario8

8,008 posts

210 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
Where's a modern day David Steel going to come from (and be re-selected and re-elected)?

omgus

7,305 posts

206 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
I genuinely feel for the bloke and hope that he gets his desire to die fulfilled soon. If i was in his position i would feel the same but as said it is a parlimentary issue.

If it was a horse/dog/cat/hamster and we kept it alive like this there would be outcry and someone would step in to stop the "suffering" a human should be afforded the same right.

FurtiveFreddy

8,577 posts

268 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
"Lawyers acting for Mr Nicklinson, who suffered a catastrophic stroke in 2005, argued for an extension to the common law defence of ‘necessity’ for murder because the alternative – forcing him to stay alive – is worse."

Does this not mean that the judges could have set legal precedent without a change in the law through Parliament?

Why take it to the High Court if there would be zero chance of winning?

I do understand the law is in Parliament's remit, but judges are there to interpret the laws and their interpretation can and do go against previous rulings, so they do hold some of the responsibility.

Anyway, we've had enough of these cases now. Change required please.

Newc

2,197 posts

213 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all

ewenm said:
Lobby your MP.
This, absolutely. If you feel strongly about this – and you should, these are random events which could happen to you, me, your spouse, or your children – then write to your MP. Make sure that they understand that you do not expect the desires of people with whom you have no relationship to override your best interests on religious grounds. Tell your MP that you expect them to support a change in the legislation.

whirligig

941 posts

226 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
Just watching the interview now with his wife and him on BBC News 24 - poor guy is absolutely heartbroken.

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
I can't see the house of lords giving the right to die of someone with no visble sign of life

scenario8

8,008 posts

210 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
I can't see the house of lords giving the right to die of someone with no visble sign of life
Au contraire, if they ever get round to even mild reform of the Upper House we might have to rely on the Lords to present such a Bill. Not that I'd count on the support of the Lords Spiritual, of course.

Otherwise, like mentioned above, we're going to have to wait for a big balls modern day David Steel who's prepared to be dragged through the mire and probably not get himself/herself re-elected. And for a governemnt to have the balls to allow parliamentary time on the matter and a free vote. let's see how long the wait takes.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Thursday 16th August 2012
quotequote all


Is possibly the best argument against this. His disability is as bad as Nicklinson's, and getting worse, but he has a very productive life. Suggesting that being disabled like this is a valid reason to have someone killed is very dangerous; especially considering that said persons can only communicate with the help of others.